12°c Overcast
18°c Cloudy with sunny breaks
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Don't bet your life on skin cancer apps
Accuracy varies widely, researchers find
A malignant melanoma (left) was misdiagnosed as a benign lesion by three out of four skin cancer-detecting apps (illustrated above). (CP)
TORONTO -- Smartphone apps that analyze photos of moles to assess whether they might be potentially deadly melanoma or benign lesions vary widely in accuracy, say researchers who warn patients against using them for diagnosis.
A study of four such applications, available free or for a modest cost from the two most popular online app retailers, found they incorrectly classified at least 30 per cent of melanomas submitted for evaluation as being of no concern.
"One of them was so bad that it actually missed over 93 per cent (of the melanomas)," said principal author Dr. Laura Ferris, a dermatologist at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.
"That's kind of scary."
Melanoma, the most serious type of skin cancer, can develop in an existing mole or arise as a fresh pigmented or unusual-looking growth on the skin. They can develop anywhere, but are most common in areas previously exposed to sunlight, such as the back, legs, arms and face. However, melanomas can also appear on the palms of the hands and soles of the feet.
If caught early and treated, this skin cancer has a high cure rate, but the survival rate is low for patients whose melanomas have gone undetected and spread to other areas of the body.
To conduct the study, the researchers submitted 188 photos of lesions to each of the four smartphone apps, none of which was identified by the authors.
The researchers knew the status of the moles or lesions -- 60 were melanomas and 128 benign -- because they had been photographed before being removed or biopsied and sent to an in-house pathologist for testing.
"We knew what they were, either cancer or not," Ferris said from Pittsburgh. "And we went with the two ends of the spectrum: It's frankly melanoma or it is a really low-grade, not bad pigmented skin lesion."
The researchers wanted to see whether assessments by the four apps matched the previously confirmed diagnoses.
Ferris said three of the apps give answers within a minute after a photo is uploaded. The fourth, which forwards the photo to a U.S. board-certified dermatologist for analysis, takes about 24 hours to provide an online opinion as to whether a lesion is suspicious or not.
"And the main thing we were looking at was how often did they get melanoma right or how often did they miss it," she said.
"Interestingly, the results we got from the one where you had a dermatologist just looking at the picture... was actually very good. It was 98.1 per cent.
"So there was a big difference between the performance of the dermatologist versus these (other three) applications."
-- The Canadian Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition January 17, 2013 A14
More Your Health
- Back to Top
- Return to Your Health
More Your Health
(1 of 50 articles for this week)
Three companies recall antipsychotic drug quetiapine: Health Canada says
05/18/2013 9:45 PM 0OTTAWA - Health Canada says three companies are voluntarily recalling all lots of the antipsychotic drug quetiapine.
A Health Canada news ...
Poll
Most Popular Your Health
- Three companies recall antipsychotic drug quetiapine: Health Canada says
- WHO warns Saudi coronavirus may be spreading; calls for urgent search for source
- Avoid herpes -- make love like a porcupine
- All the fitness that fits
- Adrenal fatigue can have significant impact
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- Opposition wants inquest into death of woman who left Winnipeg hospital ER
- New Brunswick continues liberation fund for MS patients despite waning interest
- Saved by the kettlebell
- Angelina Jolie's double mastectomy: Q&A
- No evidence cycle helmet laws reduce head injuries: study
- Prosecuting drowsy driving remains an elusive highway dilemma for prosecutors, safety experts
- Kidney problems price we pay for progress
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- Reduced urinary flow a reality for older men
- Opposition wants inquest into death of woman who left Winnipeg hospital ER
- Avoid herpes -- make love like a porcupine
- Years in the making, controversial new psychiatry 'bible' about to launch
- Baby delivery: safe haven baby drop-off sites open in Edmonton hospitals
- Boston Marathon bombing victims face huge medical bills; tens of millions in donations pour in
- Angelina Jolie's double mastectomy: Q&A
- Pharmacy assistant who found diluted cancer drugs says label raised questions
- Auditor general takes aim at residential schools, diabetes prevention
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Hockey commentator Kelly Hrudey shares daughter's struggle with mental illness
- Biomedical engineer designs exercises, tests to battle Alzheimer's
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- No evidence cycle helmet laws reduce head injuries: study
- Kidney problems price we pay for progress
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Ontario Nurses Association seeks moratorium on cuts to registered nursing jobs
- Canadian dies with aid of doctor in Zurich; wished it could have been in Canada
- Prosecuting drowsy driving remains an elusive highway dilemma for prosecutors, safety experts
- No evidence cycle helmet laws reduce head injuries: study
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Biomedical engineer designs exercises, tests to battle Alzheimer's
- AGING AMERICA: Poll finds people in denial about the need for long-term care as they get older
- Adrenal fatigue can have significant impact
- Kidney problems price we pay for progress
- Natural medicine best for lowering cholesterol
- Liberal bill in Senate aims to stop genetic discrimination by insurance firms
- Hockey commentator Kelly Hrudey shares daughter's struggle with mental illness
- Knee repair? Study finds physical therapy as good as surgery for torn cartilage, arthritis
- Federal Court tells Ottawa to reimburse First Nation for disabled child's costs
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.