Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 05/3/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
What would you do in this situation? The patient is paralyzed, incontinent of bowel and urinary functions, unable to take nourishment and obviously in pain. I doubt anyone, regardless of race or religion, would disagree with a lethal injection if the patient were a beloved dog. But humans in most nations are denied this right.
Currently, a tennis partner of mine is in this same condition, along with Alzheimer's disease. His has been a frightful sight to watch as it progressed as surely as night follows day. He no longer knows me, stares day after day at blank walls. I know from past talks he would prefer a dignified death.
Alzheimer's disease has been labelled the Grey Tsunami, and it has huge implications for families and our health-care system. Every 70 seconds, a new case of Alzheimer's disease is diagnosed in North America. This means one in 11 seniors will develop this disease. Currently 5.3 million Americans and 500,000 Canadians suffer from it and related dementia. It's small wonder Alzheimer's disease is the second-most-feared disease.
Some researchers say that it's possible, by a combination of physical and mental activity, to improve brain activity. But there's a problem. My friend was as active physically and mentally as anyone I know. He was an ardent athlete, spoke two languages, devoured figures of the Wall Street Journal daily. Now he can't add 2+2 and I doubt anything could have been done to change this outcome. Once Alzheimer's strikes, the rules of the game are fixed.
Today North Americans are living longer and it's extremely dangerous to get older. Some will develop Lou Gehrig's disease, or a number of other chronic degenerative problems that make life a living hell at the end.
It's ironic that we have a Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, but no such society for humans. Unfortunately, even expressing an opinion today about assisted death is hazardous. As Voltaire remarked, "It is dangerous to be right when the government is wrong."
When I express my opinion on assisted death, a vocal minority invariably says I want to exterminate the sick and establish death camps. They question whether I ever went to medical school or why I don't accept God. This is an unjust judgment when I've spent my life saving lives. Moreover, polls indicate a majority of North Americans agree with doctor-assisted death. It's absurd that Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms provides freedom in so many questionable ways, yet is so inhumane when it comes to the right to die with dignity.
I do not promote assisted death to anyone. But in a democratic nation, we should be allowed to sign a legal document stating if we become thoughtless, incontinent and immobile, we can choose this action.
One of Harvard's most distinguished medical professors once remarked, "The secret of caring for the patient is caring for the patient." But after years of caring for patients, he himself developed a devastating, fatal illness. Just before he committed suicide, he left a note saying, "It's wrong that society forced me to end my life this way without help."
But change is in the air. There's growing support for the people's right to self-determination. Assisted death is now permitted in seven countries and states and is being debated in Canada, New Zealand, Australia and Britain.
Recently, Montana's Supreme Court ruled physicians cannot be prosecuted for prescribing lethal medication for terminally ill patients.
Opponents cry that abuses will abound if this legislation is passed. But history proves otherwise. Oregon's legislation was passed in 1998 without triggering an epidemic of assisted deaths. Even in Switzerland, the most liberal of all nations, assisted deaths account for only 0.5 per cent of deaths in that country.
The point is that there should be no need to buy a one-way ticket to Zurich. It's time to talk about it, as no one will care as much about how you die as you will.
See the website www.docgiff.com For comments, email@example.com
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition May 3, 2013 A19
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Almost 3,000 CCAC workers on strike: union
Some doctors won't see patients with anti-vaccine views
More Evidence That Boxing Can Lead to Brain Damage
Tamiflu Cuts 1 Day Off Average Flu Bout, Study Finds
More Measles Cases Seen in January Than in Typical Year: CDC
Flu vaccine offered little or no protection
Early Birds May Catch the Worm, but Night Owls May Snatch the Win
Too Much Alcohol at Midlife Raises Stroke Risk, Study Finds
Nurses call for better security at hospital
Heart surgeon suing Alberta Health Services
Good Sleep Habits, Enforced Rules Help Kids Sleep: Study
Acne Gel Linked to Rare Side Effect, Doctors Warn
Flu's Grip on U.S. Starting to Weaken: CDC
A look at conditions on Manitoba First Nations
Black breast-feeding gatherings battle troubling health gaps
Manitoba one of worst places for natives: reports
Trial to test stem cells in MS patients
Fraser Health urges parents to vaccinate kids
Saskatchewan NDP criticizes Lean job posting
Diabetes Patients Lax With Meds If Diagnosed With Cancer, Study Finds
Little Improvement in Children Paralyzed After Viral Infection, Study Finds
Day to promote awareness of mental health raises $6M
Ontario's organ donations set new record
Winnipeggers hoping for clean water tests
Boil-water advisory lifted for Winnipeg
Health Tip: Using Sunscreen
Health Tip: Handling Your Child's Fears About Weight
Health Highlights: Jan. 29, 2015
Eye Tracking May Help to Spot Concussions Quickly
Binge-Watching TV May Be Sign of Depression, Loneliness
Nearly 1 in 10 Adults Skips Meds Due to Cost, CDC Says
Howe's stem cell treatment raises concerns
WHO: Ebola response shifts to ending epidemic
Measles outbreak with Disney park origins grows to 95 cases
Group draws attention to paramedic suicides
Liberals, Independents Win Life Span Sweepstakes, Study Claims
Rally to urge action on new cancer centre
Ebola Vaccine Appears Safe, Triggers Immune Response, U.K. Study Finds
Following Blood Pressure Guidelines Saves Lives, Dollars: Study
Have Insurers Found Way Around Obamacare 'Pre-Existing Conditions' Rule?