Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 03/20/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
MINNEAPOLIS -- A Minnesota woman at the centre of a long-running court fight over the unauthorized downloading of copyrighted music said there's still no way she can pay record companies the $222,000 judgment she owes after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear her appeal Monday.
The justices did not comment on their decision. Attorneys for Jammie Thomas-Rasset, of Brainerd, argued the amount was excessive.
The music industry filed thousands of lawsuits in the early to mid-2000s against people it accused of downloading music without permission and without paying for it. Almost all the cases settled for about $3,500 apiece. Thomas-Rasset is one of two defendants who refused to pay and went to trial. The other, former Boston University student Joel Tenenbaum, also lost and was ordered to pay $675,000.
The industry initially sued Thomas-Rasset in 2006. Her case has gone through three trials and several appeals. The industry presented evidence that Thomas-Rasset made available over 1,700 songs to other computer users via the file-sharing service Kazaa, though the suit targeted only 24 songs.
"I'm assuming that since they declined to hear the case it's probably done at this point," she said, adding she needed to consult with her attorneys to determine what happens next.
Thomas-Rasset, 35, who works for the Mille Lacs Band of Ojibwe tribal government, maintained -- as she has all along -- that she can't afford to pay.
"There's no way that they can collect," she said. "Right now, I get energy assistance because I have four kids. It's just the one income. My husband isn't working. It's not possible for them to collect even if they wanted to. I have no assets."
The Recording Industry Association of America offered to settle for $5,000 when it first sued, and offered to settle for a $25,000 donation to a charity for music industry people in need after her second trial. She refused both times.
"We appreciate the Court's decision and are pleased that the legal case is finally over," the trade group said in a statement. "We've been willing to settle this case from day one and remain willing to do so."
-- The Associated Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition March 20, 2013 C3
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Bennett, Gaga: Kids should know more about jazz
Protest music fuels festival
A Tribe Called Red pulls out of CMHR opening weekend
Leonard Cohen says touring has improved his mood
Canadian Hot 100 now includes streaming
Wig designer's suit against Nicki Minaj dismissed
Puerto Rico singer Don Omar faces abuse charges
'X' by Chris Brown tops HMV Canada CD sales chart
Jackson lets the boot-scootin' good times roll
Damian Abraham and his band get serious on Glass Boys
Jackson croons his way into hearts of country-lovin' MTS centre crowd
Jason Isbell cleans up at Americana Awards
Soprano Gauvin earns bravas at MCO season opener
Avril Lavigne and Chad Kroeger to split?
Puerto Rico police arrest reggaeton star Don Omar
Q&A: Barbra Streisand, the feminist, sings on
Review: alt-J returns with beautiful, baffling LP
Wealth of riches fuels rock band New Pornographers
Experts: Chopin's heart shows signs of TB
Concerts, concerts ...and more concerts
Lawyer: Thicke exploited in 'Blurred Lines' suit
Death certificate: Rapper Tim Dog died last year
Rachel McAdams to join Canada's Walk of Fame
The top 10 songs and albums on the iTunes Store
'Partners' among new CD releases
Review: Callaway pays tribute to Sarah Vaughan
Tim McGraw, Faith Hill score another hit together
Review: Mendes spreads joy of Brazil's music
Sam Roberts Band to play the Burt in November
Black Label Society coming to town early in 2015
Vancouver's Mother Mother in town late November
Live Whitney Houston CD/DVD to be released Nov. 10
'Four (Deluxe Edition)' top album on iTunes in Canada
Eminem publishers sue New Zealand political party
2nd conductor resigns from Vienna State Opera
Singer's fate predicted during odd encounter
Rapper Common's father, Lonnie Lynn, dies at 71
Correction: Music-U2-iTunes story