Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 03/28/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
To have watched the available movie version of The Thief and the Cobbler is to subject yourself to one of the great mysteries of animated feature films.
How did a project more than two decades in the making end up becoming such a hodgepodge of insipid cartooning coupled with a few moments of animation genius? What went wrong?
Kevin Schreck's documentary points the finger at Toronto-born animator Richard Williams, simultaneously crediting him with a genius for his transcendent artistry (Williams was the Oscar-winning animation director of Who Framed Roger Rabbit?) and accusing him of self-indulgence run amok.
Begun in the late 1960s, the project began as Williams' self-admitted "ego trip," an animated version of a book of Persian folk tales. Williams worked doggedly on the feature, devoted to blazing new trails in the medium and exemplifying "excellence."
Schreck includes reams of footage suggesting the film was indeed destined for greatness. Before computer animation made it comparatively simple to negotiate three-dimensional space, Williams was making astonishing headway in that department, as evidenced by a psychedelic chase sequence in which the cobbler chases the thief through a stunningly rendered palace.
Alas, for all his vision, Williams didn't have an end game. He was two decades and millions of dollars into the work before he even started producing storyboards for the finished movie.
Williams himself refuses to discuss the movie, but Schreck has reams of old interview footage and access to a host of animators, artists and writers willing to discuss the project. There is a suggestion that so many artists worked on the thing, it was possible for Disney to purloin some of the film's design elements for use in their hit musical Aladdin. (Check out the similarities between T&C's "Grand Vizier" and Aladdin's Jafar and the conclusion is inescapable.)
When the film was pulled from Williams' hands by Warner Bros., to be cannibalized into the available version of The Thief and the Cobbler (a.k.a. Arabian Knight, a.k.a. The Princess and the Cobbler), the movie resembled a clumsy ripoff of Aladdin, with the gratuitous addition of some insipid songs and comic voice-work by the likes of Jonathan Winters and Vincent Price.
Williams's vision of excellence became the definition of makeshift mediocrity.
Yet one doesn't come away with contempt for the philistines of the major movie studio. The film acknowledges that Williams was his own worst enemy, a visionary who knew everything about the art form, except when to stop.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition March 28, 2014 D5
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Sony cyberattack, terror threats put chill on targeting foreign leaders
The AP's top 10 movies of the year
Dolan's 'Mommy' shut out of Oscars list
Wonka, Ferris, the Dude officially cinematic treasures
It's a wander-ful life
Third Museum not worth night out
It's hard to knock sunny production of updated musical
'Team America' screenings also pulled from theatres
Texas theatre schedules showing of "Team America"
Screens onscreen: How do TV characters use tech?
Review: 'The Interview' deserves to be seen
Film students to play role in Academy Awards show
Nick Hornby gets out of his element writing his latest screenplay
Mark Wahlberg bets on upside-down remake of 1974 film
New on DVD/VOD
Local theatres pulling The Interview after threats
Waterston drawn to 'Inherent Vice' director
25 movies chosen for the National Film Registry
'Saving Private Ryan' among films being preserved
Third time's the charm for bloated Hobbit
Review: 'The Hobbit' wraps with a Middle-earth melee
No plans to go back again to Middle-earth on film
NYC premiere of Rogen film cancelled as threats fly
Sweet 'Night at the Museum' bids farewell to Robin Williams
'Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles' among new DVDs
Polanski lawyers accuse prosecutors of misconduct
Xavier Dolan always had a 'vision': father
Tolkiening it to the next level
Linklater's 'Boyhood' wins Toronto prize
"Annie" is a hard knock, no fun adaptation
'Birdman,' 'Budapest' top Critics' Choice noms
Wartime, Hollywood photographer Phil Stern dies
New Malick movie to debut at Berlin film festival
Lawyer: Free speech at stake in anti-Muslim film
'Gone with the Wind' premiere sparked tension
Ready to rock
'Selma' stars on poignancy and parallels of movie
'Exodus: Gods and Kings' conquers the box office