Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Arguments to begin over sex-trade ruling
TORONTO -- Johns openly soliciting prostitutes near schoolyards, brothels with naked women dancing in the windows and Canada becoming a destination for trafficking young girls -- these are some of the doomsday scenarios the federal government cautions may occur if Ontario's highest court agrees this week to uphold an earlier decision to decriminalize the sex-trade industry.
Ottawa and the provincial government will begin arguments to a five-justice panel today at the Ontario Court of Appeal on why a lower-court judge erred last year when she struck down three prostitution-related laws as unconstitutional.
In a controversial, 130-page decision that took more than one year to prepare, Ontario Superior Court Justice Susan Himel concluded the provisions prohibiting operating or working in a brothel, communicating for the purpose of prostitution and living off the avails of prostitution contravene a person's right to safety and liberty and endanger sex workers by forcing them to ply their trade underground.
To the three women who launched the constitutional challenge five years ago, this appeal has little to do with morality or public opinion of selling one's body for money but the obligation the law has to protect all its citizens, regardless of occupation.
"The laws are not working at all," said complainant Valerie Scott, a longtime prostitute and massage-parlour worker. "We need occupational health and safety options. We need to be treated like the legitimate business we are."
Scott, who is also the legal adviser for the national Toronto-based group, Sex Professionals of Canada, argues the governments are using "fear-mongering" tactics to scare the public about the realities of the sex-trade industry. She contends that if prostitutes were permitted to work openly, they would be able to organize in groups for protection, get away from pimps and not be afraid to report abuses by clients to the police. They also would be able to have more financial security, pay taxes and support themselves without fear of prosecution.
But in a lengthy factum filed three months ago, the government stated its position that sex workers should have no expectations of being safe when they choose to enter into an illegal trade, one that is rife with crime, drugs and violence. Furthermore, the dangerous conditions surrounding the underground industry are a result of their efforts to evade the law, and should not justify those laws being changed.
-- Postmedia News
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 13, 2011 A6
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories?
Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
(1 of 18 articles for today)2:55 PM 0
STEINBACH, Man. - A dry community in southern Manitoba has discovered it's actually wet.
Officials with the Rural Municipality of Hanover ...
Photo Store Gallery
- WestJet plane lands safely in Toronto after reporting engine trouble
- Sweeping report released on Toronto police encounters with those in crisis
- Fox gets famous after photographed sleeping aboard Ottawa city bus
- Rescued false killer whale calf passes first hurdle in long-odds battle
- Cdn activists to lug jugs of water to Detroit in H2O march to help residents
- Calgary man reunited with his beloved little red Corvette named Betsy
- Restrictions on transporting firearms to be eased under federal proposal
- Man with air gun arrested at pro-Israel rally held at Calgary Jewish centre
- Air Algerie flight 'probably crashed'; 5 Canadians among 116 on board: officials
- Charities may be asked for donor lists under CRA proposal floated by minister
- Ontario medical student, girlfriend among passengers of doomed Malaysian flight
- Mayor of Montreal-area community dies after being stung by wasps
- Police investigate suspicious death at Pemberton, B.C. Music Festival
- Duffy accused of charging for personal trainer, makeup artist, funeral travel
- Canadian teacher detained in Jakarta jail on accusations of child sexual assault
- RCMP in New Brunswick completes investigation in python deaths, now with Crown
- Big Lake Ontario shark hoax shows risks posed by viral marketing, experts say
- New report questions Canadian Ukraine election monitoring missions
- Edmonton drug dealers handing out cocaine samples to potential customers
- Survivor of plane crash, family of dead passenger still seeking damages from airline
- Family of missing boy, grandparents won't give up on finding them alive
- Calgary police confirm violent incident in case of missing boy, grandparents
- $20,000 per person:Activists push for guaranteed minimum income for Canadians
- 'We're lucky to have her in our lives;' baby survives crash that killed mother
- Suspect in case of missing grandparents and child to make court appearance
- Moms change diapers, Dads form leaders: Justice minister's emails to staff
- Investigators bring in boat in search near Calgary-area acreage in missing family case
- Calgary police say there are other leads in case of missing boy, grandparents
- Police say search near Airdrie part of probe into missing Calgary residents
- Calgary police finish looking for evidence in missing couple's home
Ads by Google