Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 02/2/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
WASHINGTON -- I suppose it's very nice for Mike Tyson, who was convicted of rape in 1992, that he's getting what he calls his "dream job" -- acting on Law & Order: SVU. The show's fans aren't quite as happy about it and have started a petition to ask NBC to cast someone else in the upcoming episode's role of a man with a troubled childhood who's now on death row.
Tyson's casting on a show that revolves around advocacy and justice for assault victims has sparked a debate about what opportunities people deserve after serving time for a violent crime and what constitutes an attempt at restitution. We probably won't get good answers to these questions with a debate over SVU. But if showrunner Warren Leight really wanted, as he said on Twitter, "to provoke discussion and awareness" by casting Tyson, it's useful to think about whether this is the best route to that goal -- or to good television.
Tyson's paid his debt to society and deserves a chance to work in his chosen profession, which is acting. But it's not as if the man lacks for opportunities. The director, James Toback, has featured Tyson as himself in his features When Will I Be Loved and Black and White, and he examined Tyson's life in a documentary that premiered at Cannes in 2008. Tyson's been in both Hangover movies, and Spike Lee produced Tyson's one-man show, Undisputed Truth, which got a Broadway run -- an exceedingly rare opportunity. I don't really think there's any question that Tyson has gotten a fair shot to pursue work in the entertainment industry, even if we're applying a heightened standard to compensate for the idea that there's employment discrimination against people who have been incarcerated.
As for Law & Order, the franchise has a rich history of famous guest stars. Generally, when celebrities play themselves, it's to integrate the events of the show into the real world of New York, as has been the case with cameos by the city's mayors. Otherwise, major actors are normally cast in roles that shake up our conception of their talents, as Cynthia Nixon did by playing a woman faking mental illness as part of an elaborate vengeance plot in 2007.
As a potentially sympathetic killer, it doesn't sound as if Tyson will be bringing local cred or fading into an out-of-the-box role -- and the worry is that the character's proximity to Tyson's life story will somehow whitewash his crimes.
Leight better hope that casting Tyson in this part really does lend life experience to the show and deepen the episode. Otherwise, it's SVU handing over its credibility to someone who still hasn't earned it.
-- Bloomberg News
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 2, 2013 E3
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Judge nixes Teresa Giudice's halfway house bid
Cat Deeley to host P&G Beauty Awards
Former Real Housewife rejoining the reality fold
Stop denying, start adapting to global-warming disasters
'Fascinating' change of plans: Walters will return
Teresa Giudice asks to serve term in halfway house
Networks encourage fans to watch competitors
'Disgraced' star Josh Radnor 'a 24-hour thinker'
'Snowpiercer' among new DVDs
Paul Gross among Screenie honourees
'Stalker' star Maggie Q loves acting - and privacy
'SNL' adds black woman to cast from writers room
'The Millers' Beau Bridges: 'Comedy is tough'
Computer hackers new go-to heroes in Hollywood
'Buffy the Vampire Slayer' actor arrested in Idaho
TV pilot based on Chris Hadfield in the works
NBC's Snyderman faces credibility issues
MP & Silva keeps Serie A world TV rights to 2018
Today on TV
On the road to rock
'Letterman' cue card man fired for colleague clash
TV Blog Buzz: Explaining the 'Walking Dead' phenomenon
NASCAR star splits time between dancing, driving
Nixon comes alive in a new show from Harry Shearer
Hip-hop improv group takes riffs to TV
Allison Tolman sad not to return to 'Fargo'
Canada shops TV series, films at giant MIPCOM
Keanu kills as John Wick
Grohl's challenge to band results in TV series
TV pioneer and sitcom king Norman Lear pens book
CBS debuts stand-alone streaming service
They really were The Wonder Years
TV picks of the week