Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 03/10/2014 12:05 PM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 03/10/2014 2:48 PM | Updates
The Canadian Museum for Human Rights is weathering a censorship allegation after deleting a blog post it commissioned from a Tyrell medal-winning Canadian historian.
To coincide with International Women’s Day, the Winnipeg-based museum asked Veronica Strong-Boag, a historian specializing in the history of women and children in Canada, to pen a blog post in her area of expertise.
The post appeared on March 4, but was removed hours later after museum staff deemed a passage criticizing the federal Conservative government unacceptable.
The passage in question described the Conservatives as having an "anti-woman record." She said museum staff first asked her to back up that claim, but ultimately rejected a footnoted posting as a partisan statement.
In a letter to Strong-Boag, museum communications director Angela Cassie apologized for failing to explain what was expected from blog-post authors.
"We will more clearly ask that guest blogs consist of anecdotal accounts of first-person experiences that illuminate human rights themes," Cassie wrote. "We also make efforts to ensure that guest blogs not be used as, or be perceived as, a platform for political positions or partisan statements."
In a response letter, Strong-Boag called Cassie’s statement "naive and pedagogically unsound" for a museum "supposedly dedicated" to promoting human rights.
"It suggests that human rights are almost purely about entertainment and that authors can pretend impartiality in dealing with them," Strong-Boag wrote.
Strong-Boag said when she was asked to back up her "anti-woman" claim, she cited the Conservatives’ cancellation of plans for a national child care program, cuts to Status of Women Canada, the prohibition of civil servants taking pay equity complaints to the Human Rights Commission, the denial of international funding for abortion and cuts to public services that employ and serve women.
Strong-Boag said she was surprised when the post was still rejected.
"As long we indicate where our evidence comes from and provide access to that evidence, I can’t imagine there would be any difficulty," she said, describing the museum’s decision as an example of censorship.
Maureen Fitzhenry, the museum’s media relations manager, rejected the assertion the museum was impinging upon academic freedom.
-CMHR's Maureen Fitzhenry
"At a university, of course that’s a legitimate discussion. We are a museum. There’s a legitimate conversation about academic freedom among our own staff. In this case, it was a guest blog," she said.
"This isn’t a question of academic freedom, it’s a question of what we think we are wanting for our blog posts."
Strong-Boag is a visiting scholar at Trent University, a professor emerita at University of British Columbia, a former president of the Canadian Historical Association and the 2012 winner of the Tyrell medal for outstanding work in Canadian history.
The Canadian Museum for Human Rights, which is slated to open this fall, has weathered criticism from departed staff who claimed the museum’s content has been watered down to reflect more positive Canadian stories.
The museum has rejected that assertion as unbalanced.
Updated on Monday, March 10, 2014 at 2:48 PM CDT: corrects typo
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Ouellette would expand donor disclosure rules for mayor, councillors
Medical examiner calls inquests into three suicides
Developers' cash wanted like a sore thumb
Havixbeck says hiring freeze necessary after city's financial outlook downgraded
Siloam Mission's basement flooded again after storm
Maryk's sentencing in child abduction case delayed until Sept. 11
The greening of Elphaba the Wicked Witch in Wicked
Dad's slaying devastated teen
Poll shows many white Americans see race getting too much attention
Crane River teen last seen in Winnipeg
Despite consecutive losses, Bombers don't see Als contest as a must-win
Crop-production drop expected
Snubbed candidates fuming
Sin City sequel stylish, but too much sordid sex and violence beats viewers to a pulp
Province's retailers ring up $1.5-B worth of sales in June; up slightly over May
Manitoba's inflation rate falls in June
Royal Bank Q3 profit up 4% to $2.4 billion
2 UofO hockey players charged with sex assault
Palliser goes platinum
Get ready for some more rain
Alcohol a factor in teen ATV driver's collision with vehicle
UN: death toll from Syrian civil war tops 191,000
Gaza militants kill 18 alleged spies for Israel
Union sorry for appearing to trivialize racism
US, EU, NATO condemn Russian aid convoy move
German man evicted for squeaky swing set sex prop
India blocks film on Indira Gandhi assassination