Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 04/23/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 04/23/2013 6:59 AM | Updates
OTTAWA -- The Manitoba government is the second NDP administration in Canada in three years to raise the provincial sales tax in the face of a deficit budget.
But the move leaves Manitoba with the highest sales tax in Western Canada and the highest sales tax in provinces that haven't yet harmonized sales taxes with the federal GST.
"Were there better choices to raise revenue?" asked Jack Mintz, the Palmer Chair of Public Policy at the University of Calgary. "Yes."
The provincial government will raise the PST to eight per cent from seven this summer. Nationally, Manitoba will be tied with Ontario, New Brunswick and Newfoundland for having the fourth-highest PST. Nova Scotia, at 10 per cent, has the highest, followed by Quebec at 9.975 per cent and Prince Edward Island at nine per cent.
British Columbia, at seven per cent, and Saskatchewan, at five per cent follow. Alberta is the only province that has no PST.
But Mintz said because Manitoba refuses to harmonize with the GST, the impact in the province likely will be more profound than it was when Nova Scotia hiked its provincial sales tax two points in 2010.
Businesses get a GST rebate for much of the tax paid for business input costs. However, the provincial sales tax has no such rebates or exemptions.
"The existing sales tax in Manitoba is not well-structured and has significant taxes on business inputs," said Mintz.
That means Manitoba exports cost more and makes imported goods often more competitive.
He said a study he did last year listed Manitoba as having the sixth-highest effective tax rate on investment compared with other provinces and OECD nations.
"This (PST hike) will likely put them close to the top," he said.
Manitoba has rejected calls from Ottawa for a HST because it would mean Manitoba consumers would end up paying sales tax on more things, such as haircuts, sports-club memberships and airline tickets, things on which PST is not currently charged.
The British Columbia Liberal government was just forced to undo the harmonization of their two sales taxes after a referendum rejected the HST, which was implemented in 2009. The HST is one of the reasons Premier Christy Clark and the B.C. Liberals are likely to be voted out of office in an election next month.
Quebec recently moved to harmonize its sales tax with Ottawa in January, although it is the only province where the joint tax, known as the QST, is administered by the province rather than Ottawa. The total combined rate in Quebec is 14.98 per cent.
Prince Edward Island became the sixth province to introduce an HST, just this month. The province lowered the provincial portion of the tax to nine per cent from 10 per cent in the process.
Ontario introduced an HST in 2011, and while it was deemed controversial at the time, it is seldom mentioned now among reasons voters are displeased with the provincial Liberal government.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition April 23, 2013 A4
Updated on Tuesday, April 23, 2013 at 6:59 AM CDT: adds photo
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Sinclair issues challenge to help heal pain of schools
Will broad family tax relief equal votes?
Jets snuffed in New Jersey
Trooper ambush suspect caught, death penalty eyed
B.C. lawyers vote down Christian law school
Reports: John Forzani on life support
'Get-out-of-jail' card for parents
Man receives 40-month sentence for involvement in drug-dealing network
Senate still out $45K for expense claims
Police search Boeing plant; no armed man found
Ministers to meet with Selinger over concerns
2 sites dropped from list of Great Lakes hot spots
Key of Bart: Fifty Ways To Punt Your Premier
Former archbishop appeals sex assault conviction
O'Shea won't say he's made mistakes as team prepares for match against Calgary
Pimicikamak meeting with mediator, MB Hydro
U of W students approve U-Pass; U of M holding similar vote
NDP 'not a credible government': Bokhari
CBC offers counselling in wake of Ghomeshi affair
Gas bills to go up by about $43
Fish board polls, trolls for support
Coalition calls on province to suspend Bipole III, Keeyask
Live chat: What you need to know about Ebola
16,000 kids attend fourth We Day Manitoba gathering
Bacon the pig no longer a ham on the lam
Viral video documents New York street harassment
Boy finds big bucks in coat
RCMP looking for suspect in homicide
Plane crashes at Kansas airport, killing 4
Reserves need $28M for fire protection: report
Police raid grow-op in St. Vital
Municipal property assessments underway
Manslaughter verdict in grisly 2012 killing
Autopsies on hold during legal battle
Missing teen, 17, last seen in North End
Man facing drug charges after raid on Maryland
Both sides refuse to blink
Oswald's stabbing words
Grain-handling difficulties continue