Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Online psychological aid helpful in anxious times
Self-analysis tool can be reassuring
Are you worried that you may need psychological help? Or have you been diagnosed with an emotional illness and desire a second opinion? Today, getting speedy appointments isn't easy if you're concerned about mental illness. But there is a way to solve this dilemma. And what should you know about embalmed psychiatrists?
Dr. Michael Van Ameringen is co-director of the Anxiety Disorders Clinic at McMaster University, in Hamilton, Ont. He recently reported to the meeting of the American Psychiatric Association how the Internet can be used to help people self-diagnose emotional illness. Or how the web can also suggest you're not too crazy.
His study reminded me of a psychiatry text I read in medical school. The book contained chapters about schizophrenia, manic depression and many other emotional disorders. But the last chapter was titled, "The rest of us!" It implied we are all a trifle crazy, but most of us not crazy enough to need treatment.
This university study, called MACSCREEN, is available at www.macanxiety.com . It suggests more than 100 questions to assess your emotional status.
I wish I were a fly on the wall to see how many readers click on this website.
You might wonder whether I bothered to answer the questionnaire. You bet I did, out of sheer curiosity to see how it worked. You should also know that I flunked the test by stating that I don't like snakes. This placed me in the phobia category, and MACSREEN says I need help. But I was not alone.
Dr. Ameringen reported that 90 per cent of respondents who took the test met the criteria for a specific problem and should seek treatment. So it's hoped that the MACSCREEN test in the future will speed up the process of getting help to those suffering from anxiety or mood disorders.
Again this study reminded me of what were once called "Ma Bell" psychiatrists in New York City. This wasn't a Big Apple gimmick. Rather, citizens of that city who preferred to remain anonymous could "dial-a-shrink" for help.
New Yorkers no longer had to lie on a couch. Anyone who thought they needed emotional help could call between 10 a.m. and 10 p.m. All they needed was a credit card and a willingness to pay X dollars every 10 minutes.
Dr. Kathleen Habner, the project founder, reported, "Our critics say we lose important information by not being face-to-face. But people tell us their problems in the first few minutes (why not, when it's an expensive telephone call?), whereas help may take several sessions of face-to-face interviews. And by using the telephone, anonymity makes this a powerful tool."
I see some merit in both of these approaches.
Mail from readers that reaches my desk often complains that face-to-face interviews with physicians are no longer what they were in the past. Time has become an expensive commodity.
All too often, patients leave their doctor's office without adequate explanation of their problem. That causes further needless worry.
Several years ago, a psychiatrist in Halifax wrote, with tongue in cheek, that he could help his patients should he himself suffer a devastating illness. For instance, if he lost his eyesight, he could always listen to patients. Even if he lost both arms he could still dictate his notes. And if illness forced him into a wheelchair, all was not lost. His secretary would be available to assist him.
But what if he died? He said this would still not be the end of assistance to his patients. He suggested that the funeral director could embalm his body and place him in a chair.
Then the chair could be programmed to tilt forward every few minutes so patients would believe he was listening to them, and his nod would reassure them.
Today, rapidly changing times cause anxiety and worry. The MACSCREEN website is one way of helping those suffering such grief. They can obtain psychological care as quickly as possible. I'm also sure that anyone who is troubled would prefer telephone help to no help at all.
But obtaining psychiatric help from an embalmed psychiatrist in a rocking chair?
Hmmm, I'll leave that decision to you.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 26, 2009 A21
More Your Health
- Back to Top
- Return to Your Health
Most Popular Your Health
- 'You look fantastic,' Ellen DeGeneres tells beaming Helene Campbell
- New book details Obama's fondness for weed while a Hawaiian high school student
- Alberta police, fire crews, paramedics get help fighting post-traumatic stress
- Schizophrenia drug may help prevent some cancers from recurring: study
- Raise prices of caffeinated alcohol drinks, discourage sale in bars: report
- Doctor house calls part of Ontario plan to keep seniors at home longer
- Tanning-salon restrictions take effect June 15
- Rick Hansen named honorary colonel of military support unit
- Man who beheaded fellow bus passenger thought victim was an alien: supporter
- Tories say Ornge running $14.5-million deficit, according to 2011 documents
- 'You look fantastic,' Ellen DeGeneres tells beaming Helene Campbell
- Man who beheaded fellow bus passenger thought victim was an alien: supporter
- Tanning-salon restrictions take effect June 15
- Gills onions and Compliments salads recalled in Listeria scare
- Schizophrenia drug may help prevent some cancers from recurring: study
- Pandemic flu shot linked to lower rates of death, preterm birth in infants
- Rick Hansen named honorary colonel of military support unit
- Cervical cancer treatment device recalled; couldn't be fully cleaned
- New Zealand raises tobacco taxes sharply, aiming to become smoke-free country
- Saved by the kettlebell
- Report finds poor diet remains recipe for disaster as Canadians get older
- 'You look fantastic,' Ellen DeGeneres tells beaming Helene Campbell
- Man who beheaded fellow bus passenger thought victim was an alien: supporter
- Pros and cons of pacifiers can leave parents pondering what's best for baby
- Double-lung recipient Helene Campbell discharged from hospital
- Tanning-salon restrictions take effect June 15
- Free Viagra and transgender surgery on the chopping block at DND: sources
- UN food envoy provokes Ottawa with findings on hunger and poor diet in Canada
- There is hope for women with decreased sex drives
- Two lung transplant patient Helene Campbell out of hospital, back on treadmill
- Some facts about the cost of mental illness to Canadians
- Gills onions and Compliments salads recalled in Listeria scare
- Rick Hansen named honorary colonel of military support unit
- Schizophrenia drug may help prevent some cancers from recurring: study
- Alberta police, fire crews, paramedics get help fighting post-traumatic stress
- Canada's first-ever mental health strategy will pressure Harper to act
- Ontario cutting hundreds of OHIP fees paid to doctors as talks reach standstill
- Saskatchewan toddler strapped to back of ATV survives underwater plunge
- Expansion of B.C. insulin pump program would save millions, says CDA
- Pros and cons of pacifiers can leave parents pondering what's best for baby
- Report finds poor diet remains recipe for disaster as Canadians get older
- Important to find out reason for fatigue
- Fat cat dies of respiratory distress
- U.S. FDA warns of injuries, deaths linked to 'liberation therapy' for MS
- Alzheimer's focus shifts to testing therapies earlier, before patients show many symptoms
- Natural medicine best for lowering cholesterol
- There is hope for women with decreased sex drives
- Seven fired after privacy breach at Peterborough, Ont., hospital
- Stressed out? Turn off email
Ads by Google









You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010; View the changes. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.