13°c A few clouds
6°c Clear
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Similarities, differences prove riveting
Jared Loughner (THE ASSOCIATED PRESS/U.S. MARSHAL'S OFFICE/ARCHIVES)
Related Items
-
Articles
Vince Li appears in a Portage la Prairie. court on August 5, 2008. (THE CANADIAN PRESS ARCHIVES)
The similarities between the Jared Loughner and Vince Li cases are riveting, as are their very different conclusions.
Loughner, who has been diagnosed with schizophrenia, pleaded guilty Tuesday to killing six people in a January 2011 Arizona shooting. He was sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole.
Loughner's attack wounded several people, including U.S. Representative Gabrielle Giffords, his intended target. The guilty plea allowed the 23-year-old college dropout to avoid the death penalty.
It also spared victims and their families the trauma of a trial.
The Associated Press reported Tuesday that Giffords and her husband welcomed the plea bargain.
"The pain and loss caused by the events of Jan. 8, 2011, are incalculable," Giffords said in a joint statement with her husband, Mark Kelly. "Avoiding a trial will allow us -- and we hope the whole Southern Arizona community -- to continue with our recovery."
In July 2008, Vince Li beheaded and cannibalized Tim McLean on a Greyhound bus bound for Winnipeg. Li, who was diagnosed with schizophrenia, was found not criminally responsible during a March 2009 trial. At the time of McLean murder, the then 40-year-old Li was suffering from violent hallucinations and believed he was acting on orders from a higher power.
He was sent indefinitely to the Selkirk Metal Health Centre, where he has been undergoing extensive psychiatric treatment. In May, Li was granted temporary supervised passes from the hospital. That decision was greeting with outrage by many across Canada.
McLean's mother, Carol De Delly, told me in May she didn't support calls for Li's incarceration in the regular prison system or his deportation back to his native China. She wanted no part of the minority who wanted Li physically harmed.
"They want to take care of Vince Li and treat him humanely. Fine. No wonder he's showing vast improvements. Compared to what he was like, no kidding," she said.
"(But) he needs to be kept there. He needs to be in a secure locked facility for the rest of his life."
Loughner's guilty plea came after more than a year of forcible medication to control his schizophrenia. Li has no choice about taking his medicine while he's in Selkirk.
According to the AP, the judge in Loughner's case said the killer was a different person after medication and able to help his lawyers in his defence. Judge Larry Burns said that observing Loughner in court left "no question that he understands what's happening today."
Li has said he now remembers killing McLean and no longer hears voices. He expressed regret for the slaying.
Two different judicial systems, two very different results. Because Jared Loughner has been treated and found to be competent when he takes psychotropic drugs, he goes to jail. Because Vince Li has been treated and shows signs of improvement, he goes out for walks.
Unlike in the U.S., our justice system doesn't try mentally ill offenders after we drug and treat them long enough to declare them competent. Vince Li was found not criminally responsible for his crime. This may gall, but we're not going to get another shot at him because his meds are working.
We shouldn't. We have to accept the opinions of trained professionals who work closely with the likes of Li.
A judge believed Vince Li didn't know what he was doing when he killed. The Arizona judge believed the same thing about Jared Loughner. Their system allows them to find a person incapable of a crime because of mental illness and, when they're medicated enough to form sentences that don't involve fantasy, put them away.
I'm not comfortable with the idea of Vince Li one day anonymously living in my neighbourhood or yours. But I'm bewildered by a system that determines a person was too ill to understand committing a crime, puts him on medication and then punishes him as if he were competent during the murder.
It's one or the other, and in both these cases it's the other.
lindor.reynolds@freepress.mb.ca
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 8, 2012 A4
More Latest News
- Back to Top
- Return to Latest News
More Latest News
(1 of 42 articles for today)
First Nation celebrates groundbreaking on city's first urban reserve
1:52 PM 0
About Lindor Reynolds
Lindor Reynolds began work at the Free Press as a 17-year-old proofreader. She was fired three weeks later.
Many years later, armed with a university education, she was hired as a columnist. During 16 years on the job she has managed to avoid being sacked again.
Lindor has received considerable recognition for her writing. Her awards include the Will Rogers Humanitarian Award, the National Society of Newspaper Columnists’ general interest award and the North American Travel Journalists Association award.
She has earned three nominations for the Michener Award and has been awarded a Distinguished Alumni commendation from the University of Winnipeg. Lindor was also named a YWCA Woman of Distinction.
She is married with four daughters.
Poll
Most Popular Latest News
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Two men now facing first-degree murder charges in Tim Bosma test drive death
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- New downtown tower could be 42 storeys tall: developers
- Flood money paid for CEO's romantic trip
- Vendor fired at Houston's Minute Maid Park after taking tray of snow cones into bathroom
- Winnipeg woman camps out in front of legislature to protest child welfare
- Thompson RCMP find their suspect
- Crash claims two young women, RCMP say
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- 87-year-old woman tells jurors, 'Somebody had to stand up to' Donald Trump
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Horrific crash kills minivan driver near Brandon
- Woman killed in head-on crash in southwestern Manitoba
- Charleswood deaths being investigated as domestic incident
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Winnipeg woman camps out in front of legislature to protest child welfare
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Seattle man dribbling soccer ball to Brazil killed by car on Oregon Coast
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- 87-year-old woman tells jurors, 'Somebody had to stand up to' Donald Trump
- Driver crashes into tree near golf course
- Arrests made after raids on local head shops
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- News of city's $17-million winner leaks out on FB
- Passengers from diverted flight to leave Winnipeg Thursday night
- No threat from bag found at Winnipeg Square
- Susan Griffiths dies in Switzerland
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- Youths in Stockholm burn down restaurant, torch more than 30 cars in 4th night of rioting
- Heritage Winnipeg hosting 10th annual Doors Open Winnipeg this weekend
- Landslide of love for Fleetwood Mac
- 2 dead in crash near Portage la Prairie
- Vendor fired at Houston's Minute Maid Park after taking tray of snow cones into bathroom
- Quicker pickup of bulk garbage urged
- Privacy commissioner wants power to impose 8-figure fines against offenders
- Underwood leaves fans blown away
- New owner for lumber stores
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- Marsh Madness: Photographers Fred Greenslade and Joe Bryksa capture spring migration's grandeur at Delta Marsh
- Chiropractor guilty of sexually assaulting, beating ex-girlfriend
- Horrific crash kills minivan driver near Brandon
- Prominent Canadians back petition to rename Victoria Day to honour aboriginals
- Famous city grocer loved job, customers
- Animals are animals, new ads say
- Skin picking gets status as distinct disorder, should help sufferers access help
- New owner for lumber stores
- Aboriginal leader Elijah Harper dies
- Dogs can experience separation anxiety and depression just like humans
- Ontario steps in to help save ELA
- Saskatchewan professor wants to test the health benefits of nose-picking
- 'Revenge of the redheads': Ginger-haired Montrealers gather in celebration
- An uncommon phenomenon
- Grocer Joe Cantor dies at 88
- Passengers from diverted flight to leave Winnipeg Thursday night
- Hundreds pitch in to dig out houses damaged, destroyed by Ochre Beach ice floe
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.