Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 04/9/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 04/9/2013 8:14 AM | Updates
Winnipeg's resale-homes market experienced its bleakest March in nearly 20 years, which industry analysts say is the result of everything from Old Man Winter to tougher mortgage rules.
The Winnipeg Realtors Association (WRA) said only 844 properties changed hands last month through the local Multiple Listing Service (MLS). That was a drop of 26 per cent from a year earlier, when 1,138 properties were sold, and was the lowest March sales total since 1995.
"Instead of March madness, it was March calmness, with buyers noticeably absent from our MLS market at this time of year," said WRA president Richard Dettman.
First-time buyers, in particular, were staying away.
It was the second consecutive double-digit, year-over-year, sales decline for the Winnipeg market, which saw sales tumble by 11 per cent in February after posting the second-busiest January on record at the start of the year.
The question is whether the last two months were just a pause in the action, or whether the market slowdown gripping some of the country's most overheated markets such as Vancouver and Toronto is finally gaining traction here.
Most of industry players and observers interviewed Monday said the answer to that question likely won't be known for at least a couple of more months.
Dettman said local real estate agents will watch April sales closely to see if the spring thaw brings more buyers out of the woodwork.
And Dianne Himbeault, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp.'s senior market analyst for Winnipeg, said what happens during the next two months, traditionally two of the busiest sales months of the year, should give a better indication of where the local market is heading.
Himbeault said April alone might not give a true indication because of the looming spring flood, which can be a distraction for both homebuyers and sellers.
Dettman and two past WRA presidents -- Claude Davis of Royal LePage Dynamic Real Estate and Ralph Fyfe of Century 21 Bachman and Associates -- maintained the weather was one of the biggest contributors to last month's decline in sales activity.
"I think the biggest thing going on is that this is the seventh month that we've had snow on the ground," Fyfe said. "People are fed up with it."
He said the snow was long gone and the spring market was already in full swing by this time last year, and this year it isn't even out of the staring blocks yet.
"When people still see snow on their lawn, they're not quick to either buy or sell or move," Dettman added.
He and Davis said last summer's tightening of federal mortgage insurance rules is also keeping some first-time buyers on the sidelines until they can save up a bigger down payment for a home.
"But I don't think it's been as big an issue in Winnipeg as it has in some other cities," where house prices are considerably higher, Davis added.
Himbeault said other factors have also been at play here. Wage increases haven't kept pace with inflation, and employment growth hasn't been as strong in the key 25- to 44-year age group.
She said she's also heard some agents say some buyers are being more fussy about what they buy, opting to wait for the right house at the right price rather than settling for whatever they can get.
Robert Hogue, senior economist with RBC Economics, said the Winnipeg market may also see "a little bit of payback" after January's strong performance.
"But that's not different from other markets in Canada." he said. "That (a softening in the demand for homes) has been the general trend... and Winnipeg is not an island unto itself."
Hogue said he wouldn't be surprised if sales bounce back a little here and elsewhere in Canada during the next few months, and then level off.
"But I'm not suggesting a major rebound," he added.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition April 9, 2013 B6
Updated on Tuesday, April 9, 2013 at 8:14 AM CDT: replaces photo, adds fact box
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Pipeline survey crews move out of disputed area
Venezuela looks to cut spending as oil prices fall
Battery-powered bus to hit city streets
Utilities Commission approves Altalink sale
Cattle workers stampede to oilpatch
Fund salesman banned for life in $6.6M
CRA looks to put a value on goodwill
Most actively traded companies on the TSX
U.S. appeals WTO COOL meat-label ruling
NY dealership ceiling partly collapses, killing 1
Argentina IDs accounts in alleged tax evasion
Crime surge accompanies Wyoming oil boom
Beyond oilpatch, little alarm from crude drop
Grain mixed, livestock mixed
Protesters leave Manitoba hydro dam after deal
Christie vetoes politically charged pig crate bill
Halliburton and Macy's big market movers
Eisner: NFL team would boost downtown Los Angeles
Recalls this week: battery packs, doors
S&P 500 ends lower as oil slump hits market
Candy distribution centre in Ohio ravaged by fire
Initial public offerings scheduled to debut next week
Tunisia's outgoing premier backs broad coalition
Brazil's GDP grows slightly in third quarter
US stock market opens mixed as oil tumbles
Past ban on marrying blacks may mar tribe's future
BCE buying wireless retailer Glentel
Enbridge buys 80 per cent stake in wind farms
Germany signs no-spy deal with BlackBerry
Falling oil prices continue to pressure loonie
Economy grew by 2.8 per cent pace in Q3
Falling energy stocks help push TSX lower
Winnipeg shoppers hope for Black Friday deals
Plunging crude prices hammer energy companies
Black Friday gets a little less frenzied
Malaysia Airlines apologizes for tweet, posts loss
BLACK FRIDAY LIVE: Thinner crowds, protests, beer
Swiss to vote on massive gold-buying plan