Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 10/25/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Angry city councillors are turning their sights on Mayor Sam Katz and his senior cabinet in the wake of the fire-hall scandal.
Couns. Harvey Smith (Daniel McIntyre) and Ross Eadie (Mynarski) said Katz should follow ex-CAO Phil Sheegl and resign.
"This is an insane world at city hall, and the mayor is responsible," Smith said. "We shouldn't be asking (Katz) to resign -- He should be voluntarily coming forward and resigning."
Katz said he would not respond to calls for his resignation, adding councillors are entitled to their opinions.
Eadie said Katz has been trying to divert blame in the fire-hall scandal to all of council and most recently to the members of executive policy committee.
"He's blaming everyone," Eadie said. "It's time (Katz) took responsibility."
Eadie said Katz brought Sheegl to city hall and pushed his advancement all the way to become chief administrative officer.
Smith said only a small group of councillors -- himself, Eadie, Russ Wyatt (Transcona), Jenny Gerbasi (Fort Rouge) and John Orlikow (River Heights) -- voted against hiring Sheegl as CAO, adding all other councillors should accept responsibility over the mess Sheegl created at city hall.
"The ones that were on EPC (at the time) should own up to the fact that they made all this possible -- they're not getting any credit for the harm they are doing.
"And the mayor is obviously the leader of the group."
Sheegl, a close friend of Katz, was hired as the city's property director in 2008 and then rose quickly up the administrative ladder to deputy CAO and then CAO.
Current EPC members Wyatt and Scott Fielding (St. James) said they do not hold Katz responsible for Sheegl's blunders and are not calling for his resignation.
Wyatt (Transcona) said he always had concerns about Sheegl's ability, adding he was saddened to see recent events have shown his judgment was correct.
Wyatt opposed Sheegl's appointment to CAO and called for his resignation a year ago.
Katz told reporters Thursday it was a letter signed by five of the six EPC members on Oct. 2, demanding he fire Sheegl, that led to Sheegl resigning last week.
The EPC letter, Katz said, resulted in negotiations with Sheegl's lawyer that ultimately led to his resignation.
Katz said concerns Sheegl's resignation allowed him to leave city hall with a generous severance package are inaccurate, adding conditions in Sheegl's contract ensured it made no difference whether he quit or was fired.
Katz said he believes it would have been better to have Sheegl still on staff to answer questions raised about the Ernst & Young review into the fire-hall scandal.
Katz said Sheegl's decision to terminate fire chief Reid Douglas -- a key figure in the fire-hall probe -- in September was the major factor that turned most members of council against Sheegl, including himself.
"It would have been a lot better if there had not been a letter asking for (Sheegl's) immediate dismissal," Katz said, adding a decision on his friend's fate would then have been made after the Ernst & Young review had been released.
"The end result would probably have been the same."
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 25, 2013 B2
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Brian Bowman wins mayoral battle
Gilroy seizes Daniel McIntyre after close race
DNA testing will determine if accused is mother of 6 dead infants
Schreyer unseats Steen in Elmwood-East Kildonan
Dobson unseats incumbent in St. Charles
Canada won't be cowed by terrorist attack: PM
Morantz edges Duncan in Charleswood-Tuxedo
Scott Gillingham wins in St. James-Brooklands
Lukes wins boss' vacated seat in St. Norbert
Orlikow beats Taz in River Heights-Fort Garry
Bruce Henley re-elected mayor in West St. Paul
Family, friends, colleagues bid farewell to Lindor Reynolds
Pagtakhan retains Point Douglas seat
Pike new mayor in St. Andrews
Devi Sharma squeaks in win in Old Kildonan
Wyatt reinstated in Transcona
Voters stick with status quo for school boards
Winnipeg votes: Oct. 22, 2014
Mayes re-elected in St. Vital
Eadie back for second term in Mynarski
Matt Allard elected councillor in St. Boniface
Gerbasi holds down Fort-Rouge-East Fort Garry
Browaty holds on to North Kildonan
Voter turnout highest in a decade
Bombers offensive line uncertain heading into must-win game against B.C.
Soldier killed in Parliament Hill siege
Expert: Autopsy doesn't show if Brown went for gun
Man, 26, killed in crash on Highway 3 between Sanford and Oak Bluff
Family: Doctors don't detect Ebola in nurse's body
Attorney says Kings' Voynov didn't hit girlfriend
Jets apply tourniquet
Senate to hear more cluster bomb testimony
Security at Manitoba Legislature tightened after Ottawa shooting
Griddle me this
Bradlee recalled as a genius, great journalist
Last chance to vote: Polls open until 8 p.m.
St. Malo man dies after collision
Civic election: then and now