Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 10/1/2013 8:41 PM
She was hauled away in handcuffs by heavily armed officers who stormed into her home — then released without charge.
But a Winnipeg woman has only herself to blame for the incident that's now the focus of a rare civil jury case, police lawyers said.
"The taxpayers of Winnipeg should not be paying for the decisions she’s made," Denise Pambrun said Tuesday in delivering her closing arguments.
Gerilyn Riedle, 52, is suing police for damages, claiming she’s the victim of a malicious arrest, false imprisonment and defamation of character. Her lawyer, John Michaels, says police actions were "over the top" in the 2009 incident.
Jurors are expected to begin deliberations Wednesday.
Police had obtained a search warrant for Riedle’s home on the belief her 19-year-old son was selling drugs. A magistrate authorized them to do a "dynamic" entry, which included setting off a flash bomb, breaking down the door and arresting everyone inside.
That included Riedle, who claims she was so humiliated by the ordeal that she had to quickly sell her home at less than market value to get out of the neighbourhood.
But police lawyers said Tuesday the evidence is clear that Riedle should have known her son had drugs in the home.
Police found paraphernalia sitting on the dining room table, the interior smelled of marijuana and officers observed a drug deal go down in their driveway just hours before the raid.
"Maybe she just looked the other way in the face of some facts she didn’t want to see," Pambrun told jurors. "She chose to ignore it. And when she came face to face with the consequences of that decision, she ran (by selling her home). It’s not what the police did to her that made her run. It’s the consequences of her decision."
Riedle’s son ultimately took responsibility for the 18 grams of marijuana and other paraphernalia found in his bedroom.
Officers involved in the incident testified last week, telling jurors what happened to Riedle is an unfortunate necessity of the job and sometimes innocent people will get caught in their web.
They said all proper procedures were followed and officers acted as prescribed by both the law and their extensive training. Police claim these types of tactics are needed during drug investigations because they often encounter members of organized crime, weapons and offenders who will do almost anything to escape arrest.
Pambrun said Tuesday that Riedle had failed to show any other method that could have been used on that night.
"You can’t just come in here and say ‘I don’t think the police should do it this way.’ You have to bring some evidence," she said. "This is not Dr. Oz. We’re not here to talk about how we feel. We’re here to talk about evidence."
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Ethics commissioner dismisses counter-complaint Vic Toews made against Pat Martin
Manitoba's CFS to stop housing kids in hotels in June
Racist Facebook page part of smear campaign against Winnipeg woman
City to use smoke bombs to control gopher population
Manitoba Hydro has spent $31 million on Conawapa station since report calling for spending to stop
Sentencing today for driver in crash that killed two students
Mayor Bowman target of online post inciting people to attack him; police examining situation
Police seek girl, 13, missing a month
Agricultural fertilizing can begin early: province
Police investigate assault on Hargrave
Mining firm, enviros in defamation court fight
Avalanche warning out for Rockies, parts of B.C.
Manitoba premier apologizes to First Nation
Warm today, but frigid Thursday
Rally against Bill C-51 to be held in Osborne Village
Obama: Canadian oil 'extraordinarily dirty'
Alberta, N.W.T. sign deal on Mackenzie River
Cars in CN train derail in southern Manitoba
Obama again whips up recipe for healthy kids
Grieving dad awaits report on deaths
Councillor to seek Conservative nod
If this were a joke, it would be funny
Compassion in the courtroom
Drawing aboriginal voters to polls
Lifting veil off attitudes about niqab, hijab
No penalty for bringing supper into Canada
Liberals set to roll out federal-election ads
Feds trample on Downs racing
We pledge to not blab to the media
Pal spins a squirrelly story
Annual Litter Index reveals Winnipeg's messiest streets
U of M workers brace for more job cuts
Tax breaks to cost public $7.7B per year: report
Winnipeg students to compete in U.S. ethics bowl