Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 03/11/2013 9:20 AM
Last Modified: 03/11/2013 1:20 PM | Updates
The lawyer for Intertribal Child and Family Services says relatives of Karl Wes McKay who reported he killed his stepdaughter, Phoenix Sinclair, should have to testify publicly at the inquiry into her death and not be protected by a publication ban.
Hafeez Khan said there’s no legal justification for protecting the identities of three of McKay’s children and a former spouse.
They’ve applied for a publication ban to keep their names and images out of the media for fear of harassment because of their connection to McKay.
In 2008, he and Phoenix’s mother, Samantha Kematch, were convicted of her 2005 murder.
The five-year-old was killed in June 2005. Her body wasn’t found until March 2006 when her half-brothers told their mom, who reported it.
An inquiry into her death began in September to find out how her case fell through Manitoba’s social-safety net. It has been beset by legal delays. One of those was by social workers whose union fought to have their identities hidden under a publication ban. Now, the lawyer for Intertribal Child and Family Services is fighting a publication ban that would protect the identities of witnesses related to McKay.
Affidavits filed on behalf of McKay’s sons’ say people they work and go to school with don’t know about their father. Their mom’s affidavit says her coworkers don’t know about her former spouse’s gruesome crime, either, and she wants to keep it that way, the inquiry heard.
They testified nearly five years ago at McKay’s criminal trial where they weren’t protected by a publication ban but should have been, said their lawyer Bill Gange.
After their criminal trial testimony, they experienced harassment, their affidavits say.
Having to testify publicly at the inquiry is causing anxiety to her sons, said McKay’s former spouse.
An adult daughter of McKay's said in her affidavit that her children don’t know the identity of their grandfather, McKay.
Khan said no evidence was produced to prove that they were harassed.
The media has not challenged the publication ban. The ban they’re requesting would allow the witnesses to testify at the inquiry by video that spectators could hear but only Commissioner Ted Hughes could see.
Hughes asked Intertribal Child and Family Services’ lawyer Khan several times to explain why his clients wanted the witnesses’ identities made public.
"What purpose it would serve to identify those witnesses?" Hughes asked.
Khan didn’t explain why his clients want the witnesses publicly identified. The lawyer did say one of the witnesses requesting the publication ban is expected to give testimony that will be different from that of Intertribal Child Family Services’ witnesses. Khan argued there is no legal reason for a publication ban to be allowed for McKay’s relatives.
The hearing into the publication ban continues this afternoon when Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs’ lawyer Jay Funke is expected to argue against it.
Updated on Monday, March 11, 2013 at 1:20 PM CDT: Adds evidence from morning's proceedings.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Selinger addresses party convention, steers clear of leadership race
Shuffling chairs in face of an iceberg
Community discusses Kapyong urban reserve plan
Police HQ flood renovation costs $4.1 million - so far
Winnipeg girl escapes grasp of attacker
Injury could sideline Byfuglien up to four weeks
Live on Sunday: NDP leadership vote
Police asking for 1.9 per cent increase in budget
Five years for man who abused daughter over five years
Police seek help in finding missing woman
Eadie blasts frontage levy as unfair
Gunman blamed shooting on military operations
Sex offender sought by police
Wynne unveils plan to end sexual violence
Wireless spectrum auction raises $2.11B
Provincial ombudsmen express concern over anti-terrorism bill
Pallister compares NDP to Ringling Brothers
Manitoba falls to P.E.I. at Tim Hortons Brier
Committee counts late-arriving delegate ballots from Swan River
Women: The hidden homeless
New trial for convicted killer
Director on hand for Freeze Frame screening of Pim and Pom
Missing St. Laurent teen last seen in Winnipeg
New exhibition explores Nunavut's origins
On the trail of a great white: tracking Lydia
Need for shelter never wanes
Beer with him
Kinsmen seek assurances for city pool
Women's game has even more room to grow
Three charged after drugs found in Portage la Prairie home
Homeless, mentally ill get to work on creativity
Local farming app among finalists in national competition
Myers has adapted quickly; stellar play has been godsend for the Jets
Wilco, Arlo Guthrie to perform at 2015 Winnipeg Folk Festival
Light snow expected, warmer temperatures for the weekend
Another delegate controversy
Finding her home away from home
Sri Lanka suspends work on China-backed resort
Ringling Bros. says circuses to be elephant-free in 3 years
UNESCO calls destruction of ancient Iraq site 'war crime'