Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 02/5/2013 3:25 PM | Comments: 0
Reports critical of the way Phoenix Sinclair’s case was handled by Winnipeg Child and Family Services were not to be shared with the staff involved, said the woman in charge at the time. At the inquiry into the little girl’s death, Darlene MacDonald testified today that she was ordered not to.
"I was asked to keep the reports confidential and not share them with anyone," said MacDonald, who was the CEO of CFS then and is now the Children’s Advocate.
"I think there were people above me who made that decision."
The three reports were written after Phoenix’s 2005 death came to light in 2006. The five-year-old’s body was discovered buried at Fisher River First Nation and in 2008 her mother Samantha Kematch and stepfather Karl "Wes" McKay were convicted of her murder.
In 2011, the province ordered an inquiry to determine how Phoenix slipped through Manitoba’s child-welfare safety net. Phoenix had been involved with Winnipeg CFS from the time she was born until her family left Winnipeg for the reserve in 2005, the year she was murdered.
Soon after her death was discovered in 2006, investigations began. The chief medical examiner, an independent third party and an internal review were conducted.
The social workers and supervisors criticized in those reports were never informed of the findings concerning their role in the case. They didn’t find out until years later, when the commission of inquiry was ordered and they were contacted by commission counsel.
Several of the workers who have testified said they wished they’d seen the reports’ findings about their involvement in the case – they might have learned something from it.
MacDonald said she assumed that the reports were to be kept secret because an inquiry would be called.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Boil-water advisory issued for entire city as precautionary measure
Ambulance delays cost WRHA $1.4 million
Rusty Jets spanked by Pens
More help promised for Manitoba child welfare in light of Phoenix Sinclair inquiry
Gunmen storm Libya hotel, killing American, 9 others
Brother charged for alleged assault on boyfriend
Oswald makes campaign pledge to boost workplace health and safety enforcement
Firm fined $4,800 for massive fire
Big banks cut prime rate to 2.85 per cent
Watchdogs want Conservative bill quashed
Obama floats offering first-ever drilling lease in Atlantic
Dog killed during break-in
Mom who used iron to scald boy loses appeal
Super Bowl, Tiger make Phoenix centre of sports universe
Mayor Bowman to launch a website to solicit ideas on beating racism
Grain shippers face railway backlog: report
Electronic music duo Purity Ring to play Garrick in June
Smith wins 1st tiebreaker at junior championships
Tim Hortons lays off staff at headquarters
Thieves smash stolen SUV into San Francisco museum for gold
Mexico: Investigation shows that all 43 students are dead
Michelle Obama navigates limits on women in Saudi Arabia
Snubs, surprises of this year's Juno nominations
Goaltender Martin Brodeur to retire
Cinematheque program explores how novels translate into films
Balanced books possible amid oil slump: PBO
Facebook blames glitch for global outage
Teen acquitted in fatal assault
RCMP arrest Portage la Prairie man in sexual assault case dating back to 2013
Marriott buying Delta Hotel & Resorts brand
Manitobans earn 12 Juno nominations
Big-box chain Lowe's could replace Targets here
Paramedics scare off suspect of attempted abduction
Mom heading to Australia with son aquitted of abduction
Documentary chronicles "Clara's Big Ride"
Passenger traffic increases in airport's fourth quarter
Monarch butterflies rebound in Mexico, numbers still low
Blizzard howls its way into Boston but largely spares NYC
Japan's Abe calls latest hostage deadline 'despicable'
On Auschwitz anniversary, leader warns Jews again targets