Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 05/6/2013 3:21 PM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 05/6/2013 5:17 PM | Updates
Finance Minister Stan Struthers has to obey the law -- at least until he changes it. That was the ruling this afternoon from Justice Robert Dewar in a dispute between the Selinger government and the Manitoba Jockey Club, which operates Assiniboia Downs.
Dewar ordered Struthers to release funds to Assiniboia Downs raised through a levy on wagering at the track, money that supports purse winnings there.
"Governments, and ministers, cannot do anything they please," Dewar stated in a 25-page written ruling released this afternoon.
The Manitoba Jockey Club (MJC) was challenging the Selinger government's plan to slash $5 million in funding the MJC receives through VLT revenues and money distributed by the Horse Racing Commission from a levy on every bet made at the track.
In last month's budget speech, Struthers said the government planned to redirect monies that had been going to the track to other government programs.
The MJC alleged the funding cut is illegal and part of the government's plan to force the club into bankruptcy and turn over Assiniboia Downs to its neighbour, the Red River Exhibition.
The MJC asked the court for an order keeping the money in place until proper negotiations have taken place. The club has also asked the RCMP to investigate its allegations and Struthers's actions.
Dewar said the betting fund was set up to benefit the racing community and Struthers was delaying its release to the MJC because he wanted to spend it elsewhere. However, that money – for now – belongs to the horse-racing community, not the province, Dewar said.
"The province has no proprietary interest in these monies," Dewar stated, and ordered Struthers to release the funds.
Dewar said the VLT revenue also belongs to the MJC through a contract with Manitoba Lotteries. However, Dewar said the government could pass a law which breaks the Lotteries contract and remove the VLTs now at the track. But until that law is passed, Dewar said, the VLT monies belong to the MJC.
Jockey club CEO Darren Dunn said he was relieved with the court ruling, adding the government's actions have scared away horse owners from the track.
Struthers is holding a news conference this afternoon to comment on the court ruling.
Updated on Monday, May 6, 2013 at 5:17 PM CDT: Corrects typos.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
CRA 'accidentally' gives CBC tax info
NDP MP says she's open to misconduct probe
Crocus wants to recoup costs from Canad Inns
Winnipeg candidates eye new campaigns
Hutchinson's hand still hot
Protesters return to riot-scarred Ferguson streets
Municipalities to get more input on mosquito-fogging rules
Butt thought 'don't ruin' Corner Gas movie
Hong Kong police arrest student protest leaders
Canucks salute late Pat Quinn with ceremony
Protests against Ferguson decision grow across US
'Bannock Lady' faces $3,000 in tickets; vehicle seized
Head of Winnipeg Regional Health Authority stepping down after five years at the helm
Ghomeshi withdraws lawsuit against CBC
Father pleased outlet published victim's name
City endorses plan for 'Precinct E' while questions are raised about costs for services
Manitoba Hydro to begin expropriating land for Bipole III hydro transmission line
Winnipeg joins in on UN campaign to end violence against women
Councillors growing weary of last-minute reports from the city administration
Zoo's harbour seal dies after getting caught in drain
Vets wait eight months for benefits: auditor
Flin Flon RCMP looking for 40-year-old man who approached 11-year-old girl near school
City to study how pipeline could affect Shoal Lake and aqueduct
CancerCare Manitoba setting up a virtual cancer hub to guide patients after diagnosis
City looking for ways to help residents with accessibility issues clear windrows
Commons committee tasked with making sexual harassment policy asks for more info
Jets down to 20th on Forbes' list of NHL teams
Manitoba appeal court to review 27-year-old murder conviction
Archives failing to preserve memory: auditor
BlackBerry will pay iPhone users to switch
City agrees to sell former Kenaston snow dump for $5.2m
Magnotta doesn't testify as defence rests
Reitmans shutting down Smart Set stores
Police bust North End grow-op and seize marijuana plants worth $292K
Police make renewed call for help in locating Colten Pratt, 26, missing since Nov. 6
Judge's long ordeal finally over
Pharma giant Valeant Canada makes major investment in Steinbach plant
Court hears from Manitoba mom fighting parental abduction charge