13°c Light rain showers
18°c Cloudy with sunny breaks
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Lawyers ordered to step down after files taken
National-security case not stayed
Mohamed Mahjoub is still considered a threat. (JEAN LEVAC / POSTMEDIA NEWS ARCHIVES)
TORONTO -- Eleven federal lawyers and assistants have been ordered to step down from a long-running national security case in an unusual court ruling that stops short of staying the proceedings.
The order comes after the government inadvertently took confidential legal files belonging to Mohamed Mahjoub, who has been imprisoned or under house arrest for a dozen years based on secret evidence.
In reaching his decision, Federal Court Justice Edmond Blanchard decided to banish the 11 Department of Justice lawyers and clerks "in the interest of ensuring public confidence in the administration of justice."
Blanchard had harsh words for Ottawa's "negligent" conduct, saying the seriousness of the consequences "cannot be overstated."
Ottawa accuses Mahjoub, 51, an Egyptian citizen living in Toronto since 1995, of posing a threat to public safety. It first slapped him with a national security certificate in 2000.
The father of three, who remains under house arrest, has been fighting to clear his name, claiming abuse of process.
Last summer, government lawyers inadvertently took confidential files belonging to his legal team from a locked courthouse room.
Mahjoub's lawyers argued the document seizure had irreparably damaged his right to a fair process and violated his constitutional rights.
They said the government had breached two fundamental tenets of the justice system: solicitor-client privilege and litigation privilege.
Blanchard agreed to a point -- but refused to toss the proceedings despite finding the situation "an affront to fair play and decency."
He found the government had not examined the Mahjoub files in any detail.
Society's interest in seeing the case decided on its merits outweighs the prejudice to Mahjoub, the judge decided.
"The conduct of the ministers, although negligent, was unintentional."
Mahjoub, who has never been charged with any crime in Canada, expressed disappointment at the decision.
"I thought that this time, finally, justice would be served and that I would be freed," Mahjoub said.
"Another year of my life gone, and who pays the price?"
Mahjoub's supporters were outraged and his lawyers said they were pondering an appeal.
One of his lawyers, Yavar Hameed, called the situation unprecedented.
"The circumstances of this case and the prejudicial nature of documents seized distinguish this as perhaps one of the clearest and damaging cases of document seizure in Canadian judicial history," Hameed said.
Although he refused to stay the proceedings, Blanchard did say Mahjoub can use the charter breach related to the seized documents and the delay sorting out the mess caused in his ongoing battle to toss the proceedings as an abuse of process.
The government alleges he had high-level links to a terrorist organization in Egypt, which he fled in the mid-1990s.
The government insists Mahjoub still has extremist beliefs and remains a threat to public safety despite having had no contact with former associates for 16 years.
-- The Canadian Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 2, 2012 A23
More Canada
- Back to Top
- Return to Canada
More Canada
(1 of 17 articles for today)
Manitoba government says Elijah Harper's body will lie in state at legislature
6:50 PM 0
Poll
Most Popular Canada
- Quake shakes Ontario, Quebec
- Sen. Pamela Wallin, target of expense audit, latest to leave Conservative caucus
- Crack-cocaine video allegations 'ridiculous,' Toronto Mayor Rob Ford says
- Father and two children fighting for lives after Montreal area house fire
- Calgary man charged with murder of woman and her five-year-old son
- Tirades won't stop global warming: Harper
- Toronto Mayor Rob Ford nixes weekend radio show in wake of video controversy
- Crack-smoking claim dogs mayor
- Senate committee to take sober second look at Duffy's expense reports
- Another senator leaves Tory caucus
- First-degree murder charge to be laid in test drive death; remains badly burned
- Crack-cocaine video allegations 'ridiculous,' Toronto Mayor Rob Ford says
- Duffy bailout by Harper's chief of staff prompts allegations of coverup by PMO
- Duffy quits Conservative caucus over expenses as colleagues began turning on him
- Liberals blaze to stunning B.C. victory, but Clark loses own seat
- Quake near Ottawa rattles residents across wide swath of Ontario, Quebec
- Sen. Pamela Wallin, target of expense audit, latest to leave Conservative caucus
- Conservative senator Duffy claimed expenses while campaigning in 2011 election
- Arrest made in case of Hamilton, Ont., man missing after pickup truck test drive
- Duffy's public salary, benefits don't paint picture of man down on his luck
- First-degree murder charge to be laid in test drive death; remains badly burned
- Multiple fatalities after serious crash near U.S. border
- Canadian tourist dies after falling from hotel in Mexican resort
- Engineer charged in mall collapse
- Arrest made in case of Hamilton, Ont., man missing after pickup truck test drive
- Crack-cocaine video allegations 'ridiculous,' Toronto Mayor Rob Ford says
- Leaving Saskatoon: police mourn homeless drunk they considered a friend
- Man with no arms plans to fight seatbelt ticket, wants apology from police
- Suspects arrested in Via train terror plot linked to al-Qaida in Iran: RCMP
- Duffy bailout by Harper's chief of staff prompts allegations of coverup by PMO
- Secret CSIS source, allied intelligence cited in high-profile terror case
- Promising new way of fighting cancer
- Quake shakes Ontario, Quebec
- U.S. bill would give Canadian snowbirds more time to spend in the sun
- Duffy bailout by Harper's chief of staff prompts allegations of coverup by PMO
- First-degree murder charge to be laid in test drive death; remains badly burned
- Search on for living creatures far beneath Canadian Shield
- Quake near Ottawa rattles residents across wide swath of Ontario, Quebec
- Effort afoot in court to sue Canadians for illegal downloads
- 'Not looking for blame,' grieving father says of fatal rugby tackle
- Federal Court to test expedited hearings for some visa-rejection reviews
- Conservative senator Duffy claimed expenses while campaigning in 2011 election
- Grade 5 kids urge Harper to drop mean attack ads against Justin Trudeau
- U.S. bill would give Canadian snowbirds more time to spend in the sun
- Foul fascination: Edmonton plant beautiful, but stinks like diapers, dead animals
- 'Revenge of the redheads': Ginger-haired Montrealers gather in celebration
- Man with no arms plans to fight seatbelt ticket, wants apology from police
- Suspects arrested in Via train terror plot linked to al-Qaida in Iran: RCMP
- Leaving Saskatoon: police mourn homeless drunk they considered a friend
- Commanding officer of Canadian Forces base in Alberta charged with sex assault
- Duffy bailout by Harper's chief of staff prompts allegations of coverup by PMO
- An in-depth look at not criminally responsible through the eyes of a patient
- Engineer charged in mall collapse
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.