10°c Clear
18°c Sunny
Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Bin Laden story actually not very dramatic
Book review
The Finish
The Killing of Osama Bin Laden
- By Mark Bowden
- Atlantic Monthly Press, 266 pages, $30.50
No Easy Day
The Autobiography of a Navy SEAL: The Firsthand Account of the Mission That Killed Osama bin Laden
- By Mark Owen
- Dutton, 316 pages, $27.50
THESE two American non-fiction books, one pure reportage, the other a memoir of sorts, tell the story of the operation that killed al-Qaida leader Osama bin Laden last May and the long preparation that led to its success.
The problem that Mark Bowden and Mark Owen share is that they choose to tell a story that is not very dramatic at all. Both Bowden and Owen all but admit as much, attributing a lot of the outcome to luck and indicating that for the SEALs this type of mission was routine.
Bowden’s is the more interesting account, focusing on the intelligence effort and the White House’s renewed push to find bin Laden. He describes this as a slow "grind" of data-gathering rather than an exciting spy saga.
Bowden, a journalist and author of the 1999 prize winner Black Hawk Down, benefited from exclusive access to President Barack Obama to tell this story, and it is interesting to learn about the president’s deliberations that led to his decision to go ahead with the raid. At times though, Obama’s remarks seem like prepared statements of justification rather than a frank discussion about life and death decisions.
Obama’s most important judgment was to simply refocus the hunt for bin Laden. He made it a top intelligence priority — something that the George W. Bush administration lost sight of while dealing with the invasion of two countries.
Mark Owen (a pseudonym), writing with Kevin Maurer, offers a dry and poorly told story of the life of a frogman in SEAL team six. Indeed, who thought elite commandos could be this boring?
It appears that Owen is a bit of a spotlight-grabber. He was a team leader during the mission, and his job on the day was to clear a secondary building. After completing his primary task, he quickly found himself at the front of the queue to clear the third floor of the main building where the SEALs suspected their target to be living.
Owen gives a brief but clear version of how the orders for the mission were to detain bin Laden if possible, especially if he did not resist. In the heat of the moment, he forgets these orders, and he recounts how an unarmed bin Laden was shot once at distance and finished with shots at close range.
After matter-of-factly describing how he fired bullets into bin Laden’s supine body, Owen later says he was "shocked" to find how neat and organized the clothes in the nearby dresser were. Owen also explains that he had no respect for his victim, since he did not attempt to defend himself.
If you are looking for deep introspection about the legalities of state-sanctioned revenge killing or the use of appropriate force, you won’t find it in either of these books.
Matthew E. Havens served in the Canadian military for 10 years. He is a research associate with the Institute of Urban Studies at the University of Winnipeg.
More Books
- Back to Top
- Return to Books
More Books
(1 of 30 articles for this week)
Publisher: Sen. Elizabeth Warren has book deal; release planned for spring 2014
05/22/2013 5:12 PM 0
Poll
Most Popular Books
- Penguin Canada promotes Khaled Hosseini's new book with the Echo Project
- 'Inferno' by Dan Brown tops Maclean's fiction list
- PAPER CHASE: Give grad the gift of penny-pinching
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- Khaled Hosseini discusses novel, "And the Mountains Echoed," at NY reading; book spans decades
- Review: 'And the Mountains Echoed,' Khaled Hosseini's new book, is another tear-jerker
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Political stories entertaining, thought provoking
- PAPER CHASE: Williams expands rehab lessons
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- First edition 'Harry Potter' book, with JK Rowling's notes and drawings, sold for $228,000
- PAPER CHASE: Give grad the gift of penny-pinching
- Political stories entertaining, thought provoking
- CHILDREN'S BOOKS: First novel tribute to power of books
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- Review: 'And the Mountains Echoed,' Khaled Hosseini's new book, is another tear-jerker
- Ultimate fighter learns from fear
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- Drunk Mom covers booze, but not the baby
- A long, dangerous road: Refugees share their journeys from Africa to Manitoba
- Cosmologist fights to bring real time back into physics
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- In the end, they knew what they were fighting against
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Hookup culture killing romance with sex
- Mommy drinks because you cry!
- Ultimate fighter learns from fear
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- First edition 'Harry Potter' book, with JK Rowling's notes and drawings, sold for $228,000
- Ultimate fighter learns from fear
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- Corporate control main problem with GMOs
- Less is more: Danish chef Trine Hahnemann promotes sustainable, seasonal eating
- Mommy drinks because you cry!
- SUSPENSE: Original European sleuth deserves wider audience
- Pat Conroy memoir about his father, 'The Death of Santini,' coming out in October
- Fascinating story of Canadian-U.S. differences
- A killer of a day really may be one
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.