Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
God save the King? Maybe... maybe not
Documentary finds Brits deeply divided on future of monarchy
Will Charles follow his mother to the throne or will MPs throw up a roadblock? (REX FEATURES)
As this hour-long meditation on the relevance of the British monarchy in 21st-century society begins, members of lofty Oxford University's debating society are sparring over precisely the question as to whether the royal line should continue beyond Queen Elizabeth II.
William Jones, holder of the title of world universities debating champion, is arguing in favour of the monarchy's preservation.
TV PREVIEW
After Elizabeth II: Monarchy in Peril
Written/directed by John Curtin
Tonight at 8
CBC
"We concede that the monarchy is irrelevant. It is undemocratic, it is unrepresentative, it is inbred, it is racist... it is anachronistic and it is elitist."
Oh, my. And he's on the side of the royals.
Clearly, the intent of this Doc Zone presentation (which airs tonight at 8 on CBC) is to portray the British royal family as a house under siege, a lineage with an uncertain future, a tradition whose time may soon have passed.
The underlying premise is that Queen Elizabeth II, at age 83, is surely in the final chapter of her reign over what's left of the British Empire. Even if she remains at her post until she dies -- which clearly seems to be her intention -- the conclusion of her tenure as wearer of the crown is on the horizon.
Despite having suffered several lifetimes' worth of trials and tribulations, Elizabeth II still enjoys widespread public support.
Since ascending to the throne at age 27, she has aged gracefully and endured stoically, and her public seems still to view her with great affection.
But after Elizabeth II... then what?
"They have to have the right person leading," says Katie Nicholl, Diary editor of The Mail on Sunday.
"If they make the wrong choice, then that will be the end of the monarchy."
The choices, of course, are very limited. There's the obvious and expected one -- the rise of Prince Charles, who has waited a lifetime for his turn to be king -- and then there's the less obvious, infinitely more tricky selection -- one of his sons, a choice that would only be made if the British Parliament decided that having Charles in charge would be detrimental to the institution.
Columnist Johann Hari of The Independent, no fan of the royals, favours the second option.
"When Elizabeth Windsor dies and she's replaced by a highly political, deeply weird man, the debate will be transformed," he offers, "particularly since he has announced that he intends to interfere with politics, using his unelected power to lobby for eccentric political causes.
"An overtly political king will be the death of the monarchy."
With camera and microphone in tow, Montreal filmmaker John Curtin roams the British countryside, visiting sites of significance and talking to people from all walks of life about the relevance, or lack thereof, of the monarchy.
What he finds is a nation with decidedly divided opinions; not many Britons seem neutral on the "whither the Windsors?" question.
Curtin also takes a close look at personal histories of the princes who might be king -- Charles, raised during a generation that still held the royals in high esteem, and William and Harry, products of the tabloid-crazed era in which their mother paid the ultimate price for fame.
Much time is devoted to "the Lady Diana factor," which is responsible for many Brits' negative feelings about Prince Charles -- they feel he treated her shabbily, in their marriage, in its aftermath, and even after her death, when his marriage to Camilla Parker Bowles only served, for some, as a reminder of misdeeds past.
In the end, Curtin asserts, the outcome of the "Who's next?" question could be largely academic as the monarchy limps toward its end.
"After Queen Elizabeth, I suspect that Prince Charles will eventually struggle to the throne," says human-rights activist Peter Tatchell, "but with greatly diminished public support. And then, when he goes, I think it will be the end. He will be Charles the Last."
Now, there's a statement that will spark a debate that extends far beyond the walls of Oxford...
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 12, 2009 D5
- Rate this

-
-
We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.
You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.
Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.
The comment period for this story has ended.
Ads by Google
- Back to Top
- Return to TV
-
CON >< CUSSIONS
Examining hockey head injuries
-
Random Acts of Kindness
Your encounters with goodness
-
Open Secrets
Red River students mine government data banks
-
Ski with WFP
Register here to ski Asessippi with the Winnipeg Free Press
-
Miss Lonelyhearts
Maureen Scurfield offers life advice
Poll
Most Popular
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Professional, helpful, brave
- Would-be Regina car thieves steal vehicle with owner clinging to hood
- He can escape her verbal abuse
- Ohio woman: US doctor botched breast surgery, used wrong implants
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- Frenchwoman on trial accused of killing 6 of her newborns, hiding corpses
- Teenage girl charged in man's death
- Mayor Katz to visit 'homeless' students
- Hometown basks in hero's glow
- Crusader up for Nobel Prize
- From poster couple to problem couple
- Manitoban wheelchair-user badly beaten in Australia
- Six-year-old leads RCMP to attacker
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- Musician's mother dies
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Greyhound apologizes for stranding passengers
- Olympic-sized hypocrisy
- Crusader up for Nobel Prize
- Not wrong, just illegal
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- Students could be punished
- Is this the worst Olympics ever?
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
- Missing Stonewall man found dead
- Mr. Matas a worthy nominee
- What should happen to two teachers who performed a sexually suggestive dance routine in front of students?
- Liberals say cutting MP mailings would save $10 million a year
- He can escape her verbal abuse
- CNIB workers hit the picket line
- Mayor Katz to visit 'homeless' students
- Charges considered in machete attack
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Would-be Regina car thieves steal vehicle with owner clinging to hood
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- If you don't feel like sharing, get your own candy bar miss lonelyhearts
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- Greyhound apologizes for stranding passengers
- Aboriginal elders removed from court on Hydro hearing
- You can't keep grandpa from seeing baby despite childish family dynamics
- Liberals say cutting MP mailings would save $10 million a year
- Explore drug aids before giving up sex
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Lesbian teen faces classmates after school cancels dance over her request to bring girlfriend
- No more quick fixes: mayor
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- He can escape her verbal abuse
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- MP may regret taking aim at Christian youth centre: Mayor Katz
- Students could be punished
- Police shoot and kill suspect
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
- More ominous issue underlies Youth for Christ flap
- Wielding a weapon costs a life
- Mounties hook ice-fishers for open beer
- Youth centre sparks dispute
- Canadian women's hockey team stunned by reaction to post-gold party
- It's the Sharks vs. the Jets in a jazzy rumble
- Professional, helpful, brave
- Hometown basks in hero's glow
- A degree of faith
- Duffers unite: driving range opens
- Winning skiers have special edge
- Building where people live
- letters March 15
- Mexican drug wars rage on
- Black Eyed Peas tickets on sale Saturday
- Socialism for the rich is Tory way
- Manitoban wheelchair-user badly beaten in Australia
- Indian Act changing to treat descendants equitably
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- It's the Sharks vs. the Jets in a jazzy rumble
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Iceland airline bullish about Winnipeg
- Older women invading Facebook
- Former prosecutor ambushed on CBC
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- Text of Shane Koyczan's opening ceremonies poem, "We Are More"
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- Olympic-sized hypocrisy
- Cabela's to open across Canada
- Oprah's on, and so is our Jon!
- Not wrong, just illegal
- Online drug pioneer tumbles
- Mounties hook ice-fishers for open beer
- No listings for buyers flooding the housing market
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
PREVIOUS

0 Comments