Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 08/30/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
I recently applauded the Province of Quebec, which is attempting to legalize assisted death. There is no better example of what's wrong with the Charter of Rights and Freedoms when it does not allow freedom from pain on the deathbed. I did not ask for reader response, but received a ton of it.
From WP: "I enjoy your column in the Kelowna Courier and I couldn't agree more on assisted suicide. I'm a volunteer counsellor at a hospice. The problem is that families will not let go, even though the patient is ready for the big trip. I have seen them rescind 'do not resuscitate' and have to remind them this decision is not about them, but the wishes of the patient"
From Medicine Hat: "Thank you, oh thank you. As a veterinarian, I watched in horror the last days of my dying mother. She was for assisted death, but we could do nothing because of our country's religious rule of government. But if it had been a dog, cat or cow, I would have to euthanize because it is the law!"
A reader from the Victoria Times Colonist says: "My thanks for bringing this issue forward, a courageous act and a rare public statement by a physician. Probably you will be attacked by enemies you didn't know you had."
But not everyone sends roses. From Toronto: "The good doctor is skipping a step. What we need is more palliative-care centres to allow quality of life at the end of life. He forgets that pain can be managed."
Another replied: "You tend to ignore the abuses in Holland, Belgium and elsewhere. Please open your mind and investigate before you write. People in Holland carry cards asking not to be killed when taken to a hospital."
From Ottawa: "I despair at what you have written. People must die like Christ did on the cross."
GS writes from Winnipeg: "What about those who suffer from unbearable non-terminal illness? We should be focusing on the degree of suffering a person is willing to live with. I've been tormented by depression and anxiety for over 20 years. If we live in a compassionate society, I should be allowed to end my life by assisted suicide rather than resorting to do-it-yourself methods that may end in more suffering if botched."
From Thunder Bay: "I hope your article generates a groundswell of like-minded opinion. At night, my 96-year-old mother moans and cries to be released from this life. The doctor is unable to relieve her great discomfort. We would not allow a loved pet to suffer this way nor should my mother have to endure such a long parting from this world."
VS says: "As a former nurse, I have seen patients die in inhumane ways. For those who argue we are playing God, we already do it by replacing umpteen body parts."
From LK in Niagara Falls: "Several years ago, my 90-year-old mother was dying and in severe pain. The doctors started a morphine drip and asked if we wanted to keep increasing the dose. We agreed, and she finally died peacefully. Keep up the good work."
An email from JM says: "Debating bigots is a waste of time. Russel Ogden tried debating Margaret Sommerville. She simply tweeted past and present students and filled the room with cronies. Poor Russel was toast before he had a chance to talk."
For the most part, readers were pleased to see Quebec was taking a stance on this controversial issue and they hoped other provinces would do so.
The final tally showed about 70 per cent agreed with assisted death, but the others were dead set against it.
Woody Allen once remarked: "I'm not afraid of dying. I just don't want to be there when it happens." Unfortunately, we have to be there and, at the moment, accept what fate has to offer. Assisted death will not happen tomorrow.
See the website www.docgiff.com.
For comments firstname.lastname@example.org.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 30, 2013 A19
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Alberta investigates 122 cases of E. coli
Certain Symptoms Can Delay Lupus Diagnosis, Researchers Report
Antibiotic Might Raise Heart Risks for Some
No helmet exemption for Sikhs in Ontario
All Pregnant Women Need Flu Shot: Ob/Gyn Group
Wynne won't say whether she'll ban e-cigs
'Bubble Boy' Disease May Be More Common Than Thought
Hospital Discharge a Key Time to Help Smokers Quit
Many With Schizophrenia Say They're Happy: Study
For Kids, Risks of Parental Smoking Persist Long-Term, Study Finds
Certain Antipsychotic Meds Tied to Kidney Problems in Elderly
When Parents Need Care, Daughters Carry the Burden: Study
Fitness May Boost Kids' Brainpower
Education Linked to Activity Levels During the Week
Health Highlights: Aug. 19, 2014
Health Tip: Teach Children Not to Waste Food
Health Tip: Have Jaw Pain?
Drug used in dementia carries kidney risk
Liberia president declares Ebola curfew
Couple with three kids face cancer together
Good Neighbors Are Good for Your Heart, Study Says
Implantable Heart Devices Work, Regardless of Race: Study
Study: Many Seniors Get Unnecessary Cancer Tests
Big Drop in U.S. Heart-Related Hospitalizations and Deaths, Study Finds
WHO Urges Screening of Travelers to Contain Ebola Outbreak
More Children Hit by Cars in September, Experts Say
Lunchbox Hygiene Helps Prevent Foodborne Illness, Expert Says
Health Highlights: Aug. 18, 2014
Emissions tests underway at Nova Scotia mill
HPV Vaccine Protects Against Infection 8 Years Out: Study
Childhood Mental Disability Rates Up, Study Finds
Co-Workers Take Dim View of Women Who Seek Flex Time: Study
Study: Vigorous Exercise Seems Safe for Heart Transplant Recipients
Health Tip: Practice a Well-Balanced Exercise Program
Health Tip: Reducing Your Chances of Heart Disease if You Have Diabetes
Growing unrest sets back Liberia's Ebola fight
A grain of salt
Get up offa that thing: doctor's orders
Ebola health workers battle death, heat, rumours
Early Research With Drug Restores Hair in Patients With Alopecia