Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 07/5/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 07/5/2013 7:54 AM | Updates
If you thought Winnipeg's glorious heat wave and a done-deal tax hike might spell the end of the PST hearings, you don't know Keith Bazin and Allison Campbell.
Bucking speculation the long, hot hearings on Bill 20 might be fizzling, Bazin and Campbell were part of a strong turnout at the Manitoba legislature Thursday night.
Instead of watching the Bomber game, Bazin chose to sit through several hours of moderately repetitive public presentations in a stuffy old committee room with a lot of sweaty Manitobans.
"That's how annoyed I am at this bill," said Bazin, a class 1 truck driver.
-- Keith Bazin
Thursday was the fourth evening of hearings on the PST hike, all following a similar pattern. People blister NDP MLAs with accusations of fiscal mismanagement, dishonesty and despotism. Finance Minister Stan Struthers politely thanks the presenters, and Tory MLAs ask loaded questions designed in part to run down the clock.
Earlier this week, the hearings ended early when more than half the speakers were no-shows. But 22 people spoke Wednesday, keeping MLAs at the table until 11:30 p.m., and Thursday was on track for the same.
But why spend a precious summer evening railing against a done deal?
"The way I see it, nothing's a done deal," said Bazin. "The next election, hopefully they'll be defeated and they'll repeal this increase."
Allison Campbell, who owns a spa and a bookkeeping business, was a little more attuned to the futility of it all.
After distancing herself from those who call New Democrats liars and acknowledging governments occasionally need to raise taxes, Campbell systematically schooled MLAs on the cumulative and devastating trickle-down effect of the PST increase on consumers.
She said she was glad she spoke first before MLAs had completely wilted.
"I think they heard what I was saying, but I don't think it will change anything," said Campbell outside in the cool hallway. "The thing I didn't get to say was how angry I am as a taxpayer that they're running roughshod over the (referendum) law -- 'Nope, doesn't matter. We're going to do it anyway.' "
It was the first time Campbell had ever spoken to a legislative committee. Out in the hallway, she said she felt satisfied she'd said her piece.
Tory Leader Brian Pallister popped out of the committee room to shake Campbell's hand, towering over the petite lady and shmoozing her in his shirtsleeves, as he has done with nearly every presenter in recent evenings.
Thursday's hearings were sprinkled with some people, including union leaders, who support the PST hike, giving the NDP a short respite from some harsh words. Norm Gould, vice-president of the Manitoba Teachers' Society, told MLAs the PST hike and proper investments in education are a vital antidote to the cuts of the 1990s. Others, including Lynne Fernandez from the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, said the NDP is making a wise long-term decision despite the short-term political pain.
But Bazin, who deliberately rushed out to buy a tent-trailer before the hike took effect Monday, said the PST has changed his political allegiance.
Not an overly partisan guy, he voted for Education Minister Nancy Allan and the NDP in the last election, but says a two-year wait for the next campaign will not dampen his anger.
"Every time I look at that tent-trailer, it will remind me of the PST," he said.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 5, 2013 A8
Updated on Friday, July 5, 2013 at 7:54 AM CDT: adds link, adds sidebar
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Families struck by tragedies consoled at massive vigil
US officials: Video shows American's beheading
Aboriginal girl's death renews calls for inquiry
Alberta investigates 122 cases of E. coli
Blast in China coal mine kills 2, traps 25 miners
Official: 4 of 6 child hostages freed in Harvey
New Bomber uniforms unveiled
Man admits to stabbing girlfriend to death, then leaving five-year-old son alone with body
City's real estate division trying to rush new land sale: Havixbeck
Gaza cease-fire efforts collapse in heavy fighting
Canada pondering pot options: justice minister
Ads accuse federal government of mismanaging money for flood evacuees
Lake Manitoba residents criticize government's water policy and push for outlet channel
Inmate charged in child-killer's death
Governor won't seek removal of county prosecutor
Brian Pallister criticizes government after debt rating downgrade
Safety board report blames Ottawa, railway
Jets captain Ladd 'accidentally' favourites tweet by fan critical of GM Cheveldayoff
Evening vigil planned for Fontaine, Hall
Longtime 'SNL' announcer Don Pardo dies at 96
Settlement reached in Moore-Bertuzzi suit
Will Scotland leave and how will this all work?
Greens to choose new leader in November
Conservatives defend CRA's charity audits
Thousands of intense earthquakes rock Iceland
Tragic end for homeless hero
Families relive loss of loved ones after teen's body found in river
Foggy start, but sun expected later today
New bill balances privacy and national security with a lean toward privacy
Toddler missing for a day found in bush
Argentina car crash kills 3 relatives of pope
Ground zero for Bombers
Liberia president declares Ebola curfew
San Gold to merge with Kerr Mines
Germany: Looted painting belongs to Jewish family
His 101st birthday present? Another day at work
Actress no longer green with envy now that she's donned the black hat of Wicked's Elphaba
Killing for God: In the Great War, religion was both a crutch and a sword
Ukrainian forces press attacks on rebel-held areas
Ukraine: Dozens killed in shelling of convoy