14°c Light rain
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Saddled with sentiment
It's a thoroughbred production, but when it comes to realism, drama fails to pony up
UNDATED -- Undated handout photo from the 2011 movie WAR HORSE. Albert Narracott (Jeremy Irvine) joyfully rides atop his beloved horse, Joey in DreamWorks Pictures' "War Horse", director Steven Spielberg's epic adventure and an unforgettable odyssey through courage, friendship, discovery and wonder. (POSTMEDIA)
Movie review
War Horse
Starring Jeremy Irvine and Niels Arestrup
Starts Sunday at the Globe, Grant Park, Polo Park, St. Vital
PG, 146 minutes
Three stars out of five
Before it became "A Film by Steven Spielberg," War Horse was a children's book by Michael Morpurgo and a hit play.
Given Spielberg's Oscar-y track record, it comes to the big screen with loads of prestige (note the Christmas Day release date) and the promise that the film version will be the best possible incarnation of the story.
I doubt that. War Horse is a lovely film, to be sure. But given its examination of the ugliness of war, it seems pertinent to ask: Should it be so very lovely?
Spielberg pulls out all the stops early on. The setting: English countryside. Cue the lyrical pseudo-Vaughn Williams strings, courtesy of composer John Williams, as we are introduced to the horse Joey as he is born. The beautiful beast falls into the hands of an alcoholic farmer (Peter Mullan) too proud to relinquish the horse to his rich landlord (David Thewlis) at auction.
Fortunately, the farmer's son Albert (Jeremy Irvine) has already fallen for the horse and vows to do anything he can to keep him, including training him for the grunt work of plowing a rocky field.
But war looms in Europe and soon the horse is transferred into the possession of an English cavalry captain (Tom Hiddleston). Call Joey a draft horse.
The captain is all very conscientious and gallant, but the face of combat changed in the First World War, and Spielberg duly portrays the transition in a scene in which an old-fashioned cavalry charge collides with the 20th century in the form of a barrage of machine gun fire.
Suddenly in the possession of Germans, Joey is stolen by a pair of young brothers who attempt to desert. And the horse winds up under the protection of a Dutch farmer (Niels Arestrup) before being taken by more villainous Germans, who hook him up to cart heavy artillery uphill. Joey unknowingly switches allegiances again, only to wind up in the vicinity of young Albert, who has evidently joined the army with the express purpose of finding his horse.
Photographed for maximum lushness by Janusz Kaminski (Schindler's List), War Horse again is a lovely looking film, but that loveliness is at odds with the story on multiple levels. A view of war as seen through the eyes of an animal would surely be a horror movie and not a pseudo-inspirational drama.
Spielberg and screenwriters Richard Curtis and Lee Hall extend the romantic fallacy to providing Joey with an equine pal with whom he might play out anthropomorphic notions of friendship and sacrifice among the horsy set.
One cannot fault the film's production, which is superb, and makes for an esthetically pleasing time at the movies. It's all so beautiful and stirring -- and as false as the promise of adventure and glory that drew all those young men into the war in the first place.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition December 23, 2011 D1
More Movies
- Back to Top
- Return to Movies
More Movies
(1 of 27 articles for this week)
'Trek' does $70.6M but falls short of studio hopes; 'Iron Man 3' tops $1B worldwide
1:27 PM 0
About Randall King
In a way, Randall King was born into the entertainment beat.
His dad was Winnipeg musician Jimmy King, a one-time columnist for the Winnipeg Free Press. One of his brothers is a playwright. Another is a singer-songwriter.
Randall has been content to cover the entertainment beat in one capacity or another since 1990.
His beat is film, and the job has placed him in the same room as diverse talents, from Martin Scorsese to Martin Short, from Julie Christie to Julia Styles. He has met three James Bonds (four if you count Woody Allen), and director Russ Meyer once told him: "I like your style."
He really likes his job.
Poll
Most Popular Movies
- McConaughey excels in tale of Southern masculinity
- Second instalment of sci-fi reboot lacks Khan-do attitude
- MOVIES
- Difficult bandmate, terrible husband, amazing drummer
- 'Trek' does $70.6M but falls short of studio hopes; 'Iron Man 3' tops $1B worldwide
- The point? What point?
- Comedy covers sex from A to Z... by way of S&M
- Subtle horror unwinds in psychological film
- Matthew McConaughey says 'Mud' avoids stereotypical view of U.S. South
- Thriller better at politics than mathematics
- Medical community lauds Jolie's courage, while pointing out that her solution is not for all
- McConaughey excels in tale of Southern masculinity
- Second instalment of sci-fi reboot lacks Khan-do attitude
- Free Press chats with producer Klymkiw before doc screens
- Difficult bandmate, terrible husband, amazing drummer
- Comedy covers sex from A to Z... by way of S&M
- Matthew McConaughey says 'Mud' avoids stereotypical view of U.S. South
- Doc pays tribute to producer who put local films on the map
- Subtle horror unwinds in psychological film
- Rape repercussion tale impressive film
- Medical community lauds Jolie's courage, while pointing out that her solution is not for all
- Comedy covers sex from A to Z... by way of S&M
- There's some big, dumb fun to be had in comedy caper, but the laughs come at a queasy cost
- McConaughey excels in tale of Southern masculinity
- Second instalment of sci-fi reboot lacks Khan-do attitude
- Futuristic Colony bleak inside and out
- Director takes ‘Roaring ’20s’ literally with loud, garish Gatsby adaptation
- Tony Stark doesn't suit up as often, but sequel still packs in action
- Catherine Zeta-Jones checks into mental health facility for treatment of bipolar disorder
- Reese Witherspoon says she's 'deeply embarrassed' by arrest; Atlanta hearing rescheduled
- Medical community lauds Jolie's courage, while pointing out that her solution is not for all
- Second instalment of sci-fi reboot lacks Khan-do attitude
- Free Press chats with producer Klymkiw before doc screens
- Difficult bandmate, terrible husband, amazing drummer
- Medical community lauds Jolie's courage, while pointing out that her solution is not for all
- Second instalment of sci-fi reboot lacks Khan-do attitude
- Movie looking for boy with 'open, honest face'
- Open casting call for part of young boy in Winnipeg-shot film
- Six Israeli secret service chiefs and one inescapable conclusion
- Tony Stark doesn't suit up as often, but sequel still packs in action
- Jonas Chernick, star of My Awkward Sexual Adventure at News Café
- Imax to go out way it came in
- Manga: it's not just for kids anymore
- Cut out the jargon: Alan Alda centre at NY college teaches scientists to keep it simple
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.