Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 10/22/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
OTTAWA -- Mike Duffy once promised his side of the story on his dealings with the Prime Minister's Office and the $90,000 payment of contested expenses.
On Monday, his lawyer helped break the senator's silence with what he called "the tip of the iceberg" of evidence.
Donald Bayne spent nearly an hour alleging Prime Minister Stephen Harper's staff and key Conservative senators developed a scheme to have Duffy take the fall for wrongdoing even they agreed he had not done.
Harper, meanwhile, continued to lay blame for the matter Monday on a single person -- his former chief of staff, Nigel Wright.
"The whole political decision-making about this has been a fiasco," Bayne told reporters.
"From the get-go, rather than letting the truth out, that there are flaws in the Senate system and rules, it's the old story. The coverup is always more damaging than the original issue."
Duffy is facing the threat of suspension without pay from the upper chamber for "gross negligence" in the management of resources, along with colleagues Pamela Wallin and Patrick Brazeau. Conservative motions are expected to be introduced today.
Last week, Wallin's lawyer also lashed out at the Conservatives and said legal options would be considered if the suspension occurred.
Bayne said Duffy never submitted any improper expense claims under the rules, borne out by an independent audit and in communications Duffy had with senior Tories. At issue was Duffy's designation of a house in Prince Edward Island as his primary residence and the living expenses he claimed for his Ottawa home.
The lawyer quoted from a letter by former Conservative Senate leader Marjory LeBreton in January 2009, in which she allegedly tells Duffy "Senate residency is not defined" anywhere in the rules. LeBreton could not immediately confirm whether she wrote such a letter.
Duffy also allegedly received an email from Wright in December 2012, when stories emerged suggesting Duffy spent little time at his P.E.I. residence.
"I am told that you have complied with all the applicable rules and there will be several senators with similar arrangements," Wright allegedly wrote. "This sure seems to be a smear."
By the following April, auditors at Deloitte had concluded a review of Duffy's living expenses and said residency rules weren't clear.
Another Conservative, Sen. John Wallace of the ethics committee, also allegedly wrote a memo saying the residency rules were not clear and quoted from a Senate handbook on the matter. Wallace's office said Monday he had no comment.
Bayne said Duffy was then told by the Prime Minister's Office that although his expenses were above board, he would have to repay four years' worth to appease Tory voters.
When Duffy objected, Bayne said the Prime Minister's Office threatened to oust him by having a Senate committee declare his residency situation ineligible.
"So that's the hammer. The threat seems obvious: You take the dive, or this subcommittee will throw you out on the residency issue before you've had any kind of hearing," Bayne said.
Wright's payment of $90,000 to cover Duffy's expenses was never the senator's idea, he added.
"The payment of $90,000 was not the doing of Sen. Duffy. It was a political tactic forced on him by the Prime Minister's Office."
When the Deloitte audit came out in early May, the Tory-dominated committee dealing with the matter released an initial report uncritical of Duffy's expense claims.
Bayne also alleged the Prime Minister's Office effectively coached Duffy not to co-operate fully with the independent auditors and told him what to say to the media.
Duffy's lawyer did not provide reporters with copies of the emails and memos he read from, saying they would come out in the course of a trial should one occur.
-- The Canadian Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 22, 2013 A6
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Lawyer trying to block Alberta spring election
Canadian flights are safe: TSB investigator
Maple syrup producers anxious for warm days
Highlights of the Alberta budget
Winners and losers in the Alberta budget
Patient death in Newfoundland under review
Finding space for largest collection of Inuit art
Feds appeal injunction on N.W.T resources suit
Highlights of 2015-16 Quebec budget
Quebec tables balanced budget with debt in mind
High court rules on Quebec gun registry data
Regulator proposes new TV service code
Airlines to have two in cockpit at all times
Accused terrorist feared for his life
CBC News slashing 144 jobs, Radio-Canada cuts 100
Quebec judge calls Toews to task over ignoring letter from former landlord
Former minister Toews fights salary seizure
'Kitty, kitty' video shows lynx encounter
Ricki's, Bootlegger, Cleo in court protection
7 years for Toronto man who kidnapped, assaulted girl
Parties split over role of Canada in MidEast
Officer at CFB Valcartier faces charges
Former spy says protesters shouldn't worry
Defence costs 'unsustainable', says PBO
Poloz defends sudden rate cut in England
Trial in June in Halifax chemicals case
Quebec set to table 2015-16 budget today
Seven stories in the news today, March 26
Rights group presses watchdog on CSIS records
ISIL endeavour not a one-year mission: sources
Butt injection woman gets 8 years in prison
Undercover cop knew nothing of Rob Ford probe
Conflict creating record refugee claims: UN