6°c Clear
18°c Sunny
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Opposition to lakes sale grows
Heavy hitters urge Tories to keep ELA
Work at the ELA in Ontario is world-renowned. (WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ARCHIVES ) Photo Store
OTTAWA -- Two former prime ministers and a former Tory fisheries minister have added their names to the growing list of people trying to save the world-renowned Experimental Lakes Area.
Former Liberal PMs John Turner and Paul Martin, and Mulroney-era cabinet minister Tom Siddon, are among 70 signatories on a full-page ad in support of the ELA that will run today in the Free Press and the Globe and Mail.
Siddon, an MP from near Vancouver, was the fisheries minister under Brian Mulroney from 1985 until 1990. He oversaw major changes to fisheries-habitat protection and last month he railed against changes to the Fisheries Act contained in the Harper Conservatives' omnibus budget bill.
"This is the voice of people outside the scientific community," said Diane Orihel, founder of Save ELA. "We are sending a strong message to the government that we're serious and we will continue to fight to save ELA."
The trio joins those calling on the government not to sell the valuable research facilities near Kenora, Ont., that allow for one-of-a-kind experiments on entire lakes. There are 58 lakes used for the research, which is done under an agreement between Ottawa and the Ontario government.
The government announced May 17 it was pulling the $2-million annual funding to operate the ELA and pay salaries of 17 scientists and administrative staff as of next April. It is attempting to transfer ownership of the ELA to a university or provincial government. The asking price is a dollar, in return for 40,000 square feet of space in 19 buildings. The government has invested $3.5 million into the facilities at the ELA in the last 10 years.
The advertisement also says "ELA is closing just when the planet needs it most" and calls ELA "unique and irreplaceable."
A spokeswoman for Fisheries Minister Keith Ashfield has repeatedly said the government believes ELA research is no longer aligned with its mandate and research the government needs can be completed by other programs.
However, ELA proponents say the research being done at ELA fits with the mandate to conduct research on fish habitat and climate change, and the work there cannot be replicated anywhere else.
John Smol, a biologist from Queen's University, said Friday even the kind of research needed to look at the impact of the oilsands on aquatic life is underway at the ELA.
Smol said $2 million is so paltry, it's akin to "a rounding on the defence budget" and that the decision is not about money.
"For $2 million, every Canadian pays a penny every couple of months and in return we don't have algae blooms or acid rain," said Smol. "But if you don't have that pesky scientific data, you don't have to do anything about it."
Scientists from around the world have written to Ashfield asking him to reconsider the decision, noting the global impact ELA research has had over the last 40 years is immeasurable.
It has affected policies on everything from mercury and acid rain to estrogen, phosphorus additives in soap and hydroelectric dams.
At the very least, ELA proponents want the government to allow more time to find programs willing to take over the ELA.
They say it is going to be next to impossible to find a new funder in nine months.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 16, 2012 A12
More The Green Page
- Back to Top
- Return to The Green Page
More The Green Page
(1 of 14 articles for this week)
Harper test-drives new "extractive industries" approach to aid in Peru
3:01 AM 0LIMA, Peru - Prime Minister Stephen Harper meets with mining executives and the Peruvian president this morning as he puts ...
Poll
Most Popular The Green Page
- Boreal Forest conservation negotiations end in failure after three years
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- More than 91,000 litres of oil spilled from derailed Saskatchewan train
- After days on pins and needles, hypothermic turtles are recovering
- White beefalo has new home to roam at Saskatoon's Forestry Farm exhibit
- Spray ban may be coming
- B.C. court rules hydro project can proceed without an environmental assessment
- Canadian Pacific rail cars derail in Minn., spill oil onto frozen ground; cleanup under way
- Trail, B.C., students need no urgin' to help transplant baby sturgeon
- BioteQ signs deal with Teck Resources for pilot test of technology
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- Technology will be key to conquering climate change in long run, Harper says
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- Boreal Forest conservation negotiations end in failure after three years
- White beefalo has new home to roam at Saskatoon's Forestry Farm exhibit
- More than 91,000 litres of oil spilled from derailed Saskatchewan train
- Spray ban may be coming
- After days on pins and needles, hypothermic turtles are recovering
- Saskatchewan creates first new provincial park in nearly 20 years
- Alberta promises better disaster response following second Slave Lake review
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- After 2 decades of tracking down world's oldest trees, group ready to begin planting clones
- Emergency management officials waiting for water levels to rise in Regina
- Flooding prompts three Saskatchewan communities to declare states of emergency
- Navy warship fuel spill into Halifax harbour described as "significant"
- TransCanada says it's somewhat surprised over EPA reaction to Keystone pipeline
- Technology will be key to conquering climate change in long run, Harper says
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- Boreal Forest conservation negotiations end in failure after three years
- Purchasing power: Five ways consumers can be more socially conscious in shopping
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- Warm weather with cool breaks forecast for Canada this summer
- 10th Saskatchewan community declares flood emergency; Regina residents told to prepare
- Better oil price needed for emissions controls to work: environment minister
- Harper heads to New York to face grilling on Canada's environmental record
- More money may be needed for heritage area along Manitoba-Ontario boundary
- After 2 decades of tracking down world's oldest trees, group ready to begin planting clones
- Ecosystem protection focus of new legislation
- Sandbags filled, barriers ready as Saskatchewan communities prepare for flooding
- Purchasing power: Five ways consumers can be more socially conscious in shopping
- Ship that sank in 1985 likely source of small oil slicks off Newfoundland
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.