The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 07/21/2013 8:50 AM | Comments: 0
JERUSALEM - A team of Israeli archaeologists believes it has discovered the ruins of a palace belonging to the biblical King David, but other Israeli experts dispute the claim.
Archaeologists from Hebrew University of Jerusalem and Israel's Antiquities Authority said their find, a large fortified complex west of Jerusalem at a site called Khirbet Qeiyafa , is the first palace of the biblical king ever to be discovered.
"Khirbet Qeiyafa is the best example exposed to date of a fortified city from the time of King David," said Yossi Garfinkel, a Hebrew University archaeologist, suggesting that David himself would have used the site. Garfinkel led the seven-year dig with Saar Ganor of Israel's Antiquities Authority.
Garfinkel said his team found cultic objects typically used by Judeans, the subjects of King David, and saw no trace of pig remains. Pork is forbidden under Jewish dietary laws. Clues like these, he said, were "unequivocal evidence" that David and his descendants had ruled at the site.
Critics said the site could have belonged to other kingdoms of the area. The consensus among most scholars is that no definitive physical proof of the existence of King David has been found.
Biblical archaeology itself is contentious. Israelis often use archaeological findings to back up their historic claims to sites that are also claimed by the Palestinians, like the Old City of Jerusalem. Despite extensive archaeological evidence, for example, Palestinians deny that the biblical Jewish Temples dominated the hilltop where the Al-Aqsa Mosque compound, Islam's third-holiest site, stands today.
In general, researchers are divided over whether biblical stories can be validated by physical remains.
The current excavators are not the first to claim they found a King David palace. In 2005, Israeli archaeologist Eilat Mazar said she found the remains of King David's palace in Jerusalem dating to the 10th century B.C., when King David would have ruled. Her claim also attracted skepticism, including from Garfinkel himself.
Using carbon dating, the archaeologists traced the site's construction to that same period. Garfinkel said the team also found a storeroom almost 15 metres (50 feet) long, suggesting it was a royal site used to collect taxes from the rest of the kingdom.
Garfinkel believes King David lived permanently in Jerusalem in a yet-undiscovered site, only visiting Khirbet Qeiyafa or other palaces for short periods. He said the site's placement on a hill indicates that the ruler sought a secure site on high ground during a violent era of frequent conflicts between city-states.
"The time of David was the first time that a large portion of this area was united by one monarch," Garfinkel said. "It was not a peaceful era."
Archaeologist Israel Finkelstein of Tel Aviv University agreed that Khirbet Qeiyafa is an "elaborate" and "well-fortified" 10th century B.C. site, but said it could have been built by Philistines, Canaanites or other peoples in the area.
He said there was no way to verify who built the site without finding a monument detailing the accomplishments of the king who built it. Last week, for instance, archaeologists in Israel found pieces of a sphinx bearing the name of the Egyptian pharaoh who reigned when the statue was carved.
Garfinkel insisted that critics like Finkelstein are relying on outdated theories.
"I think other people have a collapsed theory and we have fresh data," he said.
Follow Max J. Rosenthal on Twitter at www.twitter.com/abuzilif
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Artifacts from First World War passed down through generations
The light touch: Traffic signals improving, but still lots of work to do
Police mum on standoff death
SNAFU rugby tournament an August tradition — and there's no telling what goes on
First Nation's chief urged to quit over bonus
Gord Steeves proposes selling police HQ and library parkade to raise cash for road repair
Death incites anger
Ducks to retire Selanne's No. 8 jersey
Manitoba weightlifter Marie-Josée Arès-Pilon wins bronze at Glasgow games
Water testing shows beaches are safe for the August long weekend
Chad Posthumus, former River East Kodiak, signs with Japanese basketball team
Goldeyes baseman Casey Haerther named American Association player of the month
Jets sign free-agent Galiardi
Mosquitoes carrying West Nile virus found in Oakbank
Israel pushes deeper in Gaza after soldier seized
US aid workers headed to Atlanta for Ebola care
Battle royal over North End home
Ukraine: Body parts retrieved at jet crash site
Via Rail, CN trains collide east of Kingston
Hackers 'constantly probing' federal computers
Loonie lower, jobs data misses expectations
Robert Kennedy Jr. to marry actress Cheryl Hines
Yellowstone grizzly, people run-ins drop in 2013
Ebola moving faster than control efforts
Error made by dispatcher in professor shooting
'Real Housewife' files defence in libel suit
Obama, Putin discuss Ukraine, missile treaty
Another nail-biter for Blue
Ottawa hails new rail grain shipping rules
Vogiatzakis would give portion of business tax revenue to development group
Accused to stand trial in Saunders death
Missing teen last seen in Tyndall Park area
Girl, 12, not competent for trial in stabbing
Colorado panel considers new look for edible pot
Silva says injured leg is at 95 per cent
Mayoral candidate wants review of road safety
Procter & Gamble to slim down product lineup
High court warns against police stings
Garcia shoots 61 to take Firestone lead
Reopening of major runway bonus for airport, residents