Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 07/6/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
When I heard about Johnny Depp playing Tonto in the new Lone Ranger reboot, my first thought was, Hello, have the producers not heard of Adam Beach?
Beach is charismatic and easy on the eyes. He's worked in some award-winning films.
And, crucially, he's an actual First Nations man, not just the dress-up version.
After seeing The Lone Ranger, which is an unworkable mix of nastiness and forced fun, I think the Manitoba-born Beach might have dodged a (silver) bullet. Still, even if Beach didn't want a role that required him to wear a taxidermy crow on his head and talk without using complicated "white man" verb tenses, he, and other indigenous actors (Lorne Cardinal? Billy Merasty?), should have had right of first refusal.
There have been a few defences of the decision to cast Johnny Depp as Tonto. Let's try them out:
DEPP IS AN ACTOR:
Yes, I know. Actors put on costumes and makeup and pretend to be other people, like pirates and vampires and guys with scissors for hands. That's what they do. But if an ethnic role requires you to use spray-on body-paint and adopt a "funny" accent, that's probably a sign that you've crossed a line into cultural insensitivity.
While making vague claims to one-sixteenth Cherokee blood (why is it always Cherokee?), Depp is pretty white. In fact, in Tim Burton films, he's super-white, really working the extreme pallor thing. He's undeniably donned a kind of "red-face" for the role of Tonto.
The issue also involves simple fairness. It's not as if we're living in some post-racial utopia of colour-blind casting. The movies are still heavily weighted toward white stars. For most action heroes and romantic leads, the default setting is white. So when you finally get a major role that is specified as a First Nations character, gee, why not match it with a First Nations actor?
DEPP'S GOOD INTENTIONS:
Well, the road to hell and all that.
I don't think he means to be offensive. Depp has said in press interviews that he was struck, even as a child, by the idea that Tonto got a lousy deal. In this project, he's hoping "to take some of the ugliness thrown on the Native Americans, not only in The Lone Ranger, but the way Indians were treated throughout history of cinema, and turn it on its head."
It's true that The Lone Ranger makes Tonto less of a stoic sidekick and more of a comic lead, with the less-known Armie Hammer playing hapless straight man as the titular masked man. And Tonto's pragmatism is often contrasted with the ridiculous, fancified notions of the white characters. But it still feels like an outside view, an updated gloss on the idea of "the noble savage."
Granted, it's not like The Lone Ranger is pretending to be historically accurate. It's got horses jumping onto moving trains and enough explosions to blow up Monument Valley. It's a Jerry Bruckheimer movie machine, engineered to crank out sequels and theme-park rides and fast-food tie-ins.
But this blockbuster Disney movie still has pretensions to being a revisionist western full of Big Ideas. There's a kind of Occupy Dodge City theme in The Lone Ranger, in which the bad guys are all part of the military-industrial-capitalist complex, while the good guys are all African-Americans, American Indians, Chinese railway workers and women.
Of course, this clunky politically-correct line would be more convincing if the white guys didn't get almost all of the lines.
DEPP IS AN ICON:
There is a sense that Depp transcends the usual rules because of his megawatt star power and cut-glass cheekbones. Because of his sheer Johnny Deppness.
But it feels as if his aura is starting to fade (though the cheekbones are, admittedly, still impressive). His recent roles feel less like performances and more like elaborate impersonations, whether he's channelling Michael Jackson for his daffy take on Willy Wonka or a drunken Keith Richards for Captain Jack Sparrow.
In The Lone Ranger, Depp's Tonto is kind of a stone-faced Buster Keaton with a smidge of Alice Cooper and a finishing flourish of the Forever 21 "tribal" summer line. So yes, his performance is aggressively offbeat. But it's not that great.
DEPP IS A REBEL:
Why a man who's signed on for five Pirates of the Caribbean outings still gets billed as a rebel, I'll never know. Showing up at movie premieres looking like a hobo is not the same as challenging the Hollywood status quo.
For a guy who starred in one of the most revisionist anti-Westerns ever made, Jim Jarmusch's 1995 film Dead Man, Depp seems to have lost his way. As Tonto says -- several times, in his preordained role as spiritual sage -- "Nature is out of balance." With this last questionably "quirky" role choice, so is Depp's career.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 6, 2013 D12
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Acclaimed film 'Selma' disappoints LBJ historian
Mark Wahlberg miscast in remake of 1974 film
Brush with greatness
Benedict Cumberbatch brings overlooked British code-breaker to life in biopic
Rogen, Franco, others react to 'The Interview' online stream
'The Interview' won't be released in Canada Thursday
Court denies Polanski's motion to dismiss 1977 sex case
Film adaptation of Sondheim play keeps the Grimm sensibility of the original
Amy Adams finds the quiet strength in Margaret Keane
Review: True story eye-poppingly told in Burton's 'Big Eyes'
Review: 'Selma' a history lesson that throbs with today
Clint Eastwood and his wife finalize divorce
Christoph Waltz doesn't judge his characters
Mark Wahlberg rolls the dice with new type of role
Jackie Chan expresses shame over son's drug charge
Rep says Helena Bonham Carter, Tim Burton split
Rogen, Franco, others react to 'The Interview' release
Review: 'The Interview' dives into geopolitics
Star-studded cast reflects on challenge of adapting Sondheim
Review: 'Unbroken' is beautiful, but impersonal
Aging in Hollywood being reflected onscreen
Review: Mike Leigh paints his masterpiece in 'Mr. Turner'
Justin Lin to direct third 'Star Trek' film
Review: Don't bet on this oddly lifeless 'Gambler' remake
Jolie on 'Unbroken,' the Coens and acting with Pitt again
Angelina Jolie's latest incarnation: filmmaker
Review: A charming cast anchors the dark 'Into the Woods'
Mark Wahlberg 'starved' for 'The Gambler'
Canadian Press top 10 films of 2014
'Mr. Turner' years in the making for Leigh
'Hobbit' goes out on top with $90.6 million 5-day debut
Sony cyberattack, terror threats put chill on targeting foreign leaders
The AP's top 10 movies of the year
Dolan's 'Mommy' shut out of Oscars list
Wonka, Ferris, the Dude officially cinematic treasures
It's a wander-ful life
Third Museum not worth night out
It's hard to knock sunny production of updated musical