Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 12/27/2012 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
The family-friendliest movie comedy this holiday season is also the sappiest and schmaltziest.
And thanks to Billy Crystal, the shtickiest.
Parental Guidance is a mild-mannered riff on parenting, then-and-now. It contrasts the top-down/career-first mentality of one generation with the coddled "nurturing" of today, but never takes a stand on which is better.
Basically, it's a vehicle for Billy Crystal, and to a lesser degree Bette Midler, to riff on the spoiled, over-indulged and sometimes uptight kids their kid is raising.
Artie (Crystal) is a minor league baseball announcer who never got to his dream job, covering San Francisco Giants games. He's content to make homespun wisecracks in front of the mike for the Fresno Grizzlies. Until they lay him off for being not hip, not social media savvy.
"I'll tweet! I'll make whatever noise you want!" he pleads.
His retired "weather girl" wife Diane interrupts her pole-dance aerobics class to comfort him and listen to his lies about how young he "feels."
"You're 38? Paint the house!"
Daughter Alice (Marisa Tomei) is a web designer living in Atlanta with husband Phil (Tom Everett Scott) in the totally computerized house Phil designed.
Their kids -- 12, 8 and 5 -- have play dates, ball games and rehearsals. Violinist daughter Harper (Bailee Madison) would discover boys, if she wasn't stressing over a big audition that sets up her Berlin Philharmonic life plan. Turner (Joshua Rush) is a bullied stammerer whose little league doesn't keep score, denying him the chance to excel at anything. And Barker (Kyle Harrison Breitkopf) is a mop-topped terror with an imaginary kangaroo friend.
Into this world come, "The other grandparents," the West Coast couple that never sees them because Artie has been all about the job all his life. They're not the first choice, but Phil and Alice have a get-away planned -- if only Alice can let go.
Whatever Artie and Diane did with Alice isn't good enough for Alice's kids. She takes their finicky dinner orders, by text. The kids aren't allowed sugar, are ferried hither and yon to appointments -- touchy-feely speech therapy for Turner, violin lessons from a Russian "Tiger Mom" for Harper. Tofu mom Alice never lets them hear the word, "No."
Crystal delivers tepidly caustic rants, Midler invokes the occasional inappropriate life lesson to Harper and Tomei struggles to find anything fun about playing a smothering mother. The laughs are, to use the old-fashioned term, telegraphed, with director Andy Fickman (The Game Plan) clearing the decks to make every laugh line a stale showcase moment for his stars. A Billy and Bette duet of Who Wrote the Book of Love is cute, but the setup is sluggish and it has no life. A quicker, more cluttered movie would have been funnier.
There are sparks between generations, but with the exception of Madison, the child actors are in over their heads and the adults seem as if they've just met.
At least the sentimental stuff works. And the toilet jokes.
-- McClatchy-Tribune News Service
Starring Billy Crystal and Bette Midler
Kildonan Place, McGillivray, Polo Park, St. Vital, Towne
2.5 out of five
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition December 27, 2012 C3
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
'American Sniper' holds top spot at weekend box office
Quick Quote: Mindy Kaling on confidence
'Racing Extinction' documentary a call to save the planet
Nikki Reed coy about love for Somerhalder, but not animals
Sundance Watch: Franco falls in love, Reed coy on engagement
First Look: Reynolds charms in drama 'Mississippi Grind'
Quick Quote: What Jenji Kohan wishes
Quick Quote: Why U.K. director Rupert Goold cast Jonah Hill
Quick Quote: Jeffrey Tambor talks binge watching
Quick Quote: Jack Black on independent films
Quick Quote: Jason Segel's rewarding experience
The plot thickens
What is American Sniper taking aim at?
Oscar has a woman problem
Sundance doc paints a harrowing picture of campus rape
SUNDANCE WATCH: Williams remembered, come for the tacos
Quick Quote: Ethan Hawke talks 'Boyhood'
Quick Quote: Kristen Wiig's advice on Sundance
New doc dedicated to Robin Williams explores comedy, misery
'The Bronze' and the explicit scene everyone's buzzing about
George Lucas hopes 'Strange Magic' will appeal to all ages
It's melodramatic, but the melody is moving
Animated musical fairy tale an annoying, fantastical fail
Journey across frontier a twisty, turbulent trek
Aniston's Cake goes down like a serving of vegetables
'Can I borrow a cup of sugar... if you know what I mean?'
Nina Simone documentary a powerful portrait of the artist
John Legend performs tribute set at Sundance premiere
Frank Mazzola dies; staged James Dean's famous fight scene
Review: 'Boy Next Door' way too predictable
Review: Depp indulges inner clown in charmless 'Mortdecai'
Jennifer Lopez: 'The artist in me wants more freedom'
Oscar fever has fans scrambling to watch, watch, watch
Robert Redford kicks off Sundance Film Fest
New on DVD/VOD
Review: Deglamorized Aniston in drab 'Cake'
'Orphan Black,' 'Degrassi' up for GLAAD Media Awards
Julianne Moore a 'genius,' says Kristen Stewart