12°c Overcast
17°c Cloudy with showers
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Tale about loss can't meet promise of debut novel
Book review
The Forgetting Tree
- By Tatjana Soli
- St. Martin's Press, 404 pages, $30
SPANNING nearly two decades, this sophomore novel by California writer Tatjana Soli (The Lotus Eaters) is a flawed contemporary tale about loss, change and displacement in the intertwined lives of Claire Baumsarg, a middle-aged rancher and her companion.
At the outset, Claire's 10-year-old son is abducted and brutally slain. The family never fully recovers from the tragedy. After Claire and her husband split up, she devotes her life to running the ranch with much success.
Fast forward 15 years. Claire develops breast cancer and hires a caregiver to help her get through the treatment. Enter Minna, a charming Halle Berry look-alike whom Claire's daughter briefly met at a coffee shop.
Caribbean born-Minna is a PhD student at Berkeley, but wants to take a break from her courses. As well, she is the great-granddaughter of Claire's favourite author, Jean Rhys, who wrote the novel The Wide Sargasso Sea, a prequel to Jane Eyre.
Intrigued by Minna's connection with Rhys, Claire hires the young woman on the spot without asking for references. Bad idea. Minna turns into the caregiver from hell, yet Claire refuses to fire her. To say more would reveal spoilers from the plot.
The book's title refers to a ritual whereby African slaves circled a tree several times to allow them to forget memories of their home country.
For both Minna and Claire, the title is ironic. Minna never quite forgets her life back home, nor can Claire erase memories of her murdered son.
Soli is at her best at portraying the family dynamics in the aftermath of the tragedy. At the same time, she vividly captures the physicality of the farm in cinematic prose, as when Claire witnesses a fire on the ranch.
"Black smoke formed itself into the unforgiving blue sky," Soli writes. "A single, wide lick of flame reached from ground to topmost branch, a reversed lightning. Leaves dried out, then curled to gold, then black ash. The rinds of lemons grew rigid and tight, then burst, releasing a thick blood of juice."
The novel is divided into four parts. The opening section gives the impression of a domestic story about the aftermath of the son's abduction, its impact on the family and Claire's growing attachment to the farm.
However, the next section of 200-plus pages veers off in an entirely different direction, overwhelming us with details of Claire's six-month cancer treatment and her increasingly dysfunctional relationship with Minna.
Throughout this section, readers' attention may lag as a result of the bizarre plot developments and inexplicable character shifts in the portrayal of the two women -- Claire's passivity and Minna's callousness.
Part 3 recounts Minna's back story at lightning speed -- an 83-page summary of her life from childhood to adulthood, a lot for readers to absorb.
Part 4 ties up the loose threads of the farfetched story.
The Forgetting Tree is neither a page-turner nor a quick read. Sadly, it does not bear out the promise of Soli's earlier novel.
Bev Sandell Greenberg is a Winnipeg writer and editor.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 27, 2012 J8
History
Updated on Saturday, October 27, 2012 at 12:31 PM CDT: adds fact box
More Books
- Back to Top
- Return to Books
More Books
(1 of 13 articles for today)
Grant helps Bergen write new novel
1:00 AM 0Need, poverty, greed, love and grace come together in a new novel-in-progress by Winnipeg's David Bergen.
Bergen has received a major ...
Poll
Most Popular Books
- Manila officials angry over Brown's portrayal
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Winnipeg Bestsellers
- Political stories entertaining, thought provoking
- 'Inferno' by Dan Brown tops Maclean's fiction list
- Tommy Douglas biography tells 'kind half' of his story
- Hookup culture killing romance with sex
- CBC's Lang writes about innovation
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- First edition 'Harry Potter' book, with JK Rowling's notes and drawings, sold for $228,000
- PAPER CHASE: Give grad the gift of penny-pinching
- Manila officials angry over Brown's portrayal
- Political stories entertaining, thought provoking
- CHILDREN'S BOOKS: First novel tribute to power of books
- Review: 'And the Mountains Echoed,' Khaled Hosseini's new book, is another tear-jerker
- Penguin Canada promotes Khaled Hosseini's new book with the Echo Project
- Anne Murray memoir blows the lid off image of fresh-faced singer
- Drunk Mom covers booze, but not the baby
- A long, dangerous road: Refugees share their journeys from Africa to Manitoba
- Cosmologist fights to bring real time back into physics
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- In the end, they knew what they were fighting against
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- Hookup culture killing romance with sex
- Mommy drinks because you cry!
- Ultimate fighter learns from fear
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- A killer of a day really may be one
- Nigerian novel critiques U.S. attitudes toward race
- First edition 'Harry Potter' book, with JK Rowling's notes and drawings, sold for $228,000
- Ultimate fighter learns from fear
- Families seek apology, ways to prevent other deaths
- Life of Pi author Martel hears from Obama
- Corporate control main problem with GMOs
- A killer of a day really may be one
- Less is more: Danish chef Trine Hahnemann promotes sustainable, seasonal eating
- Mommy drinks because you cry!
- SUSPENSE: Original European sleuth deserves wider audience
- Pat Conroy memoir about his father, 'The Death of Santini,' coming out in October
- Fascinating story of Canadian-U.S. differences
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.