Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 09/9/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
It's thumbs down, at least in the United Kingdom, for Diana, the new biopic starring Naomi Watts as the Princess of Wales in the two years before her shocking death in 1997.
The film had its film premi®re in London on Thursday, is due to open in the U.K. on Sept. 20, a few weeks past the 16th anniversary of the Paris car crash in which she was killed, and is set to open in North America on Nov. 1.
Maybe the jeers won't be as loud by then, and anyway, American audiences often react differently from the British, who have been arguing over Diana and the meaning of her life and death for three decades now.
Still, some of the critical terms used to describe the film, which tells the story of Diana's doomed two-year secret love affair with a Pakistani heart surgeon named Hasnat Khan (Lost's Naveen Andrews), were less than kind:
"Excruciatingly well intentioned" with "bizarre cardboard dialogue." (The Guardian). "Lurid sensationalism" and "pedestrian" (The Telegraph). "Fabulously awful" and "cheap and cheerless" (The Mirror). "Terribly, terribly dull" (The Daily Mail). "Squirmingly embarrassing script" and "atrocious and intrusive" (The Times).
The reviewers insist the filmmakers got it wrong about the kind of woman Diana was. Diana has "died another awful death," wrote Peter Bradshaw in his review in The Guardian. "By excluding (Prince) Charles (still an important figure in her life) and any real depiction of her relationship with her sons -- perhaps through some unspoken deference to these important and very-much-alive royals -- the film creates a distorted, sugary and preposterous impression. She is the Heiress Of Sorrows."
And there was more, although Watts herself did get a few kudos. She is "utterly, uncannily brilliant," although she sports a "Godawful hair-do," says Kate Armstrong in The Telegraph in panning the film. "Was an actress ever more ill served by her make-up and hair people? Even in the air-brushed poster, she looks more Tina Brown than Princess Di," Armstrong writes.
In his review, critic David Gritten, also in The Telegraph, says "Watts makes a decent fist of playing Diana" and "the hair looks first-rate." Go figure.
Maybe the monarchy-skeptical Guardian never thought much about the real Diana when she was alive, but the same cannot be said of such pro-monarchy papers as The Telegraph and The Times, so their critics' reactions to the film are not insignificant.
The reaction in Britain has been an issue for Watts (British-born but raised in Australia) ever since she got the part after turning it down twice. She has said in media interviews she worried about whether the film would upset Diana's sons, Prince William and Prince Harry.
The princes are known to be resentful of media exploitation of their mother, so it is probably a given they will not like this film regardless of the reviews, but they will never say so in public themselves. Instead, the U.K. media will do it for them.
-- USA Today
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition September 9, 2013 D3
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
'Me and Earl and the Dying Girl' sweeps Sundance Awards
Brief Encounter lingers on
Sundance closing-night film, 'Grandma' showcases Lily Tomlin
Obama, Cooper push for media help in better vet portrayal
Comedian Tig Notaro star of Sundance doc, host of awards
'Ida' takes an unlikely road to the Academy Awards
James Franco tries to move beyond "The Interview"
Exploring dark side of the soul makes for uneasy viewing
Story requires a few more shades of grey
Film's dirty business should be more entertaining
Sundance First Look: Pearce, Smulders get rom com 'Results'
Worker dies on Taiwan film lot to be used for Scorsese movie
New on DVD/VOD
First Look: 'Dope' is fresh, funny and music-filled
For Sundance hits, theatrical still rules over VOD
'Ghostbusters' cast set with McCarthy, Wiig, McKinnon, Jones
Prosecutor: Gregg Allman filmmaker never given immunity
Review: Something's missing from the deck in 'Wild Card'
'Selma' star supports Cumberbatch over "colored" comment
Review: Tragedies of 'Timbuktu' told with rare beauty
Review: A tired gimmick weakens thriller 'Project Almanac'
Diversity at Sundance doesn't carry over to Hollywood
Sundance Watch: Celebs talk fest, iPhone film premieres
Sundance Watch: 'Tangerine' shot entirely with iPhones
Sundance Quick Quote: Spike Lee discovers crowd funding
Sundance Watch: Redford brings film to his own festival
Private jets, mega yachts marketed at Sundance Film Festival
Sundance Quick Quote: Rashida Jones on porn, sex and women
Common, John Legend to perform 'Glory' at Academy Awards
Sundance Watch: 'Me and Earl' becomes breakout hit at fest
'Django Unchained' actress pleads not guilty to lewd conduct
Sundance Watch: Celebrities sound off on the fest
Review: 'Black or White' wrestles with race in custody drama
Adrian Grenier enjoys anonymity on empty slopes at Sundance
Audrey Tautou, Matthew Weiner among Berlin film fest jury
So it is written...
Death From Above doc screens at Cinematheque
Sundance Watch: Fans angle for selfies, Reynolds talks poker