Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 07/31/2013 1:00 AM
Last Modified: 07/31/2013 9:11 AM | Updates
A doctor who sexually assaulted an incapacitated teenaged patient at the Children's Hospital will be deported once he is released from prison.
A Manitoba judge must decide when that might happen.
The Crown is seeking up to seven more years behind bars for Walid Abdelhamid, saying he committed a "predatory" breach of trust that cries out for deterrence.
But defence lawyers say Abdelhamid, who hails from Libya, should be freed immediately because the time he's spent in custody far exceeds sufficient punishment.
Queen's Bench Justice Joan McKelvey reserved her decision after hearing arguments Tuesday. Her ruling isn't expected until the fall.
Abdelhamid, 33, was convicted of sexual assault following a trial earlier this year. He was working at Health Sciences Centre in 2009 when he twice assaulted the 15-year-old boy, who had suffered a serious back injury while riding a motorbike.
The now-18-year-old told court he awoke twice in the middle of the night to find Abdelhamid fondling him. Both incidents occurred when he was immobilized and receiving morphine for pain.
A key issue at trial was the youth's state of mind as a result of being medicated. Defence lawyer Marty Minuk repeatedly suggested the boy may have been too high to comprehend what happened. But the youth said he knew what happened.
The first incident happened around 2 a.m. The teen said he woke up and found Abdelhamid hovering over him, touching his genitals.
The incident lasted a few seconds before a nurse walked in and Abdelhamid quickly pulled his hands back and left the room.
The teen said when he woke up around 5 a.m., Abdelhamid was attempting to perform oral sex on him.
Abdelhamid fled again, and this time the teen rang the buzzer to summon a nurse and disclose what had happened. His parents were notified and police were called.
Minuk questioned Tuesday how much impact the crime has really had on the victim.
He told court the teen has since returned to motocross racing and has had another accident, which landed him back in hospital.
But prosecutor Adam Bergen scoffed at the suggestion that returning to the sport he loves is somehow a sign the teen wasn't traumatized by the incidents.
He said the teen's parents stayed at his bedside 24/7 during his later hospital stay because he was afraid to be alone.
The judge must assess Abdelhamid's pre-trial custody.
Abdelhamid was released on bail following his arrest, but fled the country and ended up in Greece. He was arrested and returned to Canada in May 2011 and has remained in custody since.
Abdelhamid spent nine months in custody in Greece, and has now been incarcerated for 27 months in Canada.
Minuk argued Tuesday those 27 months should be given double-time credit of 54 months because his arrest pre-dates legislative changes banning the two-for-one credit.
As a result, Minuk claims his client has already served the equivalent of a 63-month sentence.
He said other precedents in Canada show a range of one to three years is proper punishment, which would allow Abdelhamid to be freed and deported immediately.
The Crown argued Tuesday Abdelhamid should be given no credit for his pre-trial custody because he is the author of his own demise, having fled while on bail.
The Crown is seeking an additional six or seven years behind bars.
Minuk called that "vengeful."
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 31, 2013 A4
Updated on Wednesday, July 31, 2013 at 9:11 AM CDT: Corrects typo
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
More help promised for Manitoba child welfare in light of Phoenix Sinclair inquiry
Ambulance delays cost WRHA $1.4 million
Oswald makes campaign pledge to boost workplace health and safety enforcement
Big banks cut prime rate to 2.85 per cent
Brother charged for alleged assault on boyfriend
Watchdogs want Conservative bill quashed
Firm fined $4,800 for massive fire
Obama floats offering first-ever drilling lease in Atlantic
Mom who used iron to scald boy loses appeal
Super Bowl, Tiger make Phoenix centre of sports universe
Dog killed during break-in
Mayor Bowman to launch a website to solicit ideas on beating racism
Grain shippers face railway backlog: report
Electronic music duo Purity Ring to play Garrick in June
Three men's teams clinch playoff spots
Tim Hortons lays off staff at headquarters
Experts: Gold nuggets stolen from museum may be tough sell
Mexico: Investigation shows that all 43 students are dead
Michelle Obama navigates limits on women in Saudi Arabia
Snubs, surprises of this year's Juno nominations
Jets hoping to extend their season-best winning streak against depleted Pens
Goaltender Martin Brodeur to retire
Cinematheque program explores how novels translate into films
Balanced books possible amid oil slump: PBO
Facebook blames glitch for global outage
Teen acquitted in fatal assault
RCMP arrest Portage la Prairie man in sexual assault case dating back to 2013
Marriott buying Delta Hotel & Resorts brand
Manitobans earn 12 Juno nominations
Big-box chain Lowe's could replace Targets here
Paramedics scare off suspect of attempted abduction
Mom heading to Australia with son aquitted of abduction
Documentary chronicles "Clara's Big Ride"
Passenger traffic increases in airport's fourth quarter
Monarch butterflies rebound in Mexico, numbers still low
Blizzard howls its way into Boston but largely spares NYC
Secret talks in Jordan try to win release of hostages
On Auschwitz anniversary, leader warns Jews again targets
Long-term care probe makes progress: ombudsman
True North deal has to wait