Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 10/1/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Prime Minister Stephen Harper sounded surprisingly truculent last week in New York when he said he would not take no for an answer on the Keystone XL pipeline. U.S. President Barack Obama has yet to decide whether to allow TransCanada Corp. to build the line from the Canadian border to Oklahoma to ship Canadian bitumen to Gulf Coast refineries. Opponents of the project have the president's ear. Mr. Harper warned he will continue advocating the line even if the president turns it down.
Canadians are not used to their prime ministers taking this quarrelsome tone with a U.S. president. After all, it's not Mr. Harper's pipeline and it's not his country. It might seem presumptuous for him to say it has to be built. The more he casts the case as a dispute between himself and Mr. Obama, the more he seems to weaken the chances of a favourable ruling from the president.
But this is the way the political game is often played in the U.S., where Mr. Harper's remarks may not seem out of order. Canadians have often learned, in a series of trade disputes, that no decision in the U.S. political system is ever final. There is always another court or another regulatory body or another congressional committee where a previous decision can be challenged and the merits of any case can be re-examined. Success in such a system requires persistence. Opponents of Keystone XL have shown persistence. Mr. Harper intends to show more.
Persistence is currently paralyzing Washington. Republicans opposed to Mr. Obama's health-insurance reforms are not discouraged by adoption of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in 2010 nor by defeat of reform opponent Mitt Romney in the presidential election a year ago. They are making their case over again in the course of a budget debate. In this context, Mr. Harper's plan to keep making the case for a pipeline that will serve both Canadian oil producers and U.S. oil consumers seems relatively mild and reasonable.
Mr. Harper is on solid ground in drawing attention to the economic logic supporting the Keystone XL project. He is going to have to deal squarely with the environmental objections to oilsands development, however, because the oil industry and its friends are losing that argument every week, every time another celebrity goes to look at the Fort McMurray region and the damage that has been done to the land and the water. His letter to Mr. Obama proposing joint Canada-U.S. measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the oil and gas sector is an excellent start. Persistence may help. Practical steps to deal with the objections will also help.
Editorials are the consensus view of the Winnipeg Free Press’ editorial board, comprising Catherine Mitchell, David O’Brien and Paul Samyn.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 1, 2013 A8
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Sentencing in child-abduction trial could be broadcast
Record crowd flocks to fringe
New weather stations to help flood forecasters and farmers
UN chief reinforces call for Gaza cease-fire
Preview of Folklorama at News Café today
Suspect dead, marshals and cop wounded in NYC
Israeli PM speaks of 'prolonged' campaign in Gaza
OurWinnipeg planning report to be followed, says mayoral candidate
Astronaut landing at the Concert Hall in December
Growing movement to treat PTSD in responders
New fears about Ebola spread after plane scare
911 call reveals unusual home intruder - a snake
Sunny, warm week in the forecast
Man dies in suspicious downtown highrise fire
Online post eggs on anti-Ford actions: police
Police team turns back from Ukraine crash site
Sailors to navigate dirty water in 1st Rio test
Cops: 'Spider-Man' slugged officer in Times Square
Mall collapse report won't be kept secret
Mall construction boom fuelled by wealthy
Grain mixed, livestock higher
US fuming over Israeli criticism of Kerry
Dozens treated for illness at Keith Urban concert
Virgin America files plans for IPO
Radcliffe goes undercover as Spidey at Comic-Con
Red Lobster goes vertical on plate to push quality
Health costs are biggest retirement worry
Pesticide use in Manitoba rising despite looming ban, data shows
A mayor for all seasons
FIFA seeks probe into racist remarks by Italian
Having the time of her life
Diversion endangers Lake Manitoba's future
Treasured oasis on Assiniboine
Fixation with constant suburban growth slammed
Build-first strategy bearing fruit
Fish flying into all-star break
HK pro-democracy news site folds, citing pressure
US exports help Germany increase coal, pollution
Obama practically weepy at Malia going to college