Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 02/3/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
A libel action is a double-edged sword. It's that rare legal action that can leave a plaintiff -- the party that sues -- mortally wounded. The National Council of Canadian Muslims' threatened libel suit against the Harper government is a case in point.
The NCCM, which describes itself as a non-partisan and non-profit group that's worked 14 years on human rights issues on behalf of Canadian Muslims, has given preliminary notice of its intention to sue Prime Minister Stephen Harper, his chief spokesman and the federal government for libel. It has filed a libel notice in an Ontario court that accuses the prime minister's director of communications, Jason MacDonald, of making a false and defamatory statement that linked it to a terrorist group.
In mid-January, MacDonald rejected NCCM's criticism of the prime minister's decision to include Rabbi Daniel Karobkin of Toronto as part of his delegation on his Middle East trip. In a widely released letter to the PMO, the NCCM had linked Karobkin to those "promoting hateful views" of Muslims.
MacDonald, in replying to questions about NCCM's criticism said: "We will not take seriously criticism from an organization with documented ties to a terrorist organization such as Hamas." The Canadian government designated Hamas a terrorist entity in 2002.
The prime minister and Mr. MacDonald have put themselves in a dicey legal position. Unless they can furnish the documented proof Mr. MacDonald cited, they'd best retract the statement and quickly apologize to NCCM or they're apt to face a substantial damages award against them at trial for coupling NCCM and Hamas.
On the other hand, if the government can link either NCCM or CAIR-Canada, its former name, to Hamas, the libel suit will fail and the organization will be indelibly discredited.
Thus both sides face a big risk if the libel claim goes to trial.
The legal standoff is now at a critical stage. It's at a juncture where, though notice has been served as required by law, no libel suit has actually been commenced. If the government and NCCM are going to settle out of court, this is the most opportune time to do so, before claims and defences are filed in the court and legal costs start to escalate.
But settlement -- via apology, retraction, partial retraction or even an agreed-upon amendment of MacDonald's statement -- is unlikely. There's every chance this libel claim will go the distance. And at the end of the litigation, one side or the other is going to pay big time -- either in dollars or reputation.
Editorials are the consensus view of the Winnipeg Free Press’ editorial board, comprising Catherine Mitchell, David O’Brien, Shannon Sampert, and Paul Samyn.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 3, 2014 A8
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Canada pulling team back from Ebola response
Fans roar for Katy Perry
Lost Nopiming camper safely located
Homeless hero's life celebrated
Three Winnipeggers attacked at WE Fest; Minot man charged
Bombers' chief operating officer exits
PM raises Russian threat in speech to troops
RCMP lay child abuse charges against Parkland couple
On-demand service 'Shomi' announced
Havixbeck adds to campaign platform, backs support for mental lllness
Mark Chipman declares his support for Brian Bowman
Neil Young files for divorce
No charges in Trudeau home incident
Bouchard routs Govortsova at US Open
Bowman would let city council elect the mayor's cabinet members
(Some) campaigns picking up steam
Tim Hortons and Burger King to join forces
Train cars carrying propane derail in Emerson
Trudeau's Arctic policy sparked friction: CIA
Sharma running for second term
Better access brings relief
Report finds 1,400 children exploited in UK town
Point Douglas murder victim identified
TSX rises, Burger King buys Tim Hortons
Some lawsuits against Russell Williams settled
Crushing on Katy
American woman is being held hostage in Syria
Man sought after girl, 12, grabbed
UN helicopter shot down in South Sudan
Gaza truce open-ended, but puts off tough issues
Quitting the NFL cold turkey
American, US Airways will stop listing on Orbitz
Local heroes to be honoured at gala
Quebec calls inquiry into seniors' fire
Freshwater fishery fighting upstream
Driver gets a scare after truck slammed by rock
Mexico an entry point for terrorists into the U.S.?
Lizzy Caplan, Lena Dunham: Emmys highs and lows
Grey skies are going to clear up
Guns stolen by masked intruder