18°c A few clouds
Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Publication ban would 'make a mockery' of Phoenix Sinclair inquiry: lawyer
Ruling expected next week
Kim Edwards holds the only photograph she has of foster daugher Phoenix Sinclair. . Edwards cared for Phoenix before the girl was returned to the care of her biological mother. (MIKE APORIUS / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS ) Photo Store
A lawyer representing the family of a Phoenix Sinclair argued today against a publication ban that would shield the identities of social workers involved in the girl’s case, saying it would make a mockery of the inquiry to look into her death.
Hearings continued Friday at the inquiry to examine the circumstances around the death of five-year-old Sinclair, who was killed by her mother and stepfather in 2005.
Jeffrey Gindin, the lawyer acting for Phoenix’s former foster mother Kim Edwards and biological father Steve Sinclair, said having a publication ban in place on professionals involved in Phoenix’s care would undermine the inquiry.
Gindin said there are people who have waited "an awful long time" for the inquiry to happen, and a ban – if granted - would "make a mockery of the inquiry."
Gindin said arguments in favour of the ban – which one lawyer said earlier this week would make social workers "game for the bloody-minded" - have been speculative and vague.
"It doesn’t matter that some people don’t want to have an inquiry, or that an inquiry is difficult on some people," said Gindin.
"Nobody wants to testify anywhere. (In) my experience in 40 years, I’ve never met somebody who wants to come to court and testify. Nobody wants to, but they have to."
Hughes will render his decision about the publication ban next Thursday.
Winnipeg Sun columnist Tom Brodbeck also appeared before retired judge Ted Hughes Friday morning over footage he took Wednesday of the room where the inquiry proceedings were happening.
The video was later posted to the Winnipeg Sun website. Inquiry rules state there was only one video camera and operator allowed in the hearing room to share the footage amongst media outlets. Brodbeck told Hughes allegations he filmed the proceedings were false, but acknowledged he filmed the room Wednesday when the hearing wasn't underway.
"I wish to clarify that at no time did I film or videotape the proceedings of this inquiry," said Brodbeck.
Hughes called Brodbeck's actions "disappointing," but accepted Brodbeck’s explanation and said he considered the incident a "one-off."
"I think you understand now that they’ll be no more of that," he said.
Phoenix Sinclair was abused and killed in her home after child-welfare workers took her out of foster care and returned her to her mother. She went missing for more than nine months before her remains were discovered in a landfill on the Fisher River First Nation in 2006.
According to evidence in the first-degree murder trial that led to life sentences for her mother and stepfather, Phoenix was frequently confined, shot with a BB gun and forced to eat her own vomit.
Gabrielle.giroday@freepress.mb.ca
With files from Canadian Press
More Latest News
- Back to Top
- Return to Latest News
More Latest News
(1 of 47 articles for today)
Jockey club launches $350-M civil suit against province
5:43 PM 0
Poll
Most Popular Latest News
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Flood money paid for CEO's romantic trip
- Crash claims two young women, RCMP say
- Vendor fired at Houston's Minute Maid Park after taking tray of snow cones into bathroom
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- Some good news, some bad news from weatherman
- Catching up with the Jets
- Abrupt departure for Mayor Rob Ford's chief of staff amid 'crack video' scandal
- Ottawa threatens 'retaliatory measures' over new U.S. meat labelling regulations
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- 87-year-old woman tells jurors, 'Somebody had to stand up to' Donald Trump
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Horrific crash kills minivan driver near Brandon
- Charleswood deaths being investigated as domestic incident
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Woman killed in head-on crash in southwestern Manitoba
- Winnipeg woman camps out in front of legislature to protest child welfare
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Seattle man dribbling soccer ball to Brazil killed by car on Oregon Coast
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- 87-year-old woman tells jurors, 'Somebody had to stand up to' Donald Trump
- Driver crashes into tree near golf course
- Arrests made after raids on local head shops
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- News of city's $17-million winner leaks out on FB
- Passengers from diverted flight to leave Winnipeg Thursday night
- No threat from bag found at Winnipeg Square
- Susan Griffiths dies in Switzerland
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Youths in Stockholm burn down restaurant, torch more than 30 cars in 4th night of rioting
- Landslide of love for Fleetwood Mac
- Horrific crash kills minivan driver near Brandon
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Vendor fired at Houston's Minute Maid Park after taking tray of snow cones into bathroom
- Quicker pickup of bulk garbage urged
- Privacy commissioner wants power to impose 8-figure fines against offenders
- Winnipeg Harvest issues plea for donations
- Fire crews kept busy battling south Winnipeg, Point Douglas fires
- New owner for lumber stores
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- Horrific crash kills minivan driver near Brandon
- Marsh Madness: Photographers Fred Greenslade and Joe Bryksa capture spring migration's grandeur at Delta Marsh
- Prominent Canadians back petition to rename Victoria Day to honour aboriginals
- Famous city grocer loved job, customers
- Animals are animals, new ads say
- Skin picking gets status as distinct disorder, should help sufferers access help
- New owner for lumber stores
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Dogs can experience separation anxiety and depression just like humans
- Ontario steps in to help save ELA
- Saskatchewan professor wants to test the health benefits of nose-picking
- 'Revenge of the redheads': Ginger-haired Montrealers gather in celebration
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- An uncommon phenomenon
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- Passengers from diverted flight to leave Winnipeg Thursday night
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.