24°c Partly cloudy
18°c Cloudy periods
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
The best price is no deal at all
Loyalty rewards programs carry hidden costs
One of my assignments as an investment analyst was to study Aeroplan, Air Canada's loyalty reward program.
The airline had just carved Aeroplan out of the company and floated it as a separate business on the stock market.
It's a complicated business at first glance. For example, CIBC offered the extremely popular Aerogold Visa card. You spend money using the card and you get Aeroplan points. What is actually happening, though, is that CIBC is buying the points from Aeroplan and giving them to you. When you were ready to cash in your points, Aeroplan shelled out to buy a flight from Air Canada, if that's what you chose, or a frying pan or mixer etc. if you preferred something else.
It didn't take me long to realize what a great business Aeroplan and loyalty programs in general are. They make lots of money by relying on a key human instinct: our love of the deal. It also made me realize consumers should avoid things like loyalty programs and other selling gimmicks.
The perception of a bargain makes us completely irrational. How many times have I had a conversation with a female friend that goes something like:
"Do you like my new dress? I got if for 60 per cent off."
"How much was it?"
"Only $200!"
"So you saved $133?"
"I guess."
To which I would answer, "You should have bought 10 of them and saved $1,333, then you could have taken your savings and bought 10 pairs of shoes at a big discount and done it all over again."
And that's when it sinks in.
Credit card loyalty programs are similar: They are only an illusion of value. Aeroplan makes a lot of money. Who ultimately provides those profits? People who collect Aeroplan points. You and me. We're not really getting a free flight. We pay for it.
My local grocery store accepts Air Miles and also has an in-house card that gives discounts on goods and gasoline. Most people see that as a bargain, but it's not. We pay for it one way or the other. I compared prices between that store and another store that has no loyalty offerings and found the prices were at least 10 per cent lower in the store with no program. That's not a scientific study, but it's not hard to believe, is it?
It's not just loyalty programs, either. Furniture stores that sell you a couch you don't have to pay for until 2014 or whatever are selling you a fantasy. You are paying more for that couch -- a lot more. That chain's profit margins are going to be higher than a no-frills chain's.
Banks used to offer GICs that are linked to the market's return but guarantee the principal. (They're not too popular now because of the market turmoil.) I know from banking friends that this was a particularly profitable line of business. In fact, insurance -- this product was effectively an insured investment -- is often overpriced. Travel insurance, for instance, is very expensive. It doesn't seem that way because most people weigh the cost of the insurance against what they'd have to pay if something went wrong and they didn't have insurance. But that leaves out a crucial piece of the equation: the probability of needing insurance, which is extremely low. It's not that insurance is a bad idea; it's just that it's easy to overpay.
A twist on insurance is the extended warranty. Never, ever buy an extended warranty. Companies make far greater profit margins on these than on the products they sell -- often 90 per cent. In fact, some retailers make the bulk of their profits selling warranties.
If something is going to malfunction, it is likely to happen before the regular warranty expires.
In short, use your head. There's nothing for free in this world. When it looks free, it's often actually more expensive than if you just bought it.
Fabrice Taylor is an award-winning financial journalist and analyst and author of the President's Club Investment Letter. Email him at:
fabrice.taylor@gmail.com
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 14, 2012 $sourceSection0
Fact Check
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
More Personal Finance
- Back to Top
- Return to Personal Finance
More Personal Finance
(1 of 7 articles for this week)
Parents unsure how to teach children about money
9:00 AM 0(Special) - Parents generally seem to be in a quandary about how to teach their children about money and investing, ...
Poll
Most Popular Personal Finance
- Parents unsure how to teach children about money
- Some Canadians still slow to learn rules of tax-free savings accounts
- If parents die in debt, children don't necessarily inherit the bills: experts
- Canadian real estate industry says 2013 sales off to better start than expected
- Warren Buffett -- Winnipeg-style
- Overbuilt, overpriced condo market a risk to households, economy, says BoC
- The cautious grandma
- MONEY MATTERS: The high cost of eating
- New lease in life
- Bridging the gap
- If parents die in debt, children don't necessarily inherit the bills: experts
- Warren Buffett -- Winnipeg-style
- Some Canadians still slow to learn rules of tax-free savings accounts
- Overbuilt, overpriced condo market a risk to households, economy, says BoC
- Financial education improving: not there yet
- The cautious grandma
- With OAS, 'bird in the hand' is often best
- The $2-million question
- Bridging the gap
- Fee advice
- Canadians ask Bank of Canada about maple syrup smell on new bank notes
- Bridging the gap
- Canadian non-mortgage debt shows biggest quarterly decline since 2004
- Pension plan and problem-free?
- Housing slowdown to worsen, cost 150,000 jobs, says mortgage group
- The $2-million question
- Women not satisfied with financial services
- To buy or to keep renting? Costs go beyond just the mortgage payments
- Scotiabank sees risk of single-digit cut in real estate prices by mid-decade
- Snowbirds: It's that time of year again
- Warren Buffett -- Winnipeg-style
- What recovery? For young Canadians, labour market as bad as during the recession
- The $2-million question
- Snowbirds: It's that time of year again
- Bridging the gap
- With OAS, 'bird in the hand' is often best
- Pension plan and problem-free?
- Warren Buffett -- Winnipeg-style
- Canadians ask Bank of Canada about maple syrup smell on new bank notes
- Can signing a roommate agreement protect your finances if things go sour?
- New lease in life
- Canadian non-mortgage debt shows biggest quarterly decline since 2004
- Women not satisfied with financial services
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
Have Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?
Login SubscribeHave Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?
SubscribeThe Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.