13°c A few clouds
19°c Variable cloudiness
The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Family of man who died in Winnipeg ER appeals lawsuit ruling
WINNIPEG - The family of a Winnipeg man who died in a hospital emergency room is appealing a court decision that reduced the scope of their lawsuit.
Relatives of Brian Sinclair are appealing a Court of Queen's bench ruling last year that dismissed a section of their statement of claim which said Sinclair's charter rights had been violated.
A hearing is set for Wednesday.
Sinclair, a 45-year-old double amputee, died after waiting for 34 hours in the emergency room of the Health Sciences Centre.
Sinclair's family filed the lawsuit, saying they wanted someone held accountable for what went wrong.
An inquest into the death is expected later this year.
Sinclair was in a wheelchair when he went to the emergency department in September 2008. Hospital security tape showed Sinclair went to the triage desk and spoke to an aide before wheeling himself into the waiting room. That appears to have been his only interaction with staff.
Some 34 hours later, another person in the waiting room approached a security guard to say Sinclair appeared to be dead. Efforts to revive him were unsuccessful. Manitoba's chief medical examiner said Sinclair's death could have been prevented if his blocked catheter had been changed and his infection treated.
Police and the Crown attorneys office investigated the death as to whether charges of criminal negligence or failing to provide the necessities of life might have applied. But they decided no charges were warranted.
The Winnipeg Regional Health Authority has paid out $110,000 in damages to the Sinclair family for loss of care, guidance and companionship.
The family's lawyers had also argued the health authority and the province violated Sinclair's charter rights and allowed the ER to operate even though it constituted a public nuisance to vulnerable, aboriginal patients. But a Court of Queen's Bench justice ruled there was no evidence to back up those claims and dismissed them.
The court, however, did rule that the family could sue the defendants for out-of pocket costs for participating in the upcoming inquest.
More Your Health
- Back to Top
- Return to Your Health
More Your Health
(1 of 24 articles for today)
Voluntary recall of children's medicine: Health Canada
9:28 PM 0OTTAWA - Some child fever medicine has been recalled because of concerns with the quality of one of the ingredients ...
Poll
Most Popular Your Health
- Smoke sales forbidden at pharmacies, health facilities starting May 31
- Canada lifts lifetime ban on gay men giving blood, but some restrictions remain
- H7N9 virus closer to being human transmissible than other bird flu viruses
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- Over one million affected by boil-water advisory in Montreal
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Heating-cooling mats for dogs and cats recalled due to health risk for kids, pets
- Avoid allergen triggers to keep guests safe when barbecuing this summer
- Nova Scotia survey finds drinking alcohol higher than drug use among youth
- Adrenal fatigue can have significant impact
- Smoke sales forbidden at pharmacies, health facilities starting May 31
- Canada lifts lifetime ban on gay men giving blood, but some restrictions remain
- Skin picking gets status as distinct disorder, should help sufferers access help
- Over one million affected by boil-water advisory in Montreal
- New Brunswick discouraging new family doctors from practising: medical residents
- Measles outbreaks flourish in UK years after discredited research tied measles shot to autism
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- Avoid herpes -- make love like a porcupine
- Three companies recall antipsychotic drug quetiapine: Health Canada says
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Baby delivery: safe haven baby drop-off sites open in Edmonton hospitals
- Boston Marathon bombing victims face huge medical bills; tens of millions in donations pour in
- Angelina Jolie's double mastectomy: Q&A
- Pharmacy assistant who found diluted cancer drugs says label raised questions
- Auditor general takes aim at residential schools, diabetes prevention
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Hockey commentator Kelly Hrudey shares daughter's struggle with mental illness
- Baker's cyst A sign of something else
- Biomedical engineer designs exercises, tests to battle Alzheimer's
- No evidence cycle helmet laws reduce head injuries: study
- Canada lifts lifetime ban on gay men giving blood, but some restrictions remain
- Avoid allergen triggers to keep guests safe when barbecuing this summer
- Canada lifts lifetime ban on gay men giving blood, but some restrictions remain
- Skin picking gets status as distinct disorder, should help sufferers access help
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Ontario Nurses Association seeks moratorium on cuts to registered nursing jobs
- Adrenal fatigue can have significant impact
- Canadian dies with aid of doctor in Zurich; wished it could have been in Canada
- Avoid herpes -- make love like a porcupine
- Three companies recall antipsychotic drug quetiapine: Health Canada says
- Measles outbreaks flourish in UK years after discredited research tied measles shot to autism
- Avoid allergen triggers to keep guests safe when barbecuing this summer
- Vitamin C and lysine proven to keep arteries healthy
- Biomedical engineer designs exercises, tests to battle Alzheimer's
- AGING AMERICA: Poll finds people in denial about the need for long-term care as they get older
- Adrenal fatigue can have significant impact
- Kidney problems price we pay for progress
- Natural medicine best for lowering cholesterol
- Canada lifts lifetime ban on gay men giving blood, but some restrictions remain
- Hockey commentator Kelly Hrudey shares daughter's struggle with mental illness
- Skin picking gets status as distinct disorder, should help sufferers access help
- Knee repair? Study finds physical therapy as good as surgery for torn cartilage, arthritis
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.