Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 02/5/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Aveos' former hangars in Winnipeg remain ready for action. They're being heated, and Air Canada continues to make its lease payments.
But the hangars sit empty and are likely to stay that way in the near future, despite a court ruling Monday that Air Canada broke the law by contracting out major aircraft repairs that were the lifeblood of the Winnipeg operation.
A Quebec judge ruled Air Canada violated the law by not keeping maintenance operations in Winnipeg and Montreal.
The court ruling is not going to bring jobs back to Manitoba in the near future, said Tony Didoshak, regional representative of the International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, which represented the Aveos workers.
"It's not like they are going to start Winnipeg and Montreal up immediately," he said.
Didoshak said the ruling marks one step in a process that will likely take many more months, if not longer, to complete, and he's cynical about the process in general.
"The ruling says Air Canada is not in compliance with the act," he said. "But it's up to government to determine what the act means and how they become compliant."
Justice Martin Castonguay of the Quebec Superior Court ruled that Air Canada violated the 1988 Air Canada Participation Act by contracting out major aircraft repairs and that, by law, the company must have aircraft heavy maintenance operations in Winnipeg and Montreal. "The court concludes that Air Canada doesn't respect the law put in place when it privatized in 1988," the judge wrote.
Air Canada will appeal the ruling.
The ACPA was passed in 1988 as part of the process for Air Canada to become a private company. Among the provisions was one "requiring the corporation to maintain operational and overhaul centres in the city of Winnipeg, the Montreal Urban Community and the city of Mississauga."
Since 2004, most of the maintenance work was done by Aveos, a private company in which Air Canada owned about one-fifth of the shares. In March 2012, Aveos went bankrupt and closed its operations, including a plant in Winnipeg that employed 412 people. Plants in Montreal and Mississauga, Ont., were also shuttered, throwing a total of 2,600 people out of work.
After Aveos closed, Air Canada gave American company AAR a five-year renewable contract to maintain its airplanes in a specially built facility in Duluth, Minn., which employs 350 workers.
The Quebec government took the airline to court, arguing Air Canada violated the agreement to keep maintenance operations in those cities. Manitoba was an intervenor in the case.
"This is a positive ruling for Manitoba as the Quebec Court has ruled that by closing its maintenance and overhaul facilities in Montreal it is in violation of the Air Canada Public Participation Act," said Matt Williamson, a spokesman for Premier Greg Selinger. "Unfortunately, it appears that Air Canada will appeal this ruling. If so, Manitoba will consider its options."
Last March, Transport Minister Denis Lebel asked the House of Commons transport committee to determine whether Air Canada broke the law. The committee met twice on the subject in March and April 2012 but has produced no report nor scheduled further meetings.
Air Canada says the Quebec and Manitoba governments have no jurisdiction because aviation is a federal matter.
Manitoba Liberal MP Kevin Lamoureux said he'd like to see the federal and provincial governments both fight harder to save the well-paying jobs.
-- with files from Canadian Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 5, 2013 A4
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Premier Selinger facing potential revolt within NDP
Teen charged in connection to high school fire
Jets no match for Lightning
LIVE: Churchill polar-bear cam
Slain soldier rides Highway of Heroes home
Games should remind us of what Canada is all about
Police seek girls, 11 and 14, last seen Thursday
School gunman was Homecoming prince, students say
All-Time Blue Bombers Team sees Leo Lewis cloned to play 2 positions
Bipole III the 'biggest boondoggle in Manitoba history': Pallister
'Nobody's going to believe her': defence lawyer on accused in dead infants case
Key of Bart: Choose Yourself
Bombers prepare for Saturday's crucial game against B.C. Lions
City paramedics take special Ebola precautions four times
Automotive Journalists' Association gives nod to Free Press writer
Echoes of the Cold War
Questions, answers about Takata air bag recalls
Man missing in Pembina Valley Provincial Park
Inquests called into prison deaths
City police checking in on kids' hockey this winter
Ukraine teeters on brink of revolution
Powder-filled envelope at consulate in Turkey
Maddin's 'My Winnipeg' gets Criterion treatment
Tickets to One Direction on sale Nov. 1
'Growler bars' for draft beer now in Manitoba
Result shocks Bowman
Jets can reset their season now after an awkward, fumbling start
Missing girl, 16, believed to be travelling west
Ouellette's star still on the rise
First Nation brings Hydro protest to HQ
Björk's human nature shines through multimedia overload
China launches experimental moon orbiter
Bill Murray’s reliable grumpiness gives sharp edge to sentimental premise
U.K. firm to design this year's pop-up eatery
Sweden calls off search for submarine
Man alleged to have gun on bus remanded
Warm today, but chance of flurries next week
Fletcher told caregiver to run for it, if she could