The Canadian Press - ONLINE EDITION
Fatal accident after Quebec woman stopped for ducks not criminal: defence lawyer
MONTREAL - A driver's decision to stop her car on a highway to save ducklings was a spur of the moment decision and not a criminal act, says the lawyer for a woman on trial in the deaths of two people.
Emma Czornobaj, now 25, is charged in the 2010 deaths of a father and daughter who were riding a motorcycle that slammed into her idling car.
"You are in the presence here of an accident with no criminal element," her lawyer, Marc Labelle, told the jury Wednesday. "There is no bad intention anywhere on the accused's part."
Czornobaj is charged with two counts each of criminal negligence causing death and dangerous driving causing the deaths of Andre Roy, 50, and his 16-year-old daughter, Jessie, on June 27, 2010.
She was charged 14 months later.
The jury of 10 men and two women began hearing closing arguments from lawyers after the evidence wrapped up Wednesday.
Labelle told the jury his client made a snap decision to help the ducks.
He said the evidence suggests Czornobaj then took precautions to ensure no lives were endangered by parking as far over as she could in the left lane and activating her hazard lights.
She previously testified she left her door open and the engine running because she didn't expect to be there long.
Labelle said her decision could be questioned but that there was no criminal element to it.
"This accident was caused by this choice that she made in the first place," he conceded.
"But after she took that decision (to stop), she took all the necessary steps to make sure she would not endanger her life or the life of anybody."
Labelle suggested speed had a part to play.
At least two vehicles managed to get around her car. The Crown's expert testified that Roy's motorcycle was doing at least 105 km/h at the time of impact.
His wife, Pauline Volikakis, was travelling behind in another motorcycle at a slower pace and managed to stop.
Labelle said he wasn't trying to show Roy was guilty of anything, but that speed was an issue.
"I'm stressing this because it may be the reason for the accident," he explained.
The province's highway safety code states that stopping on a highway or walking on a highway are forbidden, although there is an exception in the case of a "necessity." A police witness for the Crown confirmed that necessity is not clearly defined.
"One may say that stopping for ducklings is not a necessity," Labelle said. "The other question is, 'OK, is it criminal?'"
He noted that Czornobaj has no previous record and has only lost two demerit points since earning her driver's licence at age 18.
Labelle argued that her version of the events opens the door to an acquittal on all counts.
But the Crown has contended that a reasonable and prudent person would not have stopped his or her car.
Czornobaj repeated she wanted to save the ducklings and that the mother duck wasn't present. A lover of animals, she said her intent was to put them in the back seat and drive them to her place. But they moved away as she approached.
During cross-examination, prosecutor Annie-Claude Chasse suggested to Czornobaj that her actions weren't logical.
The accused disagreed.
"At the time, it's what I decided to do," Czornobaj said.
And today?, Chasse asked.
"Obviously now I would not have stopped," she said.
Czornobaj was the only defence witness.
The Crown will present its closing arguments Thursday morning and the jury isn't expected to begin deliberations until next Monday.
Follow (at)sidhartha_b on Twitter.
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories?
Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
(1 of 40 articles for today)7:00 PM 0
HALIFAX - A Royal Canadian Navy ship will head to the Mediterranean to join an ongoing NATO mission in the ...
Photo Store Gallery
- RCMP in New Brunswick completes investigation in python deaths, now with Crown
- Edmonton drug dealers handing out cocaine samples to potential customers
- Survivor of plane crash, family of dead passenger still seeking damages from airline
- Can you keep a secret? Edmonton couple reveals $50M lotto win after 7 months
- Protesters denounce Israeli offensive in Gaza, call on Harper to support peace
- Death of a Quebec mayor from insect stings underscores need to be prepared
- Canada's border agency had thousands of outdated lookout flags in system
- List of charities undergoing tax audits related to political activities
- Fruit from California recalled due to possible Listeria contamination
- Suspect in Calgary stabbings sent to mental hospital for assessment
- RCMP charge Sen. Mike Duffy with fraud, breach of trust and bribery
- Ontario medical student, girlfriend among passengers of doomed Malaysian flight
- Conservative party president's 7-year-old daughter hit by minivan, killed
- Mayor of Montreal-area community dies after being stung by wasps
- Police investigate suspicious death at Pemberton, B.C. Music Festival
- Canadian teacher detained in Jakarta jail on accusations of child sexual assault
- Duffy accused of charging for personal trainer, makeup artist, funeral travel
- Big Lake Ontario shark hoax shows risks posed by viral marketing, experts say
- New report questions Canadian Ukraine election monitoring missions
- Cdns at odds with Harper gov't priorities: Finance Canada focus-group report
- Family of missing boy, grandparents won't give up on finding them alive
- Moms change diapers, Dads form leaders: Justice minister's emails to staff
- Calgary police confirm violent incident in case of missing boy, grandparents
- $20,000 per person:Activists push for guaranteed minimum income for Canadians
- 'We're lucky to have her in our lives;' baby survives crash that killed mother
- Suspect in case of missing grandparents and child to make court appearance
- Investigators bring in boat in search near Calgary-area acreage in missing family case
- Calgary police say there are other leads in case of missing boy, grandparents
- Ex-wife of B.C. homicide victim says man conned her; both appeared on Dr. Phil
- Police say search near Airdrie part of probe into missing Calgary residents
Ads by Google