Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Well, it sure sounds a lot like Christmas
It may not be beginning to look a lot like Christmas, but choral ensemble Canzona decided to get the snowball rolling.
Their performance with the University of Manitoba Singers and MusikBarock Ensemble Sunday night of J.S. Bach's glorious Christmas Oratorio was a sure-fire way to usher in the holiday season.
Concert Review
The Christmas Oratorio
Canzona
Westminster United Church
Nov. 22 Attendance: 650
3-1/2 stars out of five
Composed in 1734 to be performed in church over the Christmas period, it tells the story of the Nativity and subsequent events in six cantatas. Artistic Director Henry Engbrecht wisely limited this performance to Parts 1-3 and highlights from Parts 4-6.
Soloists were soprano Charlene Pauls, alto Kirsten Schellenberg, tenor David Menzies and bass Jason Nedecky.
Opening with a briskly paced Jauchzet, frohlocket, the choir exuded joy and energy, enunciating every word with care. Trumpets soared and we held on for the ride.
Menzies, in the demanding role of Evangelist, showed stamina and control without strain as he reached the upper register repeatedly. Yet, in the tenor aria Frohe Hirten, eilt, ach eilet, which he handled cleanly and with ease, he resorted to a head voice, not nearly as effective had he sung out more, as he did as Evangelist.
The flute accompaniment for this aria was lovely, but its tone was slickly modern, not the plainer, woodier sound of the period.
Schellenberg is a gifted interpreter of Bach, with a voice rich as heavy cream. In Bereite dich, Zion, her long flowing phrases blended into one another. There was lovely oboe work from Caitlin Broms-Jacobs, and Eric Lussier, harpsichordist, who kept things moving along nicely.
But it wasn't all easy sledding. In Schlafe, mein Liebster, the orchestra tended to compete with Schellenberg's singing, not adjusting from feature instrumental playing to accompanying. Her entry was so delicately subtle, you hardly knew she was there, but soon her singing blossomed into full voice -- utterly sublime.
Nedecky has a pleasing lilt to his voice, which is lithe and resonant without heaviness. Standing in front of the continuo instruments, however, his singing was often obscured. Sound checks might have picked up on this, as it remained a problem throughout the performance.
We waited a long time to hear Pauls, who sat patiently until Part 3 before singing a duet with Nedecky. Well balanced, their voices meshed well and their pleasant facial expressions were a bonus.
Pauls has a presence that commands your attention and the voice to keep it. She brings lightness and joy to her singing, and is expressive and dramatic when required.
Chorus work was excellent, with great attention to dynamics and attack thanks to the choir's alertness to Engbrecht's precise direction.
Special mention must go to Brian Sykora, for spine-tingling trumpet work and to Lussier for the sheer endurance to play non-stop for 21/2 hours.
gwenda.nemerofsky@shaw.ca
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 24, 2009 D4
More Music
- Back to Top
- Return to Music
Most Popular Music
- Justin Bieber fans in Vancouver in disbelief over apparent tour snub
- Jets driving ratings surge at TSN Radio
- Lady Gaga won't change show to placate protesters on Asian tour, manager says
- 'Born and Raised' by John Mayer tops HMV Canada CD sales chart
- Two-day Bayou Country Superfest lineup includes Carrie Underwood, Keith Urban, Rascal Flatts
- Il Divo launches North American tour in Canada with opener Nikki Yanofsky
- Music, boards, education make up Skate 4 Cancer
- Ehnes plays with musicality, warmth
- John Mayer's 'Born and Raised' among new CD releases for the week of May 22
- Lady Gaga's comment about buying fake Rolex sparks backlash in Thailand
- Justin Bieber fans in Vancouver in disbelief over apparent tour snub
- Phillip Phillips, Jessica Sanchez face off on 'American Idol' finale
- Supreme Court won't consider reducing $675,000 verdict against student who downloaded music
- 'American Idol' judge Steven Tyler charmed by "sexy beast" J-Lo; feels Jessica can win 'Idol'
- Slash recruits Canadians for band; doesn't expect Velvet Revolver reunion
- Ian Astbury's struggles provide ammo for new Cult album 'Choice of Weapon'
- Sammy Hagar says he's not surprised Roth-Van Halen tour has postponed dozens of dates
- Il Divo launches North American tour in Canada with opener Nikki Yanofsky
- John Mayer's 'Born and Raised' among new CD releases for the week of May 22
- POP and ROCK: Adam Lambert
- Aging rockers Van Halen can still bring it
- Justin Bieber fans in Vancouver in disbelief over apparent tour snub
- Adam Yauch of the Beastie Boys dies at 47; rapper had been in treatment for cancer
- Donna Summer, Queen of Disco, dies at 63: hits included 'Last Dance,' 'Bad Girls'
- At 66, Ottawa's Bruce Cockburn pleased to have another shot at fatherhood
- Phillip Phillips, Jessica Sanchez face off on 'American Idol' finale
- Supreme Court won't consider reducing $675,000 verdict against student who downloaded music
- We still danced the night away
- Rammstein gig a flaming success
- Beastie Boy Adam (MCA) Yauch dies at 47
- Concerts
- Supreme Court won't consider reducing $675,000 verdict against student who downloaded music
- Skydiggers' latest reflects band's 23-year career arc
- Agassiz fest lines up appealing guests
- Fogerty’s travelin’ band to stop here on Sept. 20
- Musical class of 2012
- Aging rockers Van Halen can still bring it
- Rammstein gig a flaming success
- A solid performance with true Spanish flair
- At 66, Ottawa's Bruce Cockburn pleased to have another shot at fatherhood
- We still danced the night away
- Rammstein to play here for first time on May 10
- Humble Reid ready to Fire It Up in arenas
- Saucy new fest on tap
Ads by Google









You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010; View the changes. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.