Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 02/3/2014 11:06 AM | Comments: 0
The Bipole III Coalition filed its submission today with Manitoba’s Public Utilities Board calling for a "slow down" of Manitoba Hydro’s plan to build two new generating stations.
The coalition says the plan to build Keeyask and Conawapa will cost $34 billion.
The PUB’s review of Hydro’s plan is to begin is to begin March 3. The Needs For and Alternatives To (NFAT) hearing is scheduled to end May 3. The PUB is to issue its report to the Manitoba government by June 20.
The coalition says Hydro’s growth forecast, the basis of its expansion plan, is overstated and does not reflect Manitoba's future demand for electricity.
"Using Hydro’s own records, the coalition's submission demonstrates that Hydro's load forecast does not properly reflect the flattening of load growth in Manitoba over the past eight years," the group says in a news release. "It is also out of line with forecasts of modest load growth in the U.S. including the northern regions into which Hydro exports electrical energy."
The Crown power utility says it needs to build the Keeyask and Conawapa generating stations in the next decade not only to meet the province's energy needs, but to meet demands south of the border and to the east and west.
The Selinger government has said domestic demand is forecast to rise 80 megawatts a year.
Hydro's plan calls for the start of construction of the 695-megawatt Keeyask generating station in June 2014, with the first turbine to start spinning by 2019. That’s to be followed by construction of the 1,485-megawatt Conawapa generating station, with a 2026 in-service date.
The forecasted price tag for Keeyask is $6.2 billion and Conawapa is estimated to cost $10.2 billion. There will be an additional cost of running a transmission line to the Minnesota border.
The coalition says it proposes a more reasonable load forecast which better reflects current energy trends in Manitoba and the northern regions of the U.S.
"With the more defensible forecast, the coalition demonstrates that the in-service date for the next generation plant could be delayed until at least seven years," it says.
Hydro and the NDP argue export sales will rebound when natural gas prices rise and more coal-fired power plants in the U.S. either close or switch to natural gas.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Beyoncé and Jay Z put on hell of a stadium show
Man in suspicious downtown fire has died
18-year-old woman dies after rollover in Gimli
UN Security Council calls for Gaza cease-fire
Paralympian seeks return of stolen medals
Goldeyes pummel Railcats
Cyclist Kirchmann finishes third in La Course
Growing movement to treat PTSD in responders
Woman claims she plucked bird on subway
Greg Maddux inducted in baseball Hall of Fame
PM's wife gets stinging reception
Man, 35, missing: city police
Residential school survivors have physical scars
Ebola kills top Liberian doctor, American infected
Gaza war rages despite Hamas, Israel truce pledges
Fighting intensifies near MH17 disaster site
Cottage country captivating
Joust in time
Clooney loved taking on tabloid
Pratt stars at track in role as honorary Hoosier
Retired Canadian astronaut had career doubts
Four tips for a low-stress vacation
Different kind of jam session
Therese Casgrain removed from public history
O'Shea likes Blue's ability to refocus after tough loss to Esks
City dangerous by design
Italy's Vincenzo Nibali wins Tour de France
Six-year-old dead after car rams Costco
Look who's talking impeachment: the White House
Fido feels jealousy, study proposes
Franklin demands respect
Winnipeg was at a crossroads when it answered the call to arms in 1914
Typhoon Matmo kills 13 people in China
Police issue alert for missing woman
Grey day ahead
Woman dies after being hit by a car on Highway 10
Stony Mountain firm expects to cash in when drones take off
Distracted driving's most stark example
Harper says Canada must stay course on Russia
Israel says it's extending Gaza truce for 24 hours