The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 05/21/2013 3:05 PM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 05/21/2013 10:02 PM
OTTAWA - Conservative senators have sent Mike Duffy's controversial improper expenses back to the same closed-door committee that initially reviewed them, rejecting a Liberal bid to have the matter referred directly to the police.
Liberal Senate Leader James Cowan argued late Tuesday night that the committee on internal economy had lost credibility with Canadians and the police should take over.
He said the initial report the on former Conservative senator's expenses had been "whitewashed" by his Tory colleagues, and then further thrown into doubt when it was discovered the $90,000 owed by Duffy was paid by the prime minister's former chief of staff Nigel Wright.
"What confidence can we have that they will allowed to do their work without political interference from outside, from the leadership in the Senate, or the House of Commons or the prime minister's office," Cowan said on the Senate floor.
"From what we have witnessed to date, we don't believe Canadians would have any confidence in this proposed approach."
But Senate Speaker Noel Kinsella ruled Cowan's bid was out of order, and emphasized that the committee could always refer the matter to the police later.
The Conservative majority in the Senate voted to have the matter sent back to the committee.
The Liberals are also trying another tack — trying to trigger special parliamentary hearings in the hopes of forcing Wright and others to testify about the $90,000 payment to Duffy.
Cowan argued that Stephen Harper's office violated the sacrosanct privileges of parliamentarians, and may well be in contempt of Parliament.
Wright resigned Sunday, and Duffy quit the Conservative caucus last Thursday, after the details of their transaction began to emerge.
After that payment from Wright, Duffy stopped co-operating with an audit into his expenses. The Senate report into Duffy does not include some of the same language used in nearly identical reports into the claims of senators Patrick Brazeau and Mac Harb.
Liberals on the Senate committee handling the report voted against it in protest.
"If monies were paid which would influence the decision of a Senate committee, then that is contempt of Parliament, and that infringes my privileges as a senator, and it infringes the privileges of senators and the Senate and interferes in a spectacular way...with the independence of the Senate," Cowan told reporters.
Conservative Senate leader Marjory LeBreton had declared the matter closed two weeks ago when the reports on housing expenses were tabled.
During Senate question period on Tuesday, LeBreton insisted that she and her colleagues were unaware of Wright's payment to Duffy until it was revealed on the news.
"I was dealing with what I had at that point in time. That's all I could do," LeBreton said of her comments on May 9.
Cowan pressed LeBreton to explain why the report on Duffy's claims was different from that of Harb and Brazeau.
LeBreton suggested it was because Duffy had already paid his improper expenses, and the reports might have been designed to persuade Brazeau and Harb to do the same.
Cowan is arguing that the executive branch interfered in the proceedings of the Senate committee tasked with studying Duffy's expense claims.
Claude Carignan, the Conservative deputy leader in the Senate, rejected the notion the Senate's privileges had been violated. He said it was enough that the Senate ethics officer and the conflict of interest and ethics commissioner were reviewing the matter.
"I think this is a serious issue, and it shouldn't be an issue of partisanship," said Carignan. "There is a parliamentary process created to treat issues of this type, and I think we should allow it to unfold."
If Kinsella finds there appears to be a breach of parliamentary privilege, he could send the issue to a special committee for further study.
Such a Senate committee would enjoy the privilege of summoning any witness it wants on the matter, including Wright or others from Harper's office.
Kinsella said late Tuesday evening he was taking the matter under advisement.
Harper's office insisted Tuesday there was no agreement between Wright and Duffy, and that as a result no documentation of such a deal exists. But no one has yet provided a full explanation of what transpired between the two men.
Meanwhile, Harb raised a question of privilege in the Senate on Tuesday evening, suggesting his reputation was impugned when the Senate committee issued its report saying he owed $51,482. Harb noted that independent auditors declared rules around primary residences were not clear, and they did not determine he had broken them.
"Tell me what percentage of the time you want me to live in my primary residence?" Harb responded angrily to questions put by Liberal Senator George Furey.
"This is a democracy. If I'm not billing the Senate for my time off it's not anyone's business where I am."
The report into Brazeau's expenses was passed by the Senate late Tuesday. Brazeau has been asked to pay $48,744. He is also fighting the bill.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
H&M opening in Winnipeg on Sept. 10
O'Shea plays down praise he's getting for turning the Bombers around
Cut mosquito-fogging buffer zones: Steeves
The Pinkertons detective series to be shot in Winnipeg
Former Bomber pleads guilty to fraud charges
Peace rally to be held in silence
City refunding $1 million in photo radar tickets because of missing words on tickets
August civic holiday to be named after national hero
Israeli strikes hit UN school, Gaza shopping area
Police still probing girl's 1985 disappearance
Arrest made in city's 14th homicide
The search for a Billy Elliot to begin
Hamilton, former co-chair of AJI, dies
Last crew member of Enola Gay flight dies
Woods hopeful of more good memories at Firestone
Lawyer apologizes at sex assault sentencing
Ohio: 2nd fine levied against prison food vendor
Argentina officials stage 11th-hour talks in NYC
Folk festival over, but concert series continues
Cargill to close beef plant, cites cattle shortage
Senate reprieve for highly contested border bill
Contract dispute delays 'Big Bang' production
Police chief, nemesis of Rob Ford, losing job
Man charged after alleged online chats with teen
Supreme Court to rule on Mr. Big stings
Nadal out of Rogers Cup with wrist injury
WECC to get F---ed Up on Sept. 23
Kelsey Grammer won't endorse killer's release
Figure in '80s payola probe faces NY gambling case
Condo construction starts on former Restaurant Dubrovnik site
Preview of Folklorama at News Café today
Ottawa puts up $2.5M to train Saskatchewan miners
Destructive rampage 'could have been catastrophe'
Jets re-sign forward Matt Halischuk
Clashes prevent experts from reaching bodies
Russia's central bank supports sanctions targets
Tickets for 5 Seconds of Summer's Winnipeg show on sale Aug. 9
UK holds crisis meeting on Ebola; warns of threat
Raiders owner confirms talks with San Antonio
AMC to elect grand chief today