Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 06/24/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
The relationship between the City of Winnipeg and the province has been tense for decades as both governments quarrelled over issues of jurisdiction and funding, but their ability to resolve disputes has rarely been as weak as it is today.
The two sides do not even appear to be on talking terms, as evidenced by a recent series of announcements on funding for roads and infrastructure. The province hasn't invited the city to its press conferences involving civic projects, while Mayor Sam Katz has increasingly attacked Premier Greg Selinger for ignoring the city's needs.
This is not an uncommon occurrence among major cities in Canada today.
Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi, for example, has engaged Alberta's government in a series of verbal jousts over civic powers and new ways of raising revenue. A provincial official called Mr. Nenshi a "politicking peacock," while the mayor accused the province of treating the city like a country bumpkin.
The relationship was so bad, in fact, the two sides agreed to a memorandum of understanding last year to, among other things, show "mutual respect" while working out their differences. So far, it hasn't made much of a difference.
Politicians will be politicians, but the risk in dysfunctional relationships is that vital issues could be set back.
In Winnipeg, progress has stalled on the second leg of the southwest transit corridor because the city and the province aren't able to sit down and work out some of the funding glitches.
Mayor Katz said last month the project might not move forward because the province was refusing to provide a letter of support to the federal government for funding. The two sides also disagree on the funding arrangements, but the difference is only about $20 million, a relatively minor sum for a $350-million project. As the dispute spilled into the open, a cabinet minister told the mayor to stop "shouting his mouth off." Mr. Katz responded by calling the premier "pathetic."
The importance of rapid transit has increased with the opening of the new stadium at the University of Manitoba, but it could be delayed for many years if the city and province can't develop a working relationship.
The mayor and the premier don't have to like one another, but they have a duty to work together for the common good.
Editorials are the consensus view of the Winnipeg Free Press’ editorial board, comprising Catherine Mitchell, David O’Brien, Shannon Sampert, and Paul Samyn.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 24, 2013 A8
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Two more losses finish Manitoba
Community discusses Kapyong urban reserve plan
A delegate situation
Wilco, Arlo Guthrie to perform at 2015 Winnipeg Folk Festival
Gushue, Jacobs to clash in Brier playoff game
Harrison Ford survives crash-landing on golf course
RCMP warn public about "white money" scam
Convicted sex offender sentenced to 7 years for attacking neighbour
Hillary Clinton email trove reviewed for release, security
Life sentence is just that under bill
Canadian Ebola vaccine being put to the test
Envelopes with powder found at ministers' offices
Ashton says he can unite the party against Pallister’s PCs
Man admits to attacks, including sexually assaulting family member
Playoffs unlikely for Manitoba at Brier
New trial ordered for man convicted of 1984 killing of Winnipeg teen
Angry blasts at Prentice for blaming Albertans
Crave TV orders up first original series: Letterkenny
$500,000 a good investment
Canadian pastor detained in North Korea
Plane crashes on LA golf course; pilot critically injured
Birth most common reason for hospitalization in Manitoba: study
Clinton email policy violated Obama administration guidance
Alberta plans huge lease sale on caribou range
Death toll in east Ukraine mine blast reaches 33
Ferguson exposes police prejudice everywhere
Seething comedian fuels up on stupidity for volcanic eruptions
No word yet from Jets on Byfuglien's condition
CEO Sleepout raises $200K, enough to support 50 jobs for homeless
Plane skids off runway at LaGuardia, crashes through fence
Can you hear me now?
Ottawa, province contribute $1.5M to farm-safety projects
Vancouver port fire out; investigation begins
TSN tweet shows social media no Wild West: experts
Fight consensual, not assault: judge
No, really, it will get warm soon
Turmoil on the menu
Chip off the old Rock
Mourners bid goodbye to Froese boys