Latest News

Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION

Supervisors' notes on Sinclair case missing, destroyed or not made in first place, inquiry hears

By: Carol Sanders

Posted: 02/6/2013 9:22 AM | Last Modified: 02/6/2013 2:16 PM | Updates

Phoenix Sinclair is shown in a family photo released by the Commission of Inquiry looking into her 2005 death. (HANDOUT / THE CANADIAN PRESS ARCHIVES)

Related Items

Articles
- Superiors shelved reports: ex-CEO
Columns
- Common sense absent amid chaos

Six years after Phoenix Sinclair's death, when a commission of inquiry was announced and people started asking questions, the notes of supervisors who handled her file could not be found.

Today, the inquiry heard that there was no policy governing supervisors' note-taking until 2004, and once there was a policy, not all supervisors followed it in the same way.

"There (were) discrepancies," said Alana Brownlee, chief executive officer of Winnipeg Child and Family Services. The inquiry has already heard that some supervisors kept notes in binders; one testified he took his notes home and destroyed them five years after leaving the agency. Another said he kept no notes at all.

Phoenix was involved with CFS from the time she was born in 2000 when she was taken into care until CFS last closed the file on her in March 2005. She died that summer but her death wasn't discovered until 2006, and the province promised an inquiry. In 2008, Phoenix's mother Samantha Kematch and stepfather Karl McKay were convicted of her murder.

In 2011, the inquiry was formally announced. Brownlee tried to track down supervisors' notes at the request of one of the supervisors who did keep notes and was trying to jog her memory about her involvement in the case.

Angie Balan and a few other supervisors involved with Phoenix testified earlier that they left their notes in binders in their offices so whomever replaced them would have them on hand.

Brownlee sent out emails to other supervisors and administrative staff hoping to track them down. With all the reorganization and moves happening within Winnipeg CFS and devolution in May 2005, the supervisors binders relating to Phoenix weren't found, she said.

Brownlee said she spoke to managers, as well.

"I did not find any supervisory notes specific to this case." Her testimony continues today.

Three of Karl "Wes" McKay’s children and a former spouse expected to testify at the inquiry into the death of Phoenix Sinclair have asked for a publication ban to protect their identities.

Commissioner Ted Hughes will hear the request for the publication ban today at 2 p.m. at the Fort Garry Hotel.

Two of McKay’s kids testified at the murder trial that in 2008 found him and Samantha Kematch guilty of murdering five-year-old Phoenix.

"Testifying at the criminal trial was very stressful to me as I was concerned about possible retribution that might result to me because of my testimony," said the affidavit of one of the kids who was 12 when they observed Phoenix with McKay and Kematch.

"Following the arrest of Wes McKay for the murder of Phoenix Sinclair, I experienced instances of harassment from people that knew that I was a child of Wes McKay," said the affidavit.

"I doubt that any of us would want to be in their shoes," said Bill Gange, the lawyer representing the four witnesses at the inquiry.

"And I doubt that any of us would want to carry the burden that they carry," he told the Free Press.

Jonathan Kroft will represent the Free Press, CBC, CTV and Global at today’s hearing.

-- with files from staff

History

Updated on Wednesday, February 6, 2013 at 2:16 PM CST: updates with testimony re: supervisors' notes

Fact Check

Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.

* Required

In which story did you find the error? *
Please post the headline of the story or the title of the video with the error.
What was the error? *
Please post exactly what was wrong with the story.
What should we have written?
Please indicate your source for the correct information.
Who else should we interview to improve this story?
Please include any contact information you may have.
Can we contact you in the future for advice on stories about this topic?
Yes

No
First Name: *
Last Name: *
E–mail Address: *
This will only be used to contact you if we have a question about your submission, it will not be used to identify you or be published.
Phone: *
This will only be used to contact you if we have a question about your submission, it will not be used to identify you or be published.
Colour:
Are you blue? If you can see this, leave it blank and get some CSS support.
Enter the words that you see: * This is to prevent our forms from being filled out automatically.
You have failed to correctly identify the words in the box above. Please try again.