Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 05/10/2013 7:36 AM | Comments: 0
OTTAWA — A third of Manitoba’s communities won’t get a snapshot of their populations from the new National Household Survey because too few people answered the questionnaire.
The survey was done for the first time in 2011 as a replacement for the mandatory long-form census, which the Conservatives chose to ditch after citing privacy issues.
Although more people filled out the voluntary NHS in 2011 than filled out the mandatory longform census in 2006, the distribution of responses left one in three Manitoba communities — 33.8 per cent — without enough data to be reliable. That includes 97 of the 287 municipalities and districts including 46 rural municipalities, 17 First Nations, 18 towns, six villages, one local government district, as well as a handful of unorganized areas.
Nationally, data are lacking from one in four communities, or 1,128 municipalities. Saskatchewan had the worst record with 43 per cent of the communities seeing their data lacking.
"If you want to know what is going on socio-economically for (these places), there is no data," said Wilf Falk, Manitoba’s chief statistician.
All nine of Manitoba’s cities have data, said Falk, although there are pockets within each city where data will be less reliable.
Some of the communities with no data provided are among the province’s largest towns and municipalities, including the towns of Minnedosa, Lac du Bonnet, Arborg and Boissevain, and the RMs of Killarney-Turtle Mountain, Brokenhead and Dauphin, Falk said.
Doug Dobrowolski, chairman of the Association of Manitoba Municipalities, said it’s a big issue for local governments because so much of their funding programs and policies are directed by data from the census.
"A lot of municipalities depend on the census," he said. "There’s a lot of money that will be lost here."
Dobrowolski said municipalities use them to determine what kind of recreational services need to be provided, to anticipate health-care needs, and to track progress on certain issues.
Falk said if someone wanted to know whether there were improvements to educational attainments on the 17 First Nations that are fully or partly excluded from the data, this survey wouldn’t provide it. It’s also difficult to compare any data from the NHS to the 2006 census because the methodology is different, Falk said.
He said it is believed the NHS will have been skewed toward people who are more likely to be young, tech savvy and affluent because the most common way people filled out the NHS was online. Older Canadians, new Canadians and those with less access to the Internet will be underrepresented in much of the data, said Falk.
Opposition parties were on the attack this week. In question period Thursday, Liberal MP Ralph Goodale called it "Conservative ideological stupidity."
"The government is wasting $32,000 tax dollars every day to spy on the media and its own backbench. It wastes another $95,000 tax dollars on every government ad during hockey games. It vandalized the census and it now costs $25 million more to get less data," said Goodale.
Industry Minister Christian Paradis said the information at the national and provincial level is "pretty solid."
"Our government is committed to collect statistical data while protecting Canadians’ privacy... the survey provides useful and usable data for communities representing 97 per cent of the Canadian population," said Paradis.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Another nail-biter for Blue
B.C. chief's pay and expenses nears $1 million
Man who died in Stella Avenue standoff was ordered to vacate house after dispute with relatives
Drunk driver gets 4 1/2 years for deadly crash
Committee endorses $25-million upgrade for Kilcona Park
Gaza truce comes after days of pushing for a deal
Manitoba tribute for a Canadian icon
High court warns against police stings
Higher bacon prices are staying: Maple Leaf
Family finds old human skull in garage
Regulator bans exclusivity in roaming deals
Cyberattack breached personal data: watchdog
Police looking for man after attempted abduction
Candidate goes homeless to show economic gap
Fridays of long weekends the deadliest days to be on the road
Player ordered to trial for fatal punch of referee
Winnipeg airport shows off refurbished second runway
MTYP hires new artistic director
US warns against travelling to Ebola-hit countries
NASA to test making rocket fuel ingredient on Mars
Contract talks in Met Opera labour dispute extended
MTS sees slight decline in revenue and slight increase in profit in second quarter
Top 20 Concert Tours from Pollstar
Unfairly convicted man can sue police, Crown
Demoted worker shoots CEO, kills self in Chicago
Target taps outsider as CEO for needed shakeup
'Godfather of Makeup' Dick Smith dead at 92
Moncton shootings suspect fit to stand trial
US, UN announce deal on 72-hour Gaza cease-fire
Preview of Folklorama at News Café today
Study traces dinosaur evolution into early birds
Fahmy imprisoned in Egypt weighs appeal
See-through mice reveal details of inner anatomy
W. Africa Ebola outbreak tops 700 deaths
World Cup predicting sloth rejects honours
Man dies in rollover
Drivers don't care that 60 means 60
Kellogg's sales hurt as dieters drop Special K
Winnipegger to be inducted into soccer hall of fame
Improving defence a work in progress