The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 03/14/2013 7:08 PM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 03/15/2013 5:53 AM
LONDON - Young men who have served in the British military are about three times more likely than civilians to have committed a violent offence, researchers reported Friday in a study that explores the roots of such behaviour.
The research found that merely being sent to Iraq or Afghanistan made no difference in rates of violent crime later on. Instead, a key predictor was violent behaviour before enlisting. Combat duty also raised the risk, as did witnessing traumatic events during deployment or misusing alcohol afterward.
Still, the vast majority — 94 per cent — of British military staff who return home after serving in a combat zone don't commit any crimes, researchers told reporters at a briefing.
The study found little difference in the lifetime rates of violent offences between military personnel and civilian populations at age 46 — 11 per cent versus almost 9 per cent. Among younger men, however, being in the military seemed to make a difference: Nearly 21 per cent of the military group under age 30 had a conviction for a violent offence in their lifetime compared to fewer than 7 per cent of similarly aged men in the general population, according to British crime statistics.
"The problem is that some of the qualities you want in a soldier are the same ones that get people arrested for violent behaviour," said Walter Busuttil, director of medical services for Combat Stress, a British veterans' charity that was not part of the study. Busuttil said many of those recruited into the army are from disadvantaged backgrounds where violence is more common.
The research was published online Friday in the medical journal Lancet. Researchers at the Institute of Psychiatry at King's College London looked at data from more than 13,800 U.K. military personnel and veterans and compared that to records of violent crimes ranging from verbal threats to assaults and homicides. Some people were followed for up to seven years. Nearly 1,500 women were included, though they were mostly in noncombat roles.
Deirdre MacManus, the study's lead author, said combat experience seemed to matter when they compared violent crime rates among military personnel. "Being deployed in itself wasn't a risk factor for violent offences but being exposed to multiple traumas, like seeing someone get shot, increased the risk by 70 to 80 per cent," she said, compared to someone who hadn't witnessed such a harrowing ordeal.
Researchers said other studies have made similar findings.
Britain currently has some 5,000 soldiers in the NATO-led mission fighting in Afghanistan and it is the second-largest foreign contingent after the U.S. It withdrew its soldiers from Iraq in 2009 after six years. The U.K. Ministry of Defence has been under pressure to develop more mental health programs for veterans after reports of returning servicemen committing crimes, like the 2012 case of an ex-soldier in Leeds jailed for shooting his landlady after fighting in Afghanistan. He had been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder but had not been monitored or treated.
In the U.S., there have been numerous cases of veterans committing violent crimes, including a Marine charged with killing six people in California last year. Soldiers from a single Army unit in Colorado killed 11 people over a few years after their return home. An Army report in 2009 placed part of the blame on the psychological trauma of fierce combat in Iraq. And this week, a U.S. Senate panel heard women in the military describe sexual assaults by fellow soldiers.
American researchers said it is possible the same links the British study found between fighting in a war and violent crime exist in the U.S. but that there isn't enough data yet.
"For some soldiers, it's hard to stop being a warrior," said Brett Litz, a psychology professor at Boston University who studies veterans' issues. "What happens during a war may be a prescription for a small percentage of men to get into trouble," he said. "They may find it very difficult to switch out of a wartime mindset."
But given the differences between Britain and the U.S., Litz said it was impossible to predict what effects would be seen in the United States. "Maybe the economy is better here, maybe the (department of defence) does a better job with transition, maybe (the) culture is different especially with respect to alcohol," Litz said.
"There will be a lot of returning soldiers who have to be reintegrated and unfortunately there is no quick fix," he said.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Adult sentence sought for youth in assault case
Harper reaches into Quebec bar for top jurist
Funds for Guay Park riverbank project going to balance city's books instead
Cabinet rebel Theresa Oswald says she's considering an NDP leadership run
Heffel art auction hits $12 million in sales
Woman gets two-year jail term for running over man with his own truck
Cornish named CFL's top Canadian again
Canada sends army parkas to Ukrainian troops
Levant ordered to pay $80,000 in lawsuit
@Canada a gift from Spanish shoeshine man
Family: Boy's fatal shooting could have been avoided
Newfoundlanders want facts on suspended MP
Expert says Magnotta was organized after Lin's death
Ikea monkey in the market for new home
Ferguson gives thanks after a quiet night
Fifteen Manitoba First Nations haven't disclosed their financial documents
Jets centre Lowry slapped with one-game suspension
City's planning, property and development chief plans to retire
Winnipeg's first battery-powered electric bus goes into service tomorrow
MD sees charges dropped
News and talk radio still at the top of Winnipeg radio ratings
City committee gives three fire halls historic designations
Liquor store workers start voting today on possible strike before Christmas
Siloam Mission opens podiatry room to help homeless with foot care
Zoo has faults, but it's not all bad
Polo Park debuts shopping app in time for Black Friday
Queen of crime writing PD James dies aged 94
CBC, NHL websites briefly affected by hack
Flap over leadership-vote plans
Sexual-assault myths persist
Ferguson fallout: Dozens arrested in Calif. unrest
Bowman among local celebrities to appear in RWB's Nutcracker
Manitoba economic outlook 'a good news story': Conference Board
'Fun party for two' ends in tragedy
General strike shuts down services across Greece
'Bannock Lady' Guiboche among human rights awards recipients
Farmers' incomes beefed up
Tory MP retracts video devices advice
Warmer weather -- and snow -- on the way
Ugly but still worth two points