Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 10/17/2012 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
HOSPITAL administrators are losing patience with Winnipeg doctors, nurses and health-care aides who repeatedly fail to wash their hands before caring for patients.
According to statistics the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority released Tuesday, the situation is generally getting worse, despite a three-year effort to prod health workers to improve their hand-cleaning.
An audit of city hospitals conducted over the spring and summer found several had lower compliance rates than last year or showed marginal improvement.
"This does not reflect well on us as a system, as health-care providers or as professionals," WRHA president Arlene Wilgosh said in releasing the figures during Bug Day, a medical conference devoted to infectious diseases, public health and infection prevention and control.
The latest handwashing audit revealed about 50 per cent of the time, staff at city hospitals are not washing their hands when they should — before and after touching a patient.
Generally, nurses and health-care aides washed their hands more frequently than doctors — but still not nearly as frequently as they should. Health-care aides and nurses at St. Boniface General Hospital had the best compliance rates in the city, at 69 and 68 per cent respectively.
But doctors at St. B were the least likely among hospital MDs to clean their hands when required — just 17 per cent of the time, Wilgosh said, a figure that drew gasps and a shocked buzz Tuesday at a Health Sciences Centre lecture theatre jammed with doctors, nurses and students.
Wilgosh said the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority plans to publish the results of future handwashing audits on its website, beginning in the new year, to inform the public — and perhaps to shame staff into improving its record. It will also encourage patients to remind caregivers to clean their hands. The WRHA is seeking an overall compliance rate of 90 per cent.
John Embil, the health authority’s director of infection prevention and control, said administrators have been hesitant to discipline staff for failing to wash their hands when required. But that may change if education and hounding don’t work.
"At some point the regional leadership is going to have to say, ‘Enough is enough. And if you don’t comply, these are the consequences,’ " Embil said Tuesday.
"We’ve talked this to death and at some point we need to take some sort of aggressive action."
Wilgosh said the people who conducted the audit were in full view of hospital workers, sporting clipboards on which they recorded whether or not staff washed their hands or used sanitizers. They also explained to staff what they were recording.
Wilgosh noted the poor results come at a time when hospitals across Canada are spending tens of millions of dollars battling the spread of infection and socalled superbugs within their institutions — money that could be spent instead on patient treatment if sanitation efforts were improved.
The health authority boss was also "a little distressed" by stats that showed medical staff were much more likely to clean their hands after seeing a patient than before. At the Victoria General Hospital, for instance, 28 per cent of staff cleaned their hands beforehand while 69 per cent did so afterwards. At Seven Oaks, 35 per cent cleaned up beforehand and 75 per cent did so afterwards.
"What these numbers show is that we’re more concerned about taking care of ourselves than we are in taking care of patients," Wilgosh lamented.
Conservative health critic Cameron Friesen called the poor handwashing rates a safety issue. He said his party is discouraged that the situation is not improving. "Surely this is a simple fix and the health minister could have tackled this," Friesen said.
Health Minister Theresa Oswald, attending the kickoff for the province’s annual flu shot campaign Tuesday, said if anyone needs lessons on handwashing, they should ask their kids. "Any adult that wants a lesson in handwashing... should drop in at their local daycare," Oswald said in response to the study.
Meanwhile, a Queen’s University medical professor attending the Winnipeg conference said Ontario has made great strides in recent years in getting hospital workers to clean their hands through sheer persistence — frequent reminders and regular audits that are posted online and in hospital wards.
— with file from Alexandra Paul
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 17, 2012 A6
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Officer under investigation for sexual harassment sues police force, city
Kurds rally in support of besieged countrymen in Syria
Judge's inquiry panel to begin Nov. 24
HSC sets aside 10 isolation rooms to deal with Ebola
No rules stop school trustee incumbents from using official email for campaigns
Murder trial begins for man accused of dismembering co-worker
Missing teen last seen in Elmwood
Winnipeggers resign themselves to new community mailboxes
Six-week-old infant dies at Red Sucker Lake First Nation
Winnipeg group trying to sponsor three Syrian refugee families to come to Canada
Five-year old boy dies after being struck by vehicle at St. Theresa Point First Nation
Six facing charges after police find guns, drugs at house
Two-vehicle crash on Trans-Canada Highway near Oak Lake covers lane with debris
Trustees elected in Division scolaire franco-manitobaine
Advance poll turnout continues to increase, sets record this year
Manitoba Hydro invites questions online on its bid to control Lake Winnipeg levels
Missing seven-year-old girl safely located
Police looking for man suspected of sexual assault at Fort and Graham bus shelter
Police arrest man in alleged sexual assault on transit bus
Conference Board forecast says Winnipeg economy slowed this year but will rebound
Pickups scheduled for KE students' belongings after fire
Bowman, Judy W-L neck and neck, poll shows
Harry Potter sport works its magic in Winnipeg
Above-normal temps in store this week
Loved ones gather to celebrate life of music educator
St. Norbert race highly competitive
Boy hit by taxi
Front-runners for mayor firing flurry of campaign promises
Only two more sleeps till election day
A search for the visionary mayor
More aboriginal candidates on campaign trail
Sharing the hip-hop scene with the city