Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 01/4/2013 2:10 PM | Comments: 0
There’s at least a tiny bit of good news in the grounding of an oil rig in the Beaufort Sea off Alaska: As of Wednesday, the Kulluk, which ran aground near Kodiak Island, didn’t appear to be leaking fuel, thanks to its double hull of three-inch-thick steel. We’ve learned some things about oil and safety since the Exxon Valdez.
But the overwhelming lesson of the Kulluk, which broke free of boats trying to tow it to Seattle after its first season in the Beaufort Sea, is that for all the precautions taken by Royal Dutch Shell, neither the company’s executives nor federal regulators were fully prepared for the hazardous conditions in the Arctic.
The rig, which has no propulsion system of its own, was being towed for maintenance before beginning its next season of drilling in the spring. That’s supposed to be the routine: a spring-summer drilling season that ends Oct. 31, with the rig then towed to milder climates for the winter. But there were delays because of weather and equipment problems, including a lack of de-icing capability on the helicopters that were supposed to transport most of the crew off the rig before it could be moved. As a result, the towing didn’t begin until the difficult days of winter.
It’s the most recent in a long list of problems that Shell has encountered. Its failure to build an Arctic-worthy containment dome and spill-response barge kept it from drilling this year to depths where it might reach oil. In November, the U.S. Coast Guard found serious deficiencies involving pollution controls and crew safety in the Noble Discoverer, the drilling ship Shell used in the Chukchi Sea.
At least the Noble Discoverer was gone from the Chukchi by that time, because the drilling season there ends Sept. 24, before ice, high seas and storms have a greater chance of imperiling operations. At a minimum, taking into account the problems the Kulluk encountered in late October, federal regulators should consider a similar date for the Beaufort Sea.
But that would only begin to address the issues. The grounding of the Kulluk occurred within 80 kilometres of a major Coast Guard facility, allowing for a quick response. But what if the same problems had been encountered 1,200 kilometres away? In just the first season of Royal Shell’s Arctic operations, the region already has proved to be a far more perilous place for oil exploration than proponents foresaw. The rigs probably should not head back to the Arctic seas this spring; federal regulators will be endangering a valuable and fragile environmental resource if they don’t reexamine what’s needed to drill safely under the most challenging conditions.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
CRA 'accidentally' gives CBC tax info
NDP MP says she's open to misconduct probe
Crocus wants to recoup costs from Canad Inns
Winnipeg candidates eye new campaigns
Hutchinson's hand still hot
Protesters return to riot-scarred Ferguson streets
Municipalities to get more input on mosquito-fogging rules
Butt thought 'don't ruin' Corner Gas movie
Hong Kong police arrest student protest leaders
Canucks salute late Pat Quinn with ceremony
Protests against Ferguson decision grow across US
'Bannock Lady' faces $3,000 in tickets; vehicle seized
Head of Winnipeg Regional Health Authority stepping down after five years at the helm
Ghomeshi withdraws lawsuit against CBC
Father pleased outlet published victim's name
City endorses plan for 'Precinct E' while questions are raised about costs for services
Manitoba Hydro to begin expropriating land for Bipole III hydro transmission line
Winnipeg joins in on UN campaign to end violence against women
Councillors growing weary of last-minute reports from the city administration
Zoo's harbour seal dies after getting caught in drain
Vets wait eight months for benefits: auditor
Flin Flon RCMP looking for 40-year-old man who approached 11-year-old girl near school
City to study how pipeline could affect Shoal Lake and aqueduct
CancerCare Manitoba setting up a virtual cancer hub to guide patients after diagnosis
City looking for ways to help residents with accessibility issues clear windrows
Commons committee tasked with making sexual harassment policy asks for more info
Jets down to 20th on Forbes' list of NHL teams
Manitoba appeal court to review 27-year-old murder conviction
Archives failing to preserve memory: auditor
BlackBerry will pay iPhone users to switch
City agrees to sell former Kenaston snow dump for $5.2m
Magnotta doesn't testify as defence rests
Reitmans shutting down Smart Set stores
Police bust North End grow-op and seize marijuana plants worth $292K
Police make renewed call for help in locating Colten Pratt, 26, missing since Nov. 6
Judge's long ordeal finally over
Pharma giant Valeant Canada makes major investment in Steinbach plant
Court hears from Manitoba mom fighting parental abduction charge