10°c Light rain
16°c Variable cloudiness
The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Appeals court: Anti-whaling protesters are 'pirates,' must halt their aggressive tactics
SAN FRANCISCO - Their supporters call them heroes. The Japanese government calls them terrorists.
Late Monday, the United States' largest federal court labeled them pirates.
In doing so, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals castigated Paul Watson and members of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society he founded for the tactics used in their relentless campaign to disrupt the annual whale hunt off the dangerous waters of Antarctica.
"You don't need a peg leg or an eye patch," Chief Judge Alex Kozinski wrote for the unanimous three-judge panel. "When you ram ships; hurl glass containers of acid; drag metal-reinforced ropes in the water to damage propellers and rudders; launch smoke bombs and flares with hooks; and point high-powered lasers at other ships, you are, without a doubt, a pirate, no matter how high-minded you believe your purpose to be."
The same court in December ordered the organization to keep its ships at least 500 yards from Japanese whalers. The whalers have since accused the protesters of violating that order at least twice this month.
The ruling overturned a Seattle trial judge's decision siding with the protesters and tossing out a lawsuit filed by a group of Japanese whalers seeking a court-ordered halt to the aggressive tactics, many of which were broadcast on the Animal Planet reality television show "Whale Wars."
U.S. District Judge Richard Jones had sided with Sea Shepherd on several grounds in tossing out the whalers' piracy accusations and refusing to prohibit the conservation group's protests. He determined the protesters' tactics were nonviolent because they targeted equipment and ships rather than people.
The judge also said the whalers were violating an Australian court order banning the hunt and so were precluded from pursuing their lawsuit in the United States.
The appeals court called Jones' ruling "off base" and took the rare step of ordering the case transferred to another Seattle judge to comply with its ruling Monday. The appeals court said Jones had misinterpreted the Australian ruling, which didn't address the protesters' actions.
"The district judge's numerous, serious and obvious errors identified in our opinion raise doubts as to whether he will be perceived as impartial in presiding over this high-profile case," Kozinski wrote.
Charles Moure, an attorney representing Sea Shepherd, said he would ask an 11-judge panel of the 9th Circuit to reconsider Monday's ruling, including Jones' removal from the case.
"They are killing whales in violation of an Australian court order," Moure said.
More The Green Page
- Back to Top
- Return to The Green Page
More The Green Page
(1 of 17 articles for this week)
After days on pins and needles, hypothermic turtles are recovering
1:46 AM 0QUINCY, Mass. - Two endangered sea turtles that are shells of their former selves after getting stranded on Cape Cod ...
Poll
Most Popular The Green Page
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- White beefalo has new home to roam at Saskatoon's Forestry Farm exhibit
- Trail, B.C., students need no urgin' to help transplant baby sturgeon
- Spray ban may be coming
- Canadian Pacific rail cars derail in Minn., spill oil onto frozen ground; cleanup under way
- B.C. court rules hydro project can proceed without an environmental assessment
- Harper's communications unit bigfoots Parks Canada news conference
- Conservatives boost resources ad spending to $16.5M, target U.S. audiences
- Rae says TransCanada's Keystone XL oil pipeline in national interest
- Bowater Mersey lands in southwestern Nova Scotia now open to vehicles
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- Technology will be key to conquering climate change in long run, Harper says
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- White beefalo has new home to roam at Saskatoon's Forestry Farm exhibit
- Conservatives boost resources ad spending to $16.5M, target U.S. audiences
- Spray ban may be coming
- Saskatchewan creates first new provincial park in nearly 20 years
- Alberta promises better disaster response following second Slave Lake review
- Nature Conservancy announces protections for Pugwash River, Canfield Creek
- Trail, B.C., students need no urgin' to help transplant baby sturgeon
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- After 2 decades of tracking down world's oldest trees, group ready to begin planting clones
- Emergency management officials waiting for water levels to rise in Regina
- Flooding prompts three Saskatchewan communities to declare states of emergency
- Navy warship fuel spill into Halifax harbour described as "significant"
- TransCanada says it's somewhat surprised over EPA reaction to Keystone pipeline
- Technology will be key to conquering climate change in long run, Harper says
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- Former Liberal prime minister intends to let Americans know the benefits of Keystone
- Purchasing power: Five ways consumers can be more socially conscious in shopping
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- 10th Saskatchewan community declares flood emergency; Regina residents told to prepare
- Better oil price needed for emissions controls to work: environment minister
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- More money may be needed for heritage area along Manitoba-Ontario boundary
- Outdoors online: Google to map trails, historical sites in national parks
- After 2 decades of tracking down world's oldest trees, group ready to begin planting clones
- Ecosystem protection focus of new legislation
- Sandbags filled, barriers ready as Saskatchewan communities prepare for flooding
- Purchasing power: Five ways consumers can be more socially conscious in shopping
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.