Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Miniseries will give you sinking feeling
If nothing else, it can be fairly said that Global TV's new Titanic miniseries is true to the theme of the story it endeavours to tell.
It is, pretty much, a disaster.
As ambitious and well-intended as it is, this four-part dramatization of history's worst maritime calamity is a clumsy, clunky affair that seems so concerned with providing a properly stiff-lipped, Upstairs, Downstairs-style insight into the class system that governed British society in the early 20th century that it completely misses the mark in terms of portraying the emotional and organizational chaos of the tragedy.
And given all the other programming available on various channels in the lead-up to the 100th anniversary (April 15) of Titanic's sinking -- not to mention the Oscar-winning James Cameron blockbuster that stands as the definitive dramatic treatment of the event -- this tepid offering feels rather redundant and pointless.
This new Titanic, an international co-production led by Britain's ITV, Canada's Global TV and U.S.-based ABC, takes an unconventional approach to telling the familiar story, using each of its four episodes to examine events leading up to the sinking from the perspective of a different slice of the shipboard population.
Sunday's opener focuses mainly on the upper-class folk, led by the Earl and Countess of Manton (Linus Roache and Geraldine Somerville), who occupy Titanic's first-class cabins and are simply appalled by the notion that they might spend even the most fleeting of moments in the company of second- and third-class passengers.
There's even a great amount of unease among the aristocrats that they're sharing top-deck accommodations with the unsophisticated likes of American financiers and, perish the thought, film actresses. Still, the upper-class dining, dancing and gaiety continue right up until the moment the ship and the iceberg meet.
Episode 2 concerns itself more with the goings-on in second and third (steerage) class, as well as the interactions of various crew members. As is the case in the première, the script is peppered with snippets of conversation that not-very-subtly foreshadow what we all know is coming.
A discussion of cost-cutting during Titanic's construction leads one puffed-up financier to observe, "You're being stubborn -- we'll never need lifeboats for every passenger," and, later in the same heated conversation, "If liners sink at all, they take a very long time about it -- more than enough for other boats to reach them."
The stiff and unwieldy dialogue is matched by Titanic's overall production values, which rely heavily on digital effects to create the illusion -- not very effectively -- that the scenes are being acted out aboard a massive ship.
None of it is convincing, so the entirety of this Titanic effort is likely to sink quickly from view as audiences abandon ship long before the inevitable conclusion.
-- -- --
Getting Bent: The sitcom genre has always embraced the notion of unlikely romance between mismatched partners, but it has seldom thrown together two less-destined lovers than Alex and Pete.
Alex (Amanda Peet) is a high-strung single-mom lawyer who's still stinging from a recent divorce, and Pete (David Walton) is a scruffy, surfer/slacker layabout who passes himself off as a home-renovation contractor in order to make ends meet.
She wants nothing to do with love or lust or casual hookups; he'll sleep with anything that moves even remotely in his romantic direction.
But she needs a kitchen reno. And he needs a paycheque. So as completely Bent as it seems, this new NBC sitcom (which premieres tonight at 8) throws them headlong toward each other. And, of course, sparks fly.
It's illogical and almost unbelievable (but hey, so were Sam and Diane on Cheers), but there's an undeniable chemistry between Peet and Walton that might inspire many of those who sample Bent's first episode to give this dislike-at-first-sight coupling another chance.
Ain't love -- even when it makes no sense at all -- grand?
TV REVIEW
Titanic
Starring Linus Roache and Geraldine Somerville
Tonight at 9
Global
2 stars out of 5
Bent
Starring Amanda Peet and David Walton
Tonight at 8
NBC
3 stars out of 5
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition March 21, 2012 D3
More TV
- Back to Top
- Return to TV
Poll
Most Popular TV
- Biopic reveals tarnish underneath gilded life
- Catching up with Arrested Development's Bluth family
- 'So much story' for cult comedy reboot
- TV Blog Buzz: 'Amazing Race Canada' spoilers leaking, 'The Office' shuts down
- Cuts force CBC TV to cross content lines
- Handyman Challenge auditions coming to Winnipeg
- TV Listings
- Jewel's music experience comes in handy for key part in Lifetime's 'Ring of Fire'
- Glee's Lea Michele telling audition stories
- 'Idol' upended as TV's top show and CBS strengthens its lead as traditional TV season ends
- Traditional TV season becoming outdated before your eyes
- Report identifies 4 types of multi-screen multi-taskers, what type are you?
- Singer Kellie Pickler and pro partner Derek Hough named 'Dancing With the Stars' champions
- CBC warns of lawsuit over government efforts to control salary negotiations
- Handyman Challenge auditions coming to Winnipeg
- TV Listings
- He's been taking funny seriously for 60 years
- TV Blog Buzz: 'Amazing Race Canada' spoilers leaking, 'The Office' shuts down
- Fans' patience is rewarded at last: 'Arrested Development' will be reborn Sunday on Netflix
- 'Dancing With the Stars' pro Derek Hough looks to balance outside opportunities with the show
- 'Young and the Restless' star Jeanne Cooper dies at 84
- Winnipegger's video could net $10K from Ellen
- Actor Simon Helberg says to expect cliffhanger from 'Big Bang Theory' finale
- Controversy swirls over Jillian's win on the first-ever 'Big Brother Canada'
- Traditional TV season becoming outdated before your eyes
- Y&R broadcasting tribute to Cooper
- Not Howe... why?: Winnipeg-shot story about beloved hockey legend misses the net by a mile
- NBC appoints Seth Meyers as Jimmy Fallon's late-night replacement; premiere date not yet set
- TV Listings
- Big Brother Canada victory tainted by mistaken vote
- 'Entourage' star Jeremy Piven plays famed London retailer Harry Selfridge in new PBS series
- Champion Man United earns Premier League-record $93M from broadcasters for season
- Fans' patience is rewarded at last: 'Arrested Development' will be reborn Sunday on Netflix
- 'Young and the Restless' star Jeanne Cooper dies at 84
- 'The Young and the Restless' to air tribute to its late leading lady, Jeanne Cooper, on May 28
- Actor Simon Helberg says to expect cliffhanger from 'Big Bang Theory' finale
- Y&R broadcasting tribute to Cooper
- Winnipegger's video could net $10K from Ellen
- Controversy swirls over Jillian's win on the first-ever 'Big Brother Canada'
- ABC News veteran Barbara Walters to announce her retirement on Monday's edition of 'The View'
- 'Entourage' star Jeremy Piven plays famed London retailer Harry Selfridge in new PBS series
- These aren't the funny pages
- Not Howe... why?: Winnipeg-shot story about beloved hockey legend misses the net by a mile
Ads by Google












You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.