Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 02/28/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
The Manitoba courts have run into a new source of backlog -- lengthening lineups for psychiatric assessments are delaying cases, forcing accused persons to sit in pre-trial custody in jail or the remand centre. A shortage of forensic psychiatrists is the problem, but at root of the issue is what appears to be a historical deference to medical professionals.
The courts traditionally have relied on psychiatrists, who are medical doctors, to prepare reports on and testify to the competence or mental health disability of those charged with crimes. Courts have relied on the forensic unit at the Health Sciences Centre, typically staffed with five forensic psychiatrists, to complete these pre-trial assessments. That unit will soon be reduced to one physician as a result of retirements or the decision of some to leave to set up a more lucrative private practices.
The Winnipeg Regional Health Authority is recruiting, but it's a tough job in a country where psychiatrists are paid less than other specialists. Furthermore, forensic psychiatry is a subspecialty of limited interest.
Courts, like the broader society, have moved to adopt greater sensitivity to the role mental health plays in criminal conduct. The advent of a court dedicated to dealing with accused persons debilitated by disorders, meanwhile, has increased pressure on the system's ability to gather psychiatric evaluations. Court-ordered assessments, increasingly, are central to the justice system's ability to determine criminal responsibility. Amid this, HSC's forensic unit has lost physicians and now assessments are being delayed excessively, with some being scheduled into April.
The WRHA (finally, some note) is planning now to include other practitioners, including psychologists, in the forensic unit to diagnose, treat and monitor people with mental illness who come into conflict with the law. It is also looking at improving the pay packets of psychiatrists.
This may help speed along requests for assessments, but it is anticipated that court reports will have to be signed off by psychiatrists. That reveals an unnecessary bias to physicians, whose skills are required in specific, but not all, cases where compromised mental health is in question.
Courts have defaulted to physicians (psychiatrists) to write assessments because the Criminal Code specifically sets out the necessity of a medical practitioner's assessment.
Sec. 672.1, however, allows the attorney general to decide if other qualified professionals can do the assessments. Forensic psychologists also provide advice, sometimes alone or in tandem with psychiatrists, to the courts. But courts continue to defer to medical doctors for evaluations of competency of the accused.
The idea has long past that most things related to health are the purview of those with MD attached to their names. Scope of practice for various health professionals has expanded, particularly in community hubs of health and wellness. Even the holy realm of drug prescription and referrals to specialists has been breached now that nurses, physiotherapists and psychologists are writing 'scripts' for patients. Canada is catching up to moves made in other jurisdictions.
The skills of forensic psychiatrists are specifically required for some severe medical illness. But many cases can be assessed by forensic psychologists, so the delay in the courts' ability to proceed with cases in which there is a question of mental capacity results from an archaic and exclusive bias.
What the criminal courts need is the educated advice and guidance of experienced professionals who can determine whether mental health and competency plays a role in criminal conduct. Manitoba's adherence to a strict reliance on forensic psychiatry is unnecessarily restrictive. Attorney General Andrew Swan should change the rules for court-ordered assessments to expand the expertise courts can rely on.
Editorials are the consensus view of the Winnipeg Free Press’ editorial board, comprising Catherine Mitchell, David O’Brien, Shannon Sampert, and Paul Samyn.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 28, 2013 A14
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Property tax increase capped, but frontage levies, garbage fees to increase
The Hockey News proclaims Jets '2019 Stanley Cup champions' in annual Future Watch issue
Property tax or not a property tax — that is the question
72 passengers reach settlements in Asiana crash
No selfie sticks, museum says
Threat sees three Regina schools drop event
RCMP lay charges against man in Beausejour store attack
Project Distress target pleads guilty to drug charges
Bird counts still being tallied, but number of birders up in Great Backyard Count
TSN apologizes for offensive Phaneuf tweet
Flu ravaging nursing homes
Roseau River teen's death a homicide, RCMP say
Windsor cops probe secret online sex shows
Neepawa blaze proves costly: $3M
Manitoba moves into tie for third at Brier
Pair pleads 'drunken stupidity'
Bombers sign Millington, Pierre
Stempniak surprised, but excited to join Jets
Two legends, one team being inducted into Manitoba Sports Hall of Fame
Levin pleads guilty to child porn charges
Cost of Neepawa blaze pegged at $3M
Forgiving the unthinkable
Ex-CIA chief admits sharing military secrets with mistress
Ready, set, go
Feds quietly canvass provinces for GHG action
Housing affordability in Manitoba improving: report
Great-West acquires U.K.'s Equitable Life Assurance Society
Chill sets in over anti-terror laws
Netanyahu warns US 'bad deal' would put Iran on nuclear path
NHL trade deadline winners and losers
Book of Mormon to hold pre-show lotteries
Shiny new tech can't distract from CSI spinoff's deficiencies
It's not us, it's them, think-tank says
Prejudice in the court
Support flows for attacked couple
Cold today and tonight, but warmer weather on the way
Jordan, other NBA owners join Forbes' billionaire list
March to be colder than normal: forecast
India orders TV stations not to give rapist a platform
Hungary makes nuclear deal with Russia a 30-year secret