Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 04/5/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 04/5/2014 8:08 AM | Updates
In 1960, 24-year-old Jane Goodall arrived in Tanzania to study chimpanzees.
Sent by British scientist Louis Leakey, the former secretary initially had to be chaperoned by her mother. Goodall later obtained a PhD from Cambridge University in ethology, a branch of zoology that studies animal behaviour, based on the her work at the Gombe Stream National Park.
Goodall began by studying our closest relatives, discovering their propensity for using tools and hunting small mammals for meat. These were startling revelations in their day, since it was believed that using tools was a human trait and that chimpanzees were vegetarian.
More than five decades later, Goodall is still far from home, and still part of the conversation about what it means to be human.
The octogenarian spends 300 days a year on the road, lecturing on conservation and raising funds for both the Jane Goodall Institute, which funds ongoing research at Gombe, as well as Roots and Shoots, a global youth-education program.
This spring sees the publication of her 25th book, Seeds of Hope: Wisdom and Wonder from the World of Plants, the third book she's co-written with journalist and former spirituality editor for Amazon.com, Gail Hudson.
Refreshingly, Goodall is upfront about her credentials: "Of course I am best known... for the study of the Gombe chimpanzees... But there would be no chimpanzees without plants -- not human beings either, for that matter. And the chimpanzee might never have materialized for me had I not been obsessed, as a child, with stories of the wilderness areas of the planet and, most especially, the forests of Africa."
And so, in Seeds of Hope Goodall (and her co-writer) describes her specific history while also presenting a brief history of the different kinds of plants and trees, and how they have been cultivated over time. Goodall relies heavily on stories from the environmental and community groups she works with.
She also delivers a handful of big ideas with her anecdotes: Organic food is healthiest, the effects of GMOs on humans aren't fully known, mono-cultures aren't sustainable over the long term, we need our forests to be fully human.
All these big ideas bear repeating; the problem with Goodall's approach to these issues, however, is that readers aren't left with a big picture. The material hopscotches geographically between England and Africa, the two poles of Goodall's life, with stops nearly everywhere her tour bus has paused in between -- but there's very little cohesion.
Also, although Goodall is reliably charming, the sections that include material outside of her first-hand experience and/or limited areas of expertise feel like they were written by an inexperienced speechwriter.
It should come as no surprise, then, that Goodall and her collaborators were accused of plagiarism last year by the Washington Post after the American edition was released.
Goodall subsequently apologized and pledged to work with editors to correct future editions. Potential readers will be glad to hear the Canadian edition has received a relatively thorough going-over.
But even that last-minute tinkering wasn't enough to save Seeds of Hope; though its authors are earnest, the book isn't half as compelling as it should be.
Those looking for a local equivalent should dip into The Global Forest by Ontario-based botanist Diana Beresford-Kroeger, who is also interested in working with storytelling and environmental advocacy.
J.B. MacKinnon's The Once and Future World: Nature As It Was, As It Is, As It Could Be, shortlisted for this year's Charles Taylor Prize for non-fiction, is also worth a read as it digs into the archeological record and challenges some of the assumptions underlying the main tenets of conservation.
Ariel Gordon is a Winnipeg writer who once considered a career in science journalism.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition April 5, 2014 A1
Updated on Saturday, April 5, 2014 at 8:08 AM CDT: Tweaks formatting.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
WALL STREET JOURNAL-BEST SELLERS
USA TODAY Bestsellers
PUBLISHERS WEEKLY Bestsellers
Taste Canada, Food Bloggers launch new award
Charles Koch working on business book, scheduled for October
400-year-old books stolen in Italy are found in California
Former NYT executive editor Jill Abramson has book deal
Julianne Moore to be interviewed at second annual BookCon
Connecticut town pursues museum honouring Maurice Sendak
'The Girl on the Train' tops Maclean's fiction list
The top 10 books on Apple's iBooks-US
NAC Orchestra to tackle Alice Munro
Nick Hornby's 'Funny Girl' takes readers to 1960s London
Convict in murder plot that inspired 'Blind Faith' book dies
Book Review: Lippman deals with parenthood in 'Hush Hush'
Book review: Kim Gordon is more than just a 'Girl in a Band'
Winnipeg intersection inspires dark tales
Alzheimer's, dementia studies offer more questions than answers
Hollywood crock-buster: From detox programs to v-steams, celebs are steering us wrong
About a girl: Hornby's latest novel in turns frustrating, satisfying
LeCraw's latest a charming, escapist love story
In Conversation with Christine Fischer Guy
Tale of hope, promise not just for the birds
On the Night Table: Vycki Atallah
Debut Swedish thriller easily stays afloat
Wonders of life fêted in Tyler's latest
Hasiuk's teenagers endure tough times
Gaiman's collection of stories an uneven but captivating lot
New in Paper